menu
Logo
Ohio Football Topic
Topic: OSU-WHO? REALLY?
Page: 4 of 4
perimeterpost
General User
Member Since: 7/6/2010
Post Count: 3,165
mail
perimeterpost
mail
Posted: 9/21/2010 6:20 PM
The Sexual Harassment Panda wrote:expand_more
1. Ohio State was my safety school
2. My degree has not prevented me from having a successful career
3. Outside of the midwest hiring managers tend to be football fans from the SEC, Big XII and Pac10 so being from Ohio and not having a degree from OSU has actually helped me out in interviews before.
4. Congrats to OSU for all of their success.
5. Some of my good friends are Buckeye fans.
6. Buckeye fans can be the most obnoxious pricks on the planet.
7. OHIO fans should class it up and not get into these online pissing contests with buckeye trolls, but what the heck.
8. Both marching bands are good, the 110 is more "exciting".
9. OSU doesn't represent the entire state of Ohio, stop referring to yourselves as ohio, no other school in the country calls themselves by the wrong name so ignorantly and arrogantly.
10. Congratulations on your cavalcade of bandwagon fans that have no affiliation with your school.
11. I don't care where the two schools rank on any list you have, or care about anything that happened 100 years ago, I love my school as much as you love yours. Its not arrogance, its pride.
12. I hate that some OHIO students and alumni self identify as Buckeye fans first and its not out of envy- fans put their money where their mouth is and these people should be financially investing in the university they have their degree from, not one they don't.
13. The Buckeyes are good enough to make it to the championship game this year, their special teams play will prevent them from winning it.
14. I wish our mascot hadn't acted like a fool but that picture of him punching brutus in the eye makes me laugh uncontrollably.
15. GO OHIO.



I read something by another poster yesterday that I think makes the most sense that I have seen about the use of Ohio. Ohio is the state, not any university. I went to Ohio University, not Ohio. I was an Ohio student starting at the age of 4, I was not an Ohio University student until I was 18. There is nothing wrong with any university, college, high school, etc. to use "ohio." Making the claim of the name of the state doesn't make any sense.

Also about going to the Ohio State University if you are a fan (instead of Ohio University). Ohio University would lose half of its attendance. There are many reasons to go to a University. My father works at Ohio University, so I went to Ohio University for free tuition. Had it not been for the free tuition, I doubt I would have. I can't say where I would've gone, however. Ohio State University is an enormous school and many people may not want to go there just for that reason, too big. Academically, they are an excellent school.


the reason OHIO is acceptable as a reference to Ohio University is because of the precedent set by many other universities named after a state- Florida, Michigan, Texas, Oklahoma, Wisconsin, Arizona, Oregon, Tennessee, Georgia, Wyoming, Arkansas, Kansas, Iowa, Nebraska, etc., and on and on and on. And for that same reason Ohio State should refer to itself as Ohio State just as Arizona State, Oregon State, etc etc never refers to itself without the word "state." When schools are named after states if the only word listed is the state's name then the word "university" is implied, whether it is before or after (University of Kentucky, Indiana University). Never in any of these scenarios is the word "state" implied when just saying the name of the state. If I said I went to Florida, you would not think I went to school in Tallahassee or Miami, you would think I went to school in Gainesville. Its a precedent that's well established across the country, we just want to see it applied in the same way in Ohio.

I wasn't saying you should only go to the school that you are a fan of, I'm saying that you should be a fan of the school you go to. Does that mean if you grew up as an OSU fan and go to OU that you should switch and become an OU fan? Yes. That's exactly what I'm saying. I too grew up a Buckeye fan, I didn't even know OU had a football team, and I didn't really have a chance to know. That's part of the reality of OSU having a monopoly of the media coverage in the state. Like my signature say, "Buckeye by birth, Bobcat by choice". Once I made a decision to get a degree from OU I switched my loyalty because these are not professional teams, they are college teams. Its important for me to support the teams that represent the school I have my degree from, not the school I don't. Fan support = $$$$ = improved school = increased value of my degree. Because OU does not have the luxury of having bandwagon fans we have to fight to keep all the ones that we can. Its nothing personal against OSU, its about financial necessity. Every dollar an OU student or grad spends on OSU's athletic dept is a dollar not spent on the school listed on my resume. If there were a bunch of Shawnee State fans on campus at OU I'd be railing against SSU instead. Like I said, nothing personal.
Last Edited: 9/21/2010 6:26:10 PM by perimeterpost
Flomo-genized
General User
F
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Post Count: 574
person
mail
Flomo-genized
mail
Posted: 9/21/2010 6:52 PM
The Sexual Harassment Panda wrote:expand_more
I read something by another poster yesterday that I think makes the most sense that I have seen about the use of Ohio. Ohio is the state, not any university. I went to Ohio University, not Ohio.


I disagree.  Going to Ohio is the same thing as going to Ohio University, or OU.  They are synonymous, one and the same. 

Students in Gainesville say they go to Florida, not just the University of Florida.  Students in Austin don't say only that they go to the University of Texas, but to Texas.  Same thing with students in Ann Arbor.  Their shirts read "Michigan" not the "University of Michigan."

Literally, Ohio is the only state in the union where State U. tries to use the state name alone in cheers, traditions, etc.  This doesn't occur anywhere else.  It is not logical, normal, or acceptable.
Last Edited: 9/21/2010 6:54:04 PM by Flomo-genized
OhioCatFan
General User
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Athens, OH
Post Count: 15,716
mail
OhioCatFan
mail
Posted: 9/29/2010 2:39 PM
Flomo-genized wrote:expand_more
I read something by another poster yesterday that I think makes the most sense that I have seen about the use of Ohio. Ohio is the state, not any university. I went to Ohio University, not Ohio.


I disagree.  Going to Ohio is the same thing as going to Ohio University, or OU.  They are synonymous, one and the same. 

Students in Gainesville say they go to Florida, not just the University of Florida.  Students in Austin don't say only that they go to the University of Texas, but to Texas.  Same thing with students in Ann Arbor.  Their shirts read "Michigan" not the "University of Michigan."

Literally, Ohio is the only state in the union where State U. tries to use the state name alone in cheers, traditions, etc.  This doesn't occur anywhere else.  It is not logical, normal, or acceptable.


Let me add, if we hadn't agreed to the out-of-court settlement in the famous "name case," it is likely Ohio State would have had to change the name of its stadium and the words to its alma mater.  They still might have gotten away with the OH-IO cheer because they claim they are cheering for the state and not their school.  That's pretty dubious though.  I, for one, wish we hadn't agreed to the out-of-court settlement.  The Evil Empire was going to lose big time in court.
John C. Wanamaker
General User
Member Since: 1/2/2005
Post Count: 1,103
mail
John C. Wanamaker
mail
Posted: 9/29/2010 4:21 PM
OhioCatFan wrote:expand_more
I read something by another poster yesterday that I think makes the most sense that I have seen about the use of Ohio. Ohio is the state, not any university. I went to Ohio University, not Ohio.


I disagree.  Going to Ohio is the same thing as going to Ohio University, or OU.  They are synonymous, one and the same. 

Students in Gainesville say they go to Florida, not just the University of Florida.  Students in Austin don't say only that they go to the University of Texas, but to Texas.  Same thing with students in Ann Arbor.  Their shirts read "Michigan" not the "University of Michigan."

Literally, Ohio is the only state in the union where State U. tries to use the state name alone in cheers, traditions, etc.  This doesn't occur anywhere else.  It is not logical, normal, or acceptable.


Let me add, if we hadn't agreed to the out-of-court settlement in the famous "name case," it is likely Ohio State would have had to change the name of its stadium and the words to its alma mater.  They still might have gotten away with the OH-IO cheer because they claim they are cheering for the state and not their school.  That's pretty dubious though.  I, for one, wish we hadn't agreed to the out-of-court settlement.  The Evil Empire was going to lose big time in court.


OCF:  I believe you are living in a fantasy world if you think the courts would not have allowed OSU to keep the name Ohio Stadium or their alma mater.
OhioCatFan
General User
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Athens, OH
Post Count: 15,716
mail
OhioCatFan
mail
Posted: 9/29/2010 6:55 PM
JCW, that was a real worry of the OSU attorneys and one of the reasons they counseled the OSU Prez William Kirwan to accept the settlement.  The settlement exempts "traditional" OSU uses of "Ohio" and specifically mentions "Carmen Ohio" and "Ohio Stadium."  If they weren't worried about the possibility of losing the rights to those words they wouldn't have insisted that it be spelled out so explicitly in the settlement.  If you want the full  story just ask John Burns over a beer sometime and expect to spend an hour hearing all the gory details.  If this had gone to court, it would have created a real mess -- mainly for the Evil Empire.  The irony of it all is that THEY started the process by suing US.  How obnoxious and arrogant!  

An interesting sidelight to this whole affair was that Kirwan and Glidden were actually close personal friends.  The suit had been instituted under the previous prez -- the once and future Gordon "Bow-Tie" Gee of The Ohio State Agricultural and Mechanical School and State University . 
Last Edited: 9/29/2010 7:06:12 PM by OhioCatFan
That one crazy fan
General User
Member Since: 7/21/2010
Location: Iowa City, IA
Post Count: 491
mail
That one crazy fan
mail
Posted: 9/29/2010 11:09 PM
OhioCatFan wrote:expand_more
JCW, that was a real worry of the OSU attorneys and one of the reasons they counseled the OSU Prez William Kirwan to accept the settlement.  The settlement exempts "traditional" OSU uses of "Ohio" and specifically mentions "Carmen Ohio" and "Ohio Stadium."  If they weren't worried about the possibility of losing the rights to those words they wouldn't have insisted that it be spelled out so explicitly in the settlement.  If you want the full  story just ask John Burns over a beer sometime and expect to spend an hour hearing all the gory details.  If this had gone to court, it would have created a real mess -- mainly for the Evil Empire.  The irony of it all is that THEY started the process by suing US.  How obnoxious and arrogant!  

An interesting sidelight to this whole affair was that Kirwan and Glidden were actually close personal friends.  The suit had been instituted under the previous prez -- the once and future Gordon "Bow-Tie" Gee of The Ohio State Agricultural and Mechanical School and State University . 


I am very interested in all the details of this story.  I tried telling my parents about this as justification for my hatred for OSU and they called bullcrap because "it would have been all over the news had this happened."  How do I have a beer with this man to get said details?
OhioCatFan
General User
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Athens, OH
Post Count: 15,716
mail
OhioCatFan
mail
Posted: 9/29/2010 11:21 PM
Well, Ringo, many -- but not all -- of the details were in the news stories at the time of the signing of the out-of-court settlement.  Some of the stories mentioned such things as the exemptions that we granted for the use of Script Ohio and the naming of Ohio Stadium.  This wasn't hidden under a drum.  These documents are still a matter of public record and could be obtained with an FOI request to Ohio University and/or The Evil Empire.
John C. Wanamaker
General User
Member Since: 1/2/2005
Post Count: 1,103
mail
John C. Wanamaker
mail
Posted: 9/30/2010 7:25 AM
Ringo it pretty much was all over the news at that time.

OCF:  I still stand by my statement, OSU was in no way in any real danger of having to rename Ohio Stadium. 
Showing Messages: 76 - 83 of 83
MAC News Links
Tuesday, May 12, 2026



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)