Not sure that drawing parallels between an Irish Catholic university's choice of mascot, and a racial slur that has, for generations, been used to devalue a people that our own constitution deemed less than human is helping your case here.
The history of our nation is littered with laws--actual policy--designed to keep black americans from gaining access to the same opportunities as their white counterparts. That's not the context that "Fighting Irish" exists in. It is the context the "racial slurs" you're trivializing exist in.
But keep on fighting the good fight. 300 years of trying to cripple the black man in America, and now less than 70 years from Jim Crow it's unacceptable if he walks with a limp.
My point in bringing a caricature of an Irish person into this discussion and relating it to your personal attack, is that there is a distinction between generically insulting someone and personally attacking someone.
From my general life experience, black culture's collective response to generic insults dwarf any response by a white culture's collective response to generic insults. In other words, whites just aren't interested in hunger striking because some other white guy got called a name that could be applied to all white guys of the same group. I would speculate that you could spray paint a swastika on every dorm room door at NYU and not a Jew among them would venture to hunger strike for the University President's dismissal.
Interestingly enough, consider your personal attack of me:
If the guy in the truck had said, "Every time you speak in class, the value of my degree declines", would the outcome be the same? If he was speaking to a group of blacks, my personal opinion is yes, the outcome is the same. If he was speaking to a group of jewish kids, my personal opinion is no.
Though not its intent by the guy in the truck, I would speculate that the blacks in this scenario label this a "racial slur" AND a symbol of oppression. While the jewish kids look around at each other and simply ask, "did you know that guy?"
Last Edited: 11/10/2015 5:52:51 PM by The Situation