Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
1/27/2021 11:11 AM
If we generally agree that everyone is allowed their own opinion, how is an opinion wrong? For what it's worth, I think there's something to the particular opinion above. I surely don't have any solutions to what the right thing to do is for OUr state, and the country as a whole, other than what I thought about for myself last night.
In a vacuum, I don't have a huge problem with the opinion that the collateral damage of the virus has been very bad, and may well outweigh the damage that an unchecked virus may have caused on it's own. I'm not sure if I agree, but understand the viewpoint.
However, in this case, it's hard to disconnect that opinion from the completely hyperbolic and outright false factual claim that the virus is less dangerous than driving to drive to and from a basketball game.
If you believe the second, I suspect you're much more inclined to believe the first. And any discussion of how to weigh the collateral damage of the response to the virus really depends on an accurate view of how dangerous the virus is. The lack of shared facts there -- ohiobobcat1 doesn't think the case numbers or death numbers are accurate -- makes it a pretty pointless conversation to have.
To me, the real crux of the national conversation is that there are basically two camps:
1) A group that believes we didn't do enough to address the virus, and
2) A group that believes we went overboard in our approach to the virus
And the reason it's such a difficult conversation is that both sides are absolutely correct.
Group 1 is justified because we've done far too little to address the economic impact, and have failed from a testing and vaccine infrastructure standpoint.
Group 2 is correct because components of the response have been too punitive (school closures, for instance) and based less on evidence than on early interpretations of what was safe and what wasn't.
Then, of course, there's group 3 that thinks this is just the flu and was all just politics. They don't warrant anybody's time or attention because they're not serious people. If there's anything the last month should have taught us, it's that humoring crazy people and their crazy ideas is dangerous. America needs to start demanding more of its citizens.
Last Edited: 1/27/2021 11:22:31 AM by Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame