Of the states listed ahead of us in population (CA, TX, NY, FL, IL, FL, PA) only New York fails to have a more than one AQ representative of the state for college football. And they fail to have any, which might indicate something. Of the states behind us in population, 18 have at least two AQ representatives. (I'm aware Cinci is AQ, bare with me).
What does this have to do with anything? Are you saying we should be an AQ school? Is it our marketing department's fault we aren't? I'd argue it has a lot more to do with being one of the worst 1A football programs in the nation for a 30-40 year span and much less about billboards in Parma.
Ohio is a sports hungry state. We have 2 MLB, 1 NBA, 2 NFL, and 1 NHL franchise. A demand for professional athletics is there. That is evident. Then we see that Ohio State hangs around as one of the most profitable college football programs. It is evident that a demand for college football is there. And Ohio State currently satisfies an overwhelming quantity of that demand.
The Bengals and Browns are constantly under the threat of a blackout because they can't fill their stadiums. The demand isn't even high enough for fans who live in Cleveland or Cincinnati to go watch an NFL game a half hour from home.
Ohio isn't a sports hungry state, it's a sports saturated state. 2 NFL, 2 MLB, 1 NBA, 1 NHL, 2 BCS Football, 6 other Division 1 football, 13 Division 1 Basketball Programs, 7 minor league baseball and more Division 2-3 and NAIA programs than you can count (Including multiple national championship programs in many sports at those levels.)
The fact is we have to scratch and claw to get anyone to come to our games. Look at all that competition. Many say we're at a disadvantage because we're geographically isolated. In fact, it may be a good thing because we have a better chance of keeping local $$ here. Imagine if you're Akron trying to compete for a sports entertainment dollar with the Indians, Browns, Cavs, Kent, Cleveland State, etc...
Why would we throw good money into a city (Cleveland for example) that already has more sports options than it can possibly accomodate. Guysville meanwhile is limited to Federal Hocking football and the Bobcats during September - November. Priority #1 should be directing as many sports entertainment dollars within an hour or so radius of Athens to the ticket office.
We have the name of this state, the marketably better name.
That may have mattered 80 years ago, but we're way past that having any relevance. Sure it's convenient, but I highly doubt it matters much - if anything it may be a hindrance with all the confusion between us and Ohio State.
I believe that people don't know what they want. I believe people are buying in to Ohio State simply because they never knew they had a choice. I believe a large portion of Ohio State's share of the state, and the profits, are up for grabs. I believe we are in a position to take this from them and give the customer what they want; an option they never knew they had.
And what option is that? The worst football in the country for 30-40 years? 1 Bowl win in school history? 0-3 in MAC Championship Games? We're a decent option now, but it's going to take consistent winning to convince the rest of the state that we're worthwhile.
You're a perfect example - all you know is winning because of your age and years you've been affiliated with Ohio. You expect us to win, and be the best, and that's AWESOME. We've consistently won while you've been involved with Ohio, and you've bought in. Winning works. But, for anyone over 25 or so, that isn't how they perceive us. And it's going to take more than a few quality years to change their minds.
We are on our way to the top. I believe it from the bottom of my heart, but you're delusional if you think we've arrived already. We have a LONG way to go. The rest of the state still remembers that period from 1970-2006 where we were awful. Have we turned the corner? You better believe it. But is there still a long, uphill finish - absolutely.
TL;DR - We're in a very stiff competition for every dollar spent on sports entertainment in Ohio. The state is over-saturated with options. We've had some success, but we've got a long way to go before we can "expect" a sellout.