Ohio Football Topic
Topic: Brian Smith offered Associate HC/ OC at Charlotte
Page: 3 of 4
mail
person
SBH
12/11/2024 7:14 AM
I was told by a reliable source that Albin signed a week before the MACC - during his visit to Charlotte. If that's true, his willingness to consider a counter offer was all a charade. Perhaps Charlotte told him the offer was a one-time thing he had to sign before leaving town?
Last Edited: 12/11/2024 7:20:04 AM by SBH
mail
person
ohiocatfan1
12/11/2024 7:14 AM
BillyTheCat wrote:expand_more
We’ll find out if he’s a great coach. Because he’s signed up for a Heisman Mode rebuild.

I already don’t care about the drama. We got dumped. Let’s hire the right guy and make this a blip in the continued success of the program.
100%. He's gone. Saw Albin a couple times at Bobcat Club events. He was basically an aloof, arrogant jackass while Coach Boals visited every table and thanked everyone for coming. Good riddance.
Come on, man. Another possibility is that he's just a bad schmoozer, no? I'm perfectly willing to throw Albin under the bus - the one he got off of to save his sick doggie - but he definitely came across as a D-level speaker at the best of times.

You know, "taking your sick dog to the hospital" should replace "TOS to" for future coach opening discussions.
Not being a good schmoozer is one thing but he was an arrogant jerk who basically ignored everyone aside from his buddies. Coach Boals runs circles around him in that department.
As a friend of both, you are a clown.
For giving my take on what I saw happen?
mail
person
Brian Smith (No, not that one)
12/11/2024 7:15 AM
Let it never be said again that women are gossips.

Was Tim Albin down at Seven Flavors? Is it pretty serious?
mail
Andrew Ruck
12/11/2024 7:44 AM
I would not fault Cromer & the university one bit for not finalizing an extension before the Championship game. Finish the current job then we'll talk about sweetening it going forward. Like I said in other threads, my take is he bet against himself for fear the game did not go well and negotiated his destiny before it.
mail
person
L.C.
12/11/2024 8:38 AM
In the end, it's not worth worrying about the "disrespect" question at this point because there are two sides to every story, and we can't get inside their minds, or maybe it was a little of both. Maybe Albin felt disrespected, or maybe Charlotte just made an offer that was just too rich for Ohio to match. Albin was making $700k. In the MAC, Jason Candle has the top salary at $1.1m. What are salaries like in the AAC? The top salaries for 2024 were:
UTSA - Traylor, $2.8m
USF - Golesh, $2.5m
Temple - Drayton $2.5m
E. Carolina - Houston $2.3m
Army - Monken, $2.1m
Tulane - Sunmrall, $2.0m
Memphis - Silverfeild $1.9m
Tulsa - Wilson $1.9m

The median salary was $1.9m a year, so it's perfectly conceivable that Albin may have gotten an offer in that range.

A more pressing questions is, where does Ohio go from here? Should they promote from within, should they opt for something completely different?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2bF-rpJz2CA
Last Edited: 12/11/2024 8:40:58 AM by L.C.
mail
Mike Coleman
12/11/2024 8:42 AM
SBH wrote:expand_more
I was told by a reliable source that Albin signed a week before the MACC - during his visit to Charlotte. If that's true, his willingness to consider a counter offer was all a charade. Perhaps Charlotte told him the offer was a one-time thing he had to sign before leaving town?
Exactly!!!

That's why they won’t answer the question. Watch the press conference…the Charlotte AD let it slip!

The fake negotiations. The dog in the hospital. It was all planned.

What I don't think they planned was the massive win and outpouring of love.

Literally, Tim, you got what you always wanted: the five-year deal, the highest paid coach, a legend in the city, county and university community!

But instead you left your team broken hearted on a bus in the dark in the middle of Ohio on the way back to celebrate what for them was probably the best day of their life.

I get the disrespect, Tim. It’s always been there. And you've always overcome. You won at NAIA when you barely had grass. You won at Nebraska but it wasn't as good as before, you won at Ohio but you're offense wasn't good enough. You innovated the offense and set school records. They said you weren't the right guy to replace Frank and were wrong. They said you’d fail after starting 3-9 then you put together the best three-year run in school history. They said you wouldn't win your bowl game in Myrtle but you crushed them. They said you’d finish in the middle of the pack this year but won the first title in 56 years!

But, stepping back, Albin felt disrespected to be the sixth highest paid coach in the MAC this past season on a contract he signed only one season prior—enough was enough—so he turned down a chance to be the highest paid coach in the MAC to be the sixth highest paid coach in the AAC at the same price. Same gator, different swamp.
mail
M.D.W.S.T
12/11/2024 9:07 AM
Bobcat Love wrote:expand_more
Ok, so I'm am believing 100% in how these negotiations happened, but explain to me like I’m five.

Albin, at some point, entered into negotiations and eventually was offered what, or close to, what he asked for prior to the title game. Yet, this is called disrespectful and late.

The question is: At what point would the final offer have not been disrespectful? One day earlier? A week? A month?

Just my opinion, but as the season went along and the team was getting hot…like it tended to do under Albin when it was healthy, I think that was the time to make contact. Say the Toledo game. Definitely Ball State.

Anyway, was the beginning of negotiations disrespectful, the end, or just the entire process?
This is stupid. Were 6 weeks removed from an absolute shitburger at Miami and 8 weeks removed from the entire defense literally quitting at Kentucky. If Albin thought he deserved a huge raise before the MAC Championship game, he's bonkers.
Hell has officially frozen over.

I agree with this small point.

I'm curious when people thought he was worth a $1M+ extension? Mid-season? When we were 4-3? In the off-chance he was quietly interviewing behind our back before the CHAMPIONSHIP GAME?

An extension was coming. Because he won. And he earned it. But now, bc its thought to be "too late", people are enraged. Go re-read the thread about his extension. 95% of people were PISSED about it.

There are about 9 of these threads now, but they re-negotiated his salary in 2023. Making him the 3rd highest paid coach. Are they supposed to negotiate every single time a new coach gets hired and makes more? This isn't the NFL. We don't have millions sitting around in a slush fund to pay coaches every few months.

We all agree that today, on 12/11/2024 he was worth more than the 6th he was making - but $800K with bonuses and such is no paltry sum. People act like he was making $350K and got a tent for housing.

Pay Brian. Let's put this whole thing to bed, because I'm tired of crying about it. He left. Most of us thought he was going to leave. Because he left in a shitty way, to what most of us agree to be a lateral-at-best move everyone is pissed. I get it. But we're gonna be fine. We're gonna be fine.
mail
Mike Coleman
12/11/2024 9:11 AM
M.D.W.S.T wrote:expand_more
Ok, so I'm am believing 100% in how these negotiations happened, but explain to me like I’m five.

Albin, at some point, entered into negotiations and eventually was offered what, or close to, what he asked for prior to the title game. Yet, this is called disrespectful and late.

The question is: At what point would the final offer have not been disrespectful? One day earlier? A week? A month?

Just my opinion, but as the season went along and the team was getting hot…like it tended to do under Albin when it was healthy, I think that was the time to make contact. Say the Toledo game. Definitely Ball State.

Anyway, was the beginning of negotiations disrespectful, the end, or just the entire process?
This is stupid. Were 6 weeks removed from an absolute shitburger at Miami and 8 weeks removed from the entire defense literally quitting at Kentucky. If Albin thought he deserved a huge raise before the MAC Championship game, he's bonkers.
Hell has officially frozen over.

I agree with this small point.

I'm curious when people thought he was worth a $1M+ extension? Mid-season? When we were 4-3? In the off-chance he was quietly interviewing behind our back before the CHAMPIONSHIP GAME?

An extension was coming. Because he won. And he earned it. But now, bc its thought to be "too late", people are enraged. Go re-read the thread about his extension. 95% of people were PISSED about it.

There are about 9 of these threads now, but they re-negotiated his salary in 2023. Making him the 3rd highest paid coach. Are they supposed to negotiate every single time a new coach gets hired and makes more? This isn't the NFL. We don't have millions sitting around in a slush fund to pay coaches every few months.

We all agree that today, on 12/11/2024 he was worth more than the 6th he was making - but $800K with bonuses and such is no paltry sum. People act like he was making $350K and got a tent for housing.

Pay Brian. Let's put this whole thing to bed, because I'm tired of crying about it. He left. Most of us thought he was going to leave. Because he left in a shitty way, to what most of us agree to be a lateral-at-best move everyone is pissed. I get it. But we're gonna be fine. We're gonna be fine.
Bingo! You are all getting it. Albin wasn't mad he got a four-year deal, he was mad he didn't get a one-year deal—when that would have favored him! Times changed when Buffalo and WMU paid their guys that much, but a renegotiation every year?
mail
person
Bobcat1996
12/11/2024 1:41 PM
"As for Albin's first contract, it was a four year contract, but he could be terminated after two years with no penalty. Thus, in reality it was a two year contract, with an option to extend to four. Could Ohio get some coach from outside to move to Ohio on a contract that could be terminated with no buyout after two years? If an outside coach wouldn't take a 2 year deal, why should Smith? If he takes it, and isn't renewed, he may never get another head coaching offer. If he goes to Charlotte, he can expect Albin to retire in a few years, and for him to become the successor there, with a better deal than two years."

Exactly correct LC, especially the part about Albin's first contract. It could be terminated after two years with zero penalty. She didn't want him to be hired in the first place. Just one of many ways the administration showed Coach Albin no respect.
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
12/11/2024 1:48 PM
Bobcat1996 wrote:expand_more
"As for Albin's first contract, it was a four year contract, but he could be terminated after two years with no penalty. Thus, in reality it was a two year contract, with an option to extend to four. Could Ohio get some coach from outside to move to Ohio on a contract that could be terminated with no buyout after two years? If an outside coach wouldn't take a 2 year deal, why should Smith? If he takes it, and isn't renewed, he may never get another head coaching offer. If he goes to Charlotte, he can expect Albin to retire in a few years, and for him to become the successor there, with a better deal than two years."

Exactly correct LC, especially the part about Albin's first contract. It could be terminated after two years with zero penalty. She didn't want him to be hired in the first place. Just one of many ways the administration showed Coach Albin no respect.
The person who started the "Fire Cromer" thread wanted Cromer fired because that contract was too generous. He thought Cromer had been "bamboozled" because two years was too much to guarantee, and that we should have only hired Albin in an interim capacity.

It's the height of hypocrisy to now look back at that and say Cromer's initial handling didn't show enough respect to Albin. If that's the root of why Albin may be feeling disrespected, than listening to rpbobcat would have made it substantially worse.
Last Edited: 12/11/2024 2:30:28 PM by Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
mail
OhioCatFan
12/11/2024 1:52 PM
Mike Coleman wrote:expand_more
I was told by a reliable source that Albin signed a week before the MACC - during his visit to Charlotte. If that's true, his willingness to consider a counter offer was all a charade. Perhaps Charlotte told him the offer was a one-time thing he had to sign before leaving town?
Exactly!!!

That's why they won’t answer the question. Watch the press conference…the Charlotte AD let it slip!

The fake negotiations. The dog in the hospital. It was all planned.

What I don't think they planned was the massive win and outpouring of love.

Literally, Tim, you got what you always wanted: the five-year deal, the highest paid coach, a legend in the city, county and university community!

But instead you left your team broken hearted on a bus in the dark in the middle of Ohio on the way back to celebrate what for them was probably the best day of their life.

I get the disrespect, Tim. It’s always been there. And you've always overcome. You won at NAIA when you barely had grass. You won at Nebraska but it wasn't as good as before, you won at Ohio but you're offense wasn't good enough. You innovated the offense and set school records. They said you weren't the right guy to replace Frank and were wrong. They said you’d fail after starting 3-9 then you put together the best three-year run in school history. They said you wouldn't win your bowl game in Myrtle but you crushed them. They said you’d finish in the middle of the pack this year but won the first title in 56 years!

But, stepping back, Albin felt disrespected to be the sixth highest paid coach in the MAC this past season on a contract he signed only one season prior—enough was enough—so he turned down a chance to be the highest paid coach in the MAC to be the sixth highest paid coach in the AAC at the same price. Same gator, different swamp.
Best summary of the situation, at least what we know of it, to date. Good job, Mike!
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
12/11/2024 1:54 PM
OhioCatFan wrote:expand_more
I was told by a reliable source that Albin signed a week before the MACC - during his visit to Charlotte. If that's true, his willingness to consider a counter offer was all a charade. Perhaps Charlotte told him the offer was a one-time thing he had to sign before leaving town?
Exactly!!!

That's why they won’t answer the question. Watch the press conference…the Charlotte AD let it slip!

The fake negotiations. The dog in the hospital. It was all planned.

What I don't think they planned was the massive win and outpouring of love.

Literally, Tim, you got what you always wanted: the five-year deal, the highest paid coach, a legend in the city, county and university community!

But instead you left your team broken hearted on a bus in the dark in the middle of Ohio on the way back to celebrate what for them was probably the best day of their life.

I get the disrespect, Tim. It’s always been there. And you've always overcome. You won at NAIA when you barely had grass. You won at Nebraska but it wasn't as good as before, you won at Ohio but you're offense wasn't good enough. You innovated the offense and set school records. They said you weren't the right guy to replace Frank and were wrong. They said you’d fail after starting 3-9 then you put together the best three-year run in school history. They said you wouldn't win your bowl game in Myrtle but you crushed them. They said you’d finish in the middle of the pack this year but won the first title in 56 years!

But, stepping back, Albin felt disrespected to be the sixth highest paid coach in the MAC this past season on a contract he signed only one season prior—enough was enough—so he turned down a chance to be the highest paid coach in the MAC to be the sixth highest paid coach in the AAC at the same price. Same gator, different swamp.
Best summary of the situation, at least what we know of it, to date. Good job, Mike!
Mike is making the opposite point you are, OCF.
mail
OhioCatFan
12/11/2024 1:59 PM
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame wrote:expand_more
I was told by a reliable source that Albin signed a week before the MACC - during his visit to Charlotte. If that's true, his willingness to consider a counter offer was all a charade. Perhaps Charlotte told him the offer was a one-time thing he had to sign before leaving town?
Exactly!!!

That's why they won’t answer the question. Watch the press conference…the Charlotte AD let it slip!

The fake negotiations. The dog in the hospital. It was all planned.

What I don't think they planned was the massive win and outpouring of love.

Literally, Tim, you got what you always wanted: the five-year deal, the highest paid coach, a legend in the city, county and university community!

But instead you left your team broken hearted on a bus in the dark in the middle of Ohio on the way back to celebrate what for them was probably the best day of their life.

I get the disrespect, Tim. It’s always been there. And you've always overcome. You won at NAIA when you barely had grass. You won at Nebraska but it wasn't as good as before, you won at Ohio but you're offense wasn't good enough. You innovated the offense and set school records. They said you weren't the right guy to replace Frank and were wrong. They said you’d fail after starting 3-9 then you put together the best three-year run in school history. They said you wouldn't win your bowl game in Myrtle but you crushed them. They said you’d finish in the middle of the pack this year but won the first title in 56 years!

But, stepping back, Albin felt disrespected to be the sixth highest paid coach in the MAC this past season on a contract he signed only one season prior—enough was enough—so he turned down a chance to be the highest paid coach in the MAC to be the sixth highest paid coach in the AAC at the same price. Same gator, different swamp.
Best summary of the situation, at least what we know of it, to date. Good job, Mike!
Mike is making the opposite point you are, OCF.
So, please remind me, what point was I making?

[And, please remember that this situation is complex enough that one can have some inconsistent and contradictory thoughts about it.]
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
12/11/2024 2:23 PM
OhioCatFan wrote:expand_more
So, please remind me, what point was I making?

[And, please remember that this situation is complex enough that one can have some inconsistent and contradictory thoughts about it.]
Your point seems to be that Cromer is the "likely culprit."

And trust me, I know that you will constantly contradict yourself.
mail
OhioCatFan
12/11/2024 2:59 PM
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame wrote:expand_more
So, please remind me, what point was I making?

[And, please remember that this situation is complex enough that one can have some inconsistent and contradictory thoughts about it.]
Your point seems to be that Cromer is the "likely culprit."

And trust me, I know that you will constantly contradict yourself.
Though written from a different perspective, that of Tim, I don't think Mike actually addressed why Tim felt disrespected -- just that he did.

Mike said: "But, stepping back, Albin felt disrespected to be the sixth highest paid coach in the MAC this past season on a contract he signed only one season prior—enough was enough—so he turned down a chance to be the highest paid coach in the MAC to be the sixth highest paid coach in the AAC at the same price. Same gator, different swamp."

So, why was he offered this less than stellar contract a year ago? Was it his fault entirely? Was JC a "likely culprit" in what turned into this mess? I don't think liking Mike's rendition means that I have to disavow my previous comments. Yes, his emphasis was different, but what he said did not actually address directly some of the other issues at play. Subtle nuances don't seem to be your specialty.
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
12/11/2024 3:14 PM
OhioCatFan wrote:expand_more
So, please remind me, what point was I making?

[And, please remember that this situation is complex enough that one can have some inconsistent and contradictory thoughts about it.]
Your point seems to be that Cromer is the "likely culprit."

And trust me, I know that you will constantly contradict yourself.
Though written from a different perspective, that of Tim, I don't think Mike actually addressed why Tim felt disrespected -- just that he did.

Mike said: "But, stepping back, Albin felt disrespected to be the sixth highest paid coach in the MAC this past season on a contract he signed only one season prior—enough was enough—so he turned down a chance to be the highest paid coach in the MAC to be the sixth highest paid coach in the AAC at the same price. Same gator, different swamp."

So, why was he offered this less than stellar contract a year ago? Was it his fault entirely? Was JC a "likely culprit" in what turned into this mess? I don't think liking Mike's rendition means that I have to disavow my previous comments. Yes, his emphasis was different, but what he said did not actually address directly some of the other issues at play. Subtle nuances don't seem to be your specialty.
Okay, dude. I've never interacted with someone who uses so many words to say absolutely nothing. Don't your balls hurt straddling the fence all the time?


Are we now deciding that last year's extension was "less than stellar" (by the way, he was the third highest paid coach last year)? Here's what everybody thought when it was signed: https://www.bobcatattack.com/messageboard/topic.asp?FromP...

Don't see many people predicting it was the slap in the face that would cause him to bail a year later.
Last Edited: 12/11/2024 3:29:59 PM by Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
mail
person
Bobcat Love
12/11/2024 3:45 PM
Andrew Ruck wrote:expand_more
I would not fault Cromer & the university one bit for not finalizing an extension before the Championship game. Finish the current job then we'll talk about sweetening it going forward. Like I said in other threads, my take is he bet against himself for fear the game did not go well and negotiated his destiny before it.
+1. This is the correct answer. Can we just move on?

I've already talked to Kirby Smart. He said "Mr. LOVE, because of my resepect for you, 80 is not out of the question next September. Go Bobcats."
mail
person
Cleveburg Bri
12/11/2024 4:38 PM
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame wrote:expand_more
So, please remind me, what point was I making?

[And, please remember that this situation is complex enough that one can have some inconsistent and contradictory thoughts about it.]
Your point seems to be that Cromer is the "likely culprit."

And trust me, I know that you will constantly contradict yourself.
I'd like to propose an analogy. A producer wants to hire a temperamental star for a film. The star flakes out at the last minute and jets off to St Barts, killing the production. One could easily make the argument that the star is "to blame" because they're a flake. I propose that the producer damn well knows the star is a flake. Or should. Handling the egos of man-children is a key component of working in sports management, or entertainment - actually they're both entertainment so the distinction is irrelevant. I'd actually argue handling difficult overpaid personalities is the key component. Now, I'm not arguing Julie Cromer is "to blame". I haven't a clue. I wouldn't be even a bit surprised if both Albin and Cromer messed up to one degree or another. Maybe Albin thought a bit too highly of himself. But maybe Cromer should have anticipated that. Thank you, I'll take my answer off the air.
Last Edited: 12/11/2024 4:39:36 PM by Cleveburg Bri
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
12/11/2024 5:07 PM
Cleveburg Bri wrote:expand_more
So, please remind me, what point was I making?

[And, please remember that this situation is complex enough that one can have some inconsistent and contradictory thoughts about it.]
Your point seems to be that Cromer is the "likely culprit."

And trust me, I know that you will constantly contradict yourself.
I'd like to propose an analogy. A producer wants to hire a temperamental star for a film. The star flakes out at the last minute and jets off to St Barts, killing the production. One could easily make the argument that the star is "to blame" because they're a flake. I propose that the producer damn well knows the star is a flake. Or should. Handling the egos of man-children is a key component of working in sports management, or entertainment - actually they're both entertainment so the distinction is irrelevant. I'd actually argue handling difficult overpaid personalities is the key component. Now, I'm not arguing Julie Cromer is "to blame". I haven't a clue. I wouldn't be even a bit surprised if both Albin and Cromer messed up to one degree or another. Maybe Albin thought a bit too highly of himself. But maybe Cromer should have anticipated that. Thank you, I'll take my answer off the air.
Maybe. I think you're not far off.

My back of the envelope math is that Albin's name started popping up in rumors (Rice, Purdue, Charlotte, etc) and he tried to use that as leverage. But college sports are a small world, and Cromer knew Albin was choice 11 at Purdue, not in the running at Rice, and that Charlotte is a terrible job. She said some version of "we just renegotiated your deal 11 months ago, but if you think the market has changed, we can't stop you from interviewing". But the only market was Charlotte, and they made an offer. Albin took it back to OU, who needed time to get approval. In the meantime, Charlotte -- not wanting to lose out on choice number 2 if Albin said no -- told Albin his offer was exploding and that they wouldn't wait until after the MACC.

Behind door 1 was a million dollars a year. Behind door 2 was a potential raise, but of an uncertain amount. He was one year removed from negotiating with OU, and they were likely very transparent about budget and the administrations appetite for football salaries. So he signed with Charlotte and took the sure thing. He probably figured until he showed up in North Carolina, he could back out if needed. But he's not very savvy, and Charlotte leaked the deal post Championship to force his hand and make it harder to accept a counter.

And everything else -- his love of Athens, his terrible treatment at the hands of Julie Cromer, his poor, poor dog -- is just nonsense fan narrative to make themselves feel better about what was a purely rational choice.
Last Edited: 12/11/2024 5:19:09 PM by Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
mail
person
GoCats105
12/11/2024 5:24 PM
Andrew Ruck wrote:expand_more
I would not fault Cromer & the university one bit for not finalizing an extension before the Championship game. Finish the current job then we'll talk about sweetening it going forward. Like I said in other threads, my take is he bet against himself for fear the game did not go well and negotiated his destiny before it.
This +1000
mail
Real49er
12/11/2024 7:10 PM
Quote:expand_more
Cromer knew Albin was choice 11 at Purdue, not in the running at Rice, and that Charlotte is a terrible job. [/QUOTE]I think it would help you folks better dissect this situation by accurately grasping how the Charlotte job was viewed. It isn't "terrible". It's not even bad. It's mediocre at worst. (I'm not singling out this quote or poster. I've seen this sentiment numerous times.)

Chris Vannini's Charlotte job report card grade: C
https://x.com/ChrisVannini/status/1859253172230848605
"C" is in the middle, mediocre at worst. And that's partly because our 12-year old program hasn't been winning. That can change with good coaching.

The opening at Charlotte, following the end of the dreadful Biff Poggi experience, remains an attractive post, coaches and sources tell FootballScoop.

https://footballscoop.com/news/what-were-hearing-coaching...
"attractive" per coaches.

The Charlotte job is regarded as one of the best in the Group of 5. The city of Charlotte annually ranks among the fastest-growing in America, and the program is young enough that a successful coach can put his fingerprints on the program in a way that is not possible at other institutions.

https://footballscoop.com/news/update-at-charlotte
"one of the best in [G5]"

This very long article ranks the open jobs. Charlotte is ranked 11 out of 24. That's above half. And since Rice was mentioned, Rice ranks 16. Coincidentally, the lowest ranked job is UMass, who is joining your conference in 2025.
[QUOTE=AthlonSports.com]Pros: Charlotte is a job with intriguing potential. The state of North Carolina is growing in population, and the high school ranks produce plenty of talent to build a solid class every year. This program wants to be a factor in the AAC and plans to upgrade the stadium and facilities to be a major factor in the future. Charlotte also has one of the bigger football operating budgets in the American Athletic Conference. The willingness to win is there, and the talent to build a solid program isn't far away.

Cons: Charlotte started playing football in 2013. It's a young program with little tradition and doesn't have a track record of success. Since moving to the FBS level in '15, the 49ers have only one winning season ('19).

https://athlonsports.com/college-football/ranking-college...
Again, the lone con is youth and lack of winning. Who thinks a new program is going to start out winning?

There was another graphic I couldn't find, but it had the Charlotte job ranked in the middle of open jobs.

Compared to OU job:
- Higher pay
- More NIL (10x more possibly)
- Chance to be the coach casting a shadow rather than be in the shadow of a past coach
- Better conference (not my opinion, based on online sources)
- Big city
- Better weather (depends on preference, but regularly claimed)

Albin's first game with Charlotte will be in an NFL stadium in Charlotte. Maybe he doesn't care about it, but it's certainly a recruitment tool.

If your view of how much of an "avoidable catastrophe" this is includes the perception that Charlotte is "a bad job", your analysis will be flawed, and it will bring you undue frustration.
Last Edited: 12/11/2024 9:18:53 PM by Real49er
mail
greencat
12/11/2024 7:30 PM
Athens Ohio vs Charlotte NC
____________________________

Athens housing costs are 46.6% less expensive than Charlotte housing costs.

Athens has 64% less violent crime than Charlotte.

Athens has 49% less property crime than Charlotte.

The average commute for residents of Athens is 10.6% shorter than it is for residents of Charlotte.

Athens spends 26.8% more per student than Charlotte.

- The Student Teacher Ratio is 7.8% lower in Athens than in Charlotte. (lower means fewer students in each classroom).

- Athens had 5.7% more residents who had graduated High School compared to Charlotte

Average Rent Charlotte: $1,850
Athens: $1,030


Source: Best places.net
mail
M.D.W.S.T
12/11/2024 7:46 PM
Real49er wrote:expand_more
Compared to OU job:
- More NIL (10x more possibly)
- Chance to be the shadow rather than be in the shadow of
Delusion.

But it does make me smile.

UNCC is hardly a drop of piss on the sidewalk in North Carolina. I lived in Charlotte for years. Never met a UNCC grad. Not sure they exist. Any pretend NIL, is now headed to UNC.

Hopefully you’re able to find a dummy with checkbook to steal Parker, because your QB1 decided your new coach, and all your points were nonsense.
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
12/11/2024 8:05 PM
Real49er wrote:expand_more
Cromer knew Albin was choice 11 at Purdue, not in the running at Rice, and that Charlotte is a terrible job.
I think it would help you folks better dissect this situation by accurately grasping how the Charlotte job was viewed. It isn't "terrible". It's not even bad. It's mediocre at worst. (I'm not singling out this quote or poster. I've seen this sentiment numerous times.)

Chris Vannini's Charlotte job report card grade: C
https://x.com/ChrisVannini/status/1859253172230848605
"C" is in the middle, mediocre at worst. And that's partly because our 12-year old program hasn't been winning. That can change with good coaching.

The opening at Charlotte, following the end of the dreadful Biff Poggi experience, remains an attractive post, coaches and sources tell FootballScoop.

https://footballscoop.com/news/what-were-hearing-coaching...
"attractive" per coaches.

The Charlotte job is regarded as one of the best in the Group of 5. The city of Charlotte annually ranks among the fastest-growing in America, and the program is young enough that a successful coach can put his fingerprints on the program in a way that is not possible at other institutions.

https://footballscoop.com/news/update-at-charlotte
"one of the best in [G5]"

This very long article ranks the open jobs. Charlotte is ranked 11 out of 24. That's above half. And since Rice was mentioned, Rice ranks 16. Coincidentally, the lowest ranked job is UMass, who is joining your conference in 2025.
Pros: Charlotte is a job with intriguing potential. The state of North Carolina is growing in population, and the high school ranks produce plenty of talent to build a solid class every year. This program wants to be a factor in the AAC and plans to upgrade the stadium and facilities to be a major factor in the future. Charlotte also has one of the bigger football operating budgets in the American Athletic Conference. The willingness to win is there, and the talent to build a solid program isn't far away.

Cons: Charlotte started playing football in 2013. It's a young program with little tradition and doesn't have a track record of success. Since moving to the FBS level in '15, the 49ers have only one winning season ('19).

https://athlonsports.com/college-football/ranking-college...
Again, the lone con is youth and lack of winning. Who thinks a new program is going to start out winning?

There was another graphic I couldn't find, but it had the Charlotte job ranked in the middle of open jobs.

Compared to OU job:
- Higher pay
- More NIL (10x more possibly)
- Chance to be the shadow rather than be in the shadow of anyone
- Better conference (not my opinion, based on online sources)
- Big city
- Better weather (depends on preference, but regularly claimed)

Albin's first game with Charlotte will be in an NFL stadium in Charlotte. Maybe he doesn't care about it, but it's certainly a recruitment tool.

If your view of how much of an "avoidable catastrophe" this is includes the perception that Charlotte is "a bad job", your analysis will be flawed, and it will bring you undue frustration.
I was in Charlotte a few weeks ago. No offense, man, but no University that isn't in the shadow spends that much money to advertise in their own airport. A massive campaign advertising really basic things like "D1 sports". Didn't notice a big ad campaign reminding people that UNC has a basketball team.
mail
Mike Coleman
12/11/2024 8:29 PM
Haha you better get someone to change Wikipedia:

“The basketball team has spent the better part of its history in the shadow of the state's four Atlantic Coast Conference teams. “

Be the shadow. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlotte_49ers_men%27s_b...
Showing Messages: 51 - 75 of 90
MAC News Links



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)