Ohio Football Topic
Topic: What can Ohio do to take legitimate next steps in football?
Page: 3 of 4
mail
person
Robert Fox
12/19/2017 7:07 PM
I think they're trying to balance Mom's weekend and Dad's weekend. Dad's is in the Fall. Mom's is in the Winter/Spring. I agree it would be good to have a football game, but I suspect this is an effort to spread activities over multiple weekends. I suppose the thinking is: Football games will bring traffic already. Let's schedule Dad's weekend to bring in traffic on a non-football weekend, thus make the local merchants including the hoteliers happy, and make some University cash as well.
mail
person
Mark Lembright '85
12/19/2017 7:30 PM
Alan Swank wrote:expand_more
My question that I would ask, not just about Ohio, but to all the MAC, and many other G5 schools is this:

How much longer to they want to continue to try to play the arms race with increasing spending? I'd say at some point in the future, coaching salaries and football spending has to peak, and then start to decline. But at what point, if we're not already there, is it worth it to continue to try to keep up with the P5 schools in spending?

This past weekend, I watched the FCS semi's with my dad, and also the DII final. It led me to wonder how those schools' spending differs from MAC Schools? Is there a continued benefit for the MAC, etc., for being FBS?

OHIO is the biggest spender in MBB budget in the MAC, and has the best facility.

OHIO is in the 50th percentile in FB spend in the MAC, and with many of the facilities being worse than their peers.

Is football spending really a problem when we are significantly outspent by some of the programs in the G5 with whom many here believe should be able to compete?

A program like Boise spends more than double what OHIO spends, and any investments made at OHIO in the last five to seven years to elevate the program to a modest level (IPF/new locker room) have been done so 100% at donor expense, not raising student fees to pay for them.
Not true. $1.2 million in student fees helped pay for the multi-purpoe facility.

https://www.ohio.edu/studentaffairs/planning/fieldhouse.cfm

And the general student body gets to use the facility more than 10% of its open hours, so my point stands, donations paid for 100% of the ICA benefit. That was the deal that was stuck to finalize the project. https://twitter.com/OU_WalterFH Check the twitter feed and you see a significant amount of twitter post volume of general student body/ROTC/etc usage of the facility, so I think the student body made out pretty damn well on that deal.
Had two student senate members not "sold out" the student body, donations would not have been enough to build the structure. Lots of lame duck behind the scenes arm twisting. And then we have daily maintenance and upkeep of these buildings which comes out of - you guessed it- the general budget. Don't get me wrong because the indoor multipurpose facility is of great benefit to the student body; the study hall under construction, not so much. So go ahead and "trump" me with your facts.
That being said, no donation seed money (and what the donors and the Sooks gave for the IPF and the Academic Center respectively was much more than seed money) no infrastructure improvements to Ohio’s football program; I think that’s the point of the discussion. Were it not for the Walter family, the Sooks and the other donors, Ohio would be even further behind the 8 ball as far as football’s concerned. And that, I think, says it all.
mail
person
bobcatsquared
12/19/2017 9:28 PM
Alan Swank wrote:expand_more
Throw in the 110 floor show and you have a "World Series of Rock" type atmosphere.
Be careful Alan - while I appreciate your analogy, I'll bet the majority on here are too young to make the connection.
mail
TWT
12/20/2017 7:34 AM
FCS is a theoretical discussion. Ohio State in that large Columbus corporate market with that large student body if it was starting football from scratch in the 90's would be in the AAC today like UCF. There is no conceivable way a university with a situation like Ohio State could be in FCS. Ohio with its 20k enrollment size + 200 year tradition its inconceivable almost that it wouldn't be competing in Division 1 though Athens is small enough for DII or DIII. Then with a football program at a minimum with no tradition its an FCS program with an 8,500 seat stadium but in something like the MVC, CAA or Southern Conference because we would have been around since the beginning of FCS. High level FCS is Ohio's floor. The MAC is the penthouse of mid major football. Midweek TV deal with highlights on Sportscenter afterwards is as much publicity as what we can get. There is no way playing on Saturday to get on sportscenter aside from playing Tennessee early in the season or something. We could be at the high FCS level but why would we want to be? I am pretty sure there are no markets as tiny as Athens in the P5 and definitely not with our corporate support level so that one seems out too.
mail
person
Alan Swank
12/20/2017 10:03 AM
Robert Fox wrote:expand_more
I think they're trying to balance Mom's weekend and Dad's weekend. Dad's is in the Fall. Mom's is in the Winter/Spring. I agree it would be good to have a football game, but I suspect this is an effort to spread activities over multiple weekends. I suppose the thinking is: Football games will bring traffic already. Let's schedule Dad's weekend to bring in traffic on a non-football weekend, thus make the local merchants including the hoteliers happy, and make some University cash as well.
Having three family weekends in the fall in seven weeks with the first one being only three weeks after "drop off" and the last one less than three weeks before Thanksgiving break is packing quite a few visits in a very short period of time hence one of the reasons I think you saw such a small Dads Weekend crowd this year.

When we were on quarters we used to have Dads and Sibs during basketball season and Mom's in late April or early May. As OCF would say, this "fake semester" schedule has goofed up everything.
mail
person
Mark Lembright '85
12/20/2017 10:15 AM
Alan Swank wrote:expand_more
When we were on quarters we used to have Dads and Sibs during basketball season and Mom's in late April or early May. As OCF would say, this "fake semester" schedule has goofed up everything.
AMEN TO THAT!!
mail
person
LynxRufus6
12/20/2017 11:03 AM
Mark Lembright '85 wrote:expand_more
When we were on quarters we used to have Dads and Sibs during basketball season and Mom's in late April or early May. As OCF would say, this "fake semester" schedule has goofed up everything.
AMEN TO THAT!!
MY SEMESTER WAS SO BACKWARDS THIS FALL!!!!

Some profs adjusted their syllabi, most did not. And in return I had exams every other week for all classes and quickly became exhausted because there was no rhythm to my schedule. 2 of 5 classes were finished the week before finals so I essentially had 2 “finals weeks”. I’ve been told the changes were mainly pressed by faculty memebers who wanted their Christmas breaks aligned with the local schools. Unsure as to whether or not that’s accurate, but I can say that I DID NOT appreciate the change.
mail
OhioStunter
12/20/2017 12:23 PM
I enjoyed quarters because I used the break between Thanksgiving and New Year's to get two seasonal jobs (UPS and department store) to help pay tuition.

I've always questioned the switch to semesters and the only answer I've heard was that the Ohio Board of Regents wanted it that way, even though it was never really explained what the advantages for OU were.
mail
person
rpbobcat
12/20/2017 12:27 PM
OhioStunter wrote:expand_more
I enjoyed quarters because I used the break between Thanksgiving and New Year's to get two seasonal jobs (UPS and department store) to help pay tuition.

I've always questioned the switch to semesters and the only answer I've heard was that the Ohio Board of Regents wanted it that way, even though it was never really explained what the advantages for OU were.
I've gone to college under both Quarters and Semesters.

I preferred semesters for the following:

1.Finals twice a year,instead of 3 times.
With quarters,Finals Week came up FAST !

2.Most schools use semesters.
Makes comparing/transferring credit hours easier.

I was at O.U. when the Fall Quarter started at the end of September,ended around Christmas and you got out for the Summer in June.
That schedule didn't work well for anyone.

I remember when Ohio decided that all colleges in the state would have to be on the same system,OSU pushed real hard for quarters.

Why?

Under quarters,they got almost a month of "class free" football practice.
Last Edited: 12/20/2017 12:34:13 PM by rpbobcat
mail
person
Mark Lembright '85
12/20/2017 1:04 PM
[/QUOTE]

I was at O.U. when the Fall Quarter started at the end of September,ended around Christmas and you got out for the Summer in June.
That schedule didn't work well for anyone.



[/QUOTE]
Getting out in June-and the problem would be??? Athens in May-June, does it get better that that?? ;)


Said tongue-in-cheek. I know that getting out in June didn't help as far as jobs were concerned.
mail
person
mf279801
12/20/2017 1:15 PM
I attended OHIO under quarters, and had my fill of semesters in grad school. Give me quarters or give me death! MUCH preferred to semesters. A painful and fiery death to the regents/chancellor of regents/trustees/etc. who insisted on and voted for the switch to semesters! (hyperbole aside, years and years and years of painful and/or embarrassing rashes would probably be a more appropriate punishment to wish upon them, especially during the Christmas season).

That said, I think the quarter schedule when I was in school (2001-05, Fall quarter ran from labor day to thanksgiving, basically) sounds much better than the one you describe RP.
mail
person
Ohio69
12/20/2017 1:24 PM
OU in May....(sigh).... good times....

These poor semester system kids don't know what they are missing.
mail
person
Buckeye to Bobcat
12/22/2017 6:14 PM
I will say, today is a part of that next step. Gotta put a whooping on national TV when you get a chance. Even if it wasn't seen by everyone, a 41-6 whoopin' is a great day for our boys. That goes a long way.
mail
person
Doc Bobcat
12/22/2017 6:25 PM
Buckeye to Bobcat wrote:expand_more
I will say, today is a part of that next step. Gotta put a whooping on national TV when you get a chance. Even if it wasn't seen by everyone, a 41-6 whoopin' is a great day for our boys. That goes a long way.
Yes.
mail
OhioCatFan
12/22/2017 8:09 PM
+1 ^^*
mail
person
Casper71
12/22/2017 8:31 PM
Win a MACC
Last Edited: 12/22/2017 10:51:42 PM by Casper71
mail
person
Buckeye to Bobcat
12/22/2017 8:56 PM
Casper71 wrote:expand_more
When a MACC
Already been covered in this discussion. That is a legitimate step.

But as to today, I am never the optimist, but these are the kind of poundings you need.
mail
person
LynxRufus6
12/23/2017 1:52 PM
Wondering where that Ohio team that showed up yesterday was a few weeks ago vs Akron and Buffalo. But hey, a W is a W and doing it in the Bahamas was a great experience for the team.

Glad to see the Cats get another bowl win and it’s a nice way to polish off the season. Let’s hope the staff goes out and fills some of the holes that’ll be left behind after this senior class leaves. Already counting down until the Howard game
mail
person
Doc Bobcat
12/23/2017 2:43 PM
OUr offense needs 3 decent RBs for every game. That way...like yesterday....when one goes down we still have 2 to rotate.

Next year I’m counting 4 with Irons...Ouellette...Ross...and the running back we just signed.
mail
person
cbus cat fan
12/23/2017 2:57 PM
A couple of points; as for the quarter-semester deal. A neighbor who is a mover and shaker in the Higher Education world told me that schools were at first gently persuaded to switch to semesters and then strong armed. Apparently, the reasoning behind all of this stems from the ability to transfer within the state and thus making it easier in this the era of educational mobility

Secondly as for Ohio Football, I think this deliberative matter needs to be in the MAC's court, not in that of each individual school. We can't single handily change the direction of our conference's football status. This has to be done at HQ. Yesterday's glorious bowl result helps, but it must be addressed by the MAC itself. We have debated this point ad nauseum, but with less and less kids playing football in youth leagues and high school football, and few Division I schools dropping the sport, great athletes will be in short supply and thus probably heading to Power 5 conferences. We need a plan not so much for the next few years, but for 2025 and beyond.

Finally, thank you Alan for the World Series of Rock reference, though it is getting harder and harder to explain that 1970s event to young people, especially our children, many of which aren't even familiar with what we would consider to be the headliners of the those days!
Last Edited: 12/23/2017 3:01:03 PM by cbus cat fan
mail
person
Alan Swank
12/23/2017 6:29 PM
cbus cat fan wrote:expand_more
Finally, thank you Alan for the World Series of Rock reference, though it is getting harder and harder to explain that 1970s event to young people, especially our children, many of which aren't even familiar with what we would consider to be the headliners of the those days!
Glad you enjoyed it cbus. The one in particular that I remember was August 31, 1974. Still have the general admission ticket stub ($10) and a ticket sales poster of the show. Jesse Colin Young, Santana, The Band and Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young. My girlfriend (wife now of 40 years) and I sat on the field not 50 feet from the Free Clinic Tent. You can only imagine.

As for boats being lifted, I agree, the MAC needs to do the lifting not the individual schools.
mail
person
cbus cat fan
12/23/2017 7:10 PM
Wow Alan those were some headliners. I hate to think what ticket prices would cost today for a similar event. As for where you sat, I can only imagine the stories. I am glad we agree that the conference as a whole has to address the future specifically what the MAC thinks the future holds for the conference, not teams on an ad hoc basis. If it is every team for itself, God only what what will happen!
Last Edited: 12/23/2017 7:12:21 PM by cbus cat fan
mail
person
Bobcat1996
12/23/2017 9:47 PM
Take a look at the salaries paid to most MAC asst. coaches and also take a look at the facilities. I am guessing the MAC is the lowest even behind Sun Belt when it comes to paying assistant staff members and head coaches overall. I'm not certain what all the in door facilities look like or weight rooms/locker rooms and academic centers, but guessing that Ohio isn't at the top of the list when recruits compare lists. The MAC will never be able to compete with the big boys, but you would think that they would be able to stay with the the Sun Belt or CUSA. Salary wise, both those leagues pay more than the MAC. I'm not certain this school or league is willing to fork out the necessary funds to do what it takes to get to the next step. I certainly appreciate the 9 wins this season and it very easily could have been double digits, but does anyone think the powers that be at this university really want to take the next step to reach that higher level?
mail
person
mf279801
12/23/2017 11:44 PM
cbus cat fan wrote:expand_more
A couple of points; as for the quarter-semester deal. A neighbor who is a mover and shaker in the Higher Education world told me that schools were at first gently persuaded to switch to semesters and then strong armed. Apparently, the reasoning behind all of this stems from the ability to transfer within the state and thus making it easier in this the era of educational mobility
Yep, that is some of the same reasoning cited by those gutless wastes of carbon who were on the board of trustees at the time. Nevermind that when the state strong armed the switch to semesters through OHIO, Ohio State, and Cincinnati (and I think a number of community colleges) were also on quarters: so if those dirty weasels were actually interested in making it easier for students to transfer, there would at least have been SOME discussion of forcing the other schools over to quarters, rather than vice a versa. Add to that, if you're looking at transferring among schools, you've got an extra opportunity going from "quarter to quarter" than from "semester to semester,"
or "quarter to semester, semester to quarter" ( that is, 4x per year rather than 3x per year).

No, logical arguments had nothing to do with it. The schools were, as you say, forced from on high to switch to semesters, any and all arguments against it be damned. It is for these reasons that Strickland and his unindicted (probably) co-conspirator Fingerhut should be forever damned to the deepest pits of hell, or at least a series of extremely painful and extremely embarrassing skin conditions. They're the dirty rotten bas****s who forced our fine institution onto semesters. May they be forever hounded from polite society.
mail
person
ozarkcat
12/24/2017 11:00 AM
I continue to believe that with spiraling sports costs the solution is to create an Ohio Conference of larger schools and play club competition in all but the bigger spectator sports. Single day travel, no overnights, carry your lunches type of thing. You can even add track,tennis and other sports schools have dropped in recent years, Drop the MAC, play five or so Ohio teams in D-1 competition and the rest of the games with outside the state competition. Only Ohio, California and Texas are in the position now to make such a move. You free up more money for football, basketball and volleyball and add more sports at the same time.
Showing Messages: 51 - 75 of 81
MAC News Links



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)