"Yawn." - signed Michigan, Penn State, and Wisconsin (Ohio State's yearly competitors) who have handled the SEC in bowl games. The Big Ten and SEC are tied in bowl games over the last 10 years. OSU has none of the wins, so the Big Ten wins have come from OSU's yearly competitors. Thus, OSU racks up those winning records against teams handling their own against the SEC equal.
A couple points. First of all, I'm talking about the last 4-5 years, not a decade ago. I don't have time to pull the numbers, but I suspect the totals would be different if I did. Second, you also have to consider whether like teams are being paired in the games. The #2 Big Ten team beating the #4 SEC team, for instance, isn't quite as impressive as the second ranked teams in both conferences duking it out.
I'd also be curious to see regular season results as well, such as Alabama-Penn State last week.
The numbers would not be different. In 2006, for instance, the Big Ten was 2-1 against the SEC. Oddly enough, that's when the "SEC is so awlesome and the Big Ten is so bad" stuff started to really gain momentum. That year, the Big Ten #3 beat the SEC West Champion. The Big Ten #4 beat the SEC East runner-up. That was the year OSU lost to Florida.
In 2007, the SEC was 2-1 against the Big Ten. The SEC #1 beat the Big Ten #1. The SEC East #1 beat the Big Ten #3 21-17. The Big Ten #4 beat the SEC East #3 (Florida) 41-35.
In 2008, the conferences went 1-1 against each other. The Big Ten #5 beat the SEC East #3 31-10. The SEC East #2 beat the Big Ten #3 24-12.
In 2009, the conferences went 1-1 against each other. The SEC West #4 beat the Big Ten #5 in OT. The Big Ten #3 beat the SEC West #2 19-17.
For the most part, the matchups have been fairly equal according to standings. Also, 2008 and 2009 happened with Michigan totally on the mat.
As for regular season, there have not been many matchups but I have no clue. The Bama/PSU game is a poor example though, as it was at Bama, PSU started a true frosh QB in his first road game, and PSU is not likely a Big Ten top 3.
Note: I do not think the Big Ten is as good as the SEC in most recent years. My point is that once you get past hyperbole and sensationalism, the margin is slim. Essentially, lately the SEC's best team is better than the Big Ten's best team. Though, it is all cyclical. There have been years in my young lifetime that the Big Ten has run right through the SEC.
Also, Doc Holliday (UF assistant in 2006) said that this OSU team is much fast and better than what he saw in 2006. That may not matter, because luck is always involved in a full season.
Last Edited: 9/19/2010 8:18:57 PM by Mr. Mo Jo Risin