I just wonder if those billboards advertising $5 tickets for games against Big East schools and the high school football-level season ticket prices don't undercut bigger things like building a market and a value for Ohio football tickets.
The results would argue that the whole "$4.50" message is working, though. We just led the MAC in attendance and had 3 sellouts. All this with maybe the WORST home schedule in program history. What does "building a market and a value for Ohio Football" accomplish? I'd rather have the sellouts.
If you ask me, it appears the core of the recent marketing strategy is drawing in the casual fan from SE Ohio. Joe Six-Pack from Albany, McArthur, Logan, McConnelsville, etc. who's looking for something to do. The type who, dare I say, wears O$U stuff to the game...and probably couldn't name one of our players. Joe Six-Pack also doesn't have lots of $$$$...and hence you have to keep the product cheap.
But, in a place like Athens, this is EXACTLY who you have to bring to the games to achieve sellouts. I think they've hit a home run with this strategy, and that's where much of the attendance increase is coming from. I've seen more groups at the Convo and Peden this year than maybe the past 5 combined. Everything from 4H kids to Canal Winchester football teams and the Morgan County basketball leagues. None of these "new" fans I've seen, though, are the type of folks that will (or would be able to) fork out big $$$ for tickets.
Give me cheap tickets all day if it brings in the masses. Hopefully, as these "new" fans get to experience more of our games, they'll all grow to love the teams as we do....and ultimately become bigger fans and season ticket holders. And maybe then, they'll start complaining about cheap tickets on a message board. 
Kidding aside though, all interesting points to discuss!