Piney/BC - no surprise that I disagree. But what you may think is simply blind hatred for OSU playing itself out in wanting/praying for tough penalties is actually based on the fact I am hearing the same rhetoric out of Knoxville as I hear out of Columbus/you - which isn't a good thing for either Knoxville or Columbus. The husband of a business associate is UT through and through. Friend of mine is ex-UT women's basketball player. Both echo the same rhetoric - we got rid of Pearl, the infractions are no big deal, we are cleaning our house and imposing sanctions, etc. Unfortunately, it is a bad time to be under the gun.
The NCAA has made it clear they want to be tough on those caught breaking the rules - "We need to make sure our penalty structure and enforcement process imposes a thoughtful level of concern, and that the cost of violating the rules costs more than not violating them" - Mark Emmert NCAA President. The NCAA knows everyone is pulling these shenanigans. But they can't look the other way when they are so out in the open. Unfortunately, the NCAA has incredible leeway in assigning penalty. Based on a little fire and a lot of smoke, they can assign pretty tough sanctions. More than what you would get for tattoos.
At the end of the day, they know as fact, the answer to three questions.
Did Tressel/OSU know the players were selling memorabilia, and/or trading for tattoos (both of which are an infraction thus making the players ineligible). Answer is Yes.
And then the two biggies:
Did Tressel/OSU knowingly then allow these players to play. The Answer is Yes. Thus the coach knowingly played ineligible players and knowingly broke the rules.
Was the coach less than forthright in dealing with the NCAA? The answer is yes. When provided the opportunity to come clean, he did not - over and over again.
It is not a question of what they should get, it is what they will get. The NCAA comes down hard when they have anything to go on - just ask UNC (a second tier program). And yes, that involved an agent, but do you think the NCAA feels the guy in Columbus is stand-up?
And today's actions regarding Tressel will not help their argument. We blame the coach. He alone caused all this. So we got rid of him. Rescind his $250,000 fine and pay him $50,000. How convenient that the day he formally falls on the sword with the NCAA he profits $300,000.
They will not let UT or OSU off lightly. Will they let them break the rules and punish themselves? They simply can't. They come down light - the whole country laughs at them. They come down hard and Columbus and Knoxville are upset. Pretty easy choice. Not justice, just reality.
We'll see in a few months.
Last Edited: 7/8/2011 5:58:09 PM by cc-cat