If there's any hope to be had, both Grobe and Knorr lost to fcs/1aa teams. Both those teams picked themselves up pretty well and finished "ok". Yes even the knorr team.
I know that a ranked Washington team and Florida State both lost to FCS schools. But let's not get confused. Montana would probably beat JSU and JSU would be a big favorite over Duquesne. To me it isn't so much that we lost to Duquesne. The difference between winning or losing by 2 isn't so meaningful in projecting the rest of the season. We beat Hampton 59-0 a few years ago. If we had a upper tier MAC team we should have, in all probability, done something close to that to Duquesne. I hope the Dukes are better than expected but this is much more discouraging than Knorr losing to Northeastern. After the absurdity that was 2001 I don't think many of us were surprised by Ohio losing to team that finished #11 in 1AA. Grobe's loss to NIU was more disappointing but that team also finished #15 in the FCS. Duquesne might not be top 70.
I think by one measure BGSU and Akron were the two youngest teams in the FBS last season. There are no highly probable wins as of now.
Masseyratings.com and teamrankings.com say that 3-8 is the most likely record.
FPI Says:
Louisiana 9%
Northwestern 7%
Akron 70%
CMU 16%
Buffalo 8%
Kent St. 22%
Miami 31%
EMU 16%
Toledo 10%
BGSU 56%
By FPI 2 or 3 wins is the the most probable. I'd take a 4 win season right now in a heartbeat. I'd be pretty surprised if we can get there. I hope we do but I can't reasonably expect 4 wins.
Why bother playing the games?
Have you taken some sort of offense to this? I don't understand why.
Could you drive your car 100MPH in the wrong lane and get where you are going faster? Is it possible? Yes. Do people do it? No, because the odds of it turning out well are not in your favor.
FPI gives New Mexico St. a 0.1% chance to beat Alabama. Are they going to play the game? Is it possible for NMSU to win? Yes and Yes. Are they going to offer a straight up even money bet on who will win this game? No, because no reasonable person would bet on NMSU. Not even the most rose colored glasses NMSU fan would take that bet. Everyone would bet on Alabama and if they offered bets like that I hope we all agree the casino would lose its shirt and go out of business.
Vegas lines need to represent the most reasonable outcome given the evidence at hand. If they didn't they couldn't exist. Those probabilities can easily be translated into Vegas style odds if you prefer that. If they weren't close to correct in that regard most of the time they also probably wouldn't exist. I actually like the Odds represented in Percent chance of winning better than the expected Spread BECAUSE it shows that there is doubt. It always shows that there is a chance the underdog could win and there is still a reason to play.
Now given that, is there a chance that Ohio could have a winning season? Yes. Should we be thinking that it is reasonably likely? Of course not! Is it as crazy as a NMSU fan expecting to beat Alabama? No, it isn't that far out there but it should still be considered pretty unlikely.
The program probably just had its worst result in more than 3 decades. Arguably, the Northeastern loss was worst because Ohio got shutout but Northeastern was probably a much, much, much better team than Duquesne is. Some of those Ohio teams were pretty darn bad. Some of them were even the very worst team in the FBS/1A. This team just outperformed all of them in ineptitude. If that doesn't tell you something about resetting what is most realistically likely range of wins this team might have then I don't knw what will.