I've seen taylor price and lavon brazile...this group of receivers does not have either!
I don't think we're disagreeing. I already put Foster behind Brazill and Price, and Todd Snyder as well. Still, he's in the top 5 receivers of all time for Ohio, and that's not bad. Will he get drafted? No, I don't think so, but I'm sure he'll probably get a free agent contract. I also think he'd start for any MAC team, but as good as Brazill and Price, no.
As for Cochran, to me he compares with Scott Mayle, and he wasn't a bad receiver. Scott even appeared in an NFL game or two, if I recall. To me, Waters compares to Dunlop or McCrae, again, not bad receivers. How do these groups compare?
2005 - Mayle (21/338), Fitzgerald (18/228), Norwood (11/96) [Everson]
2006 - Nwokocha (11/113), Mayle (10/155), Norwood (10/94) [Everson]
2007 - Price (33/464), Nwokocha (25/361) Brazill (16/201) [Bower/T3]
2008 - Price (51/694), Brazil (34/384), Garrett (24/290) [Jackson/T3]
2009 - Brazill (53/702), Price (52/735), McCrae (33/564) [T3/Jackson]
2010 - McCrae (35/505), Dunlop (27/387), Goulet (25/388) [Jackson]
2011 - Brazill (74/1146), Dunlop (43/586), Foster (30/352) [TT}
2012 - Foster (59/659), Bussey (37/313). Futrell (28/422) [TT]
2013 - Foster (57/769), Waters (32/446), Cochran (30/614) [TT]
I think we'd agree that the 2008 group is tough to beat, at least in terms of potential, with 2 future NFL drafts and a future CFL star, though the output wasn't that high. The 2009 and 2011 groups were probably the best two. I'd say that the 2013 group is better than the 2012, 2010, or 2005-2007, though. Thus, it's not the best group ever, but it's not bad.
This team clearly has issues., and it clearly has some positions that are not as good as in the past. WR may not have the NFL draft choices of the last few years, but it's not the primary cause of the problems this year. If the running game had been working, and TT had a bit more time, I'm sure their numbers would have been even better. I called it a "solid" position, and I'll stand by that. I wish I could say the same for the other positions.
Last Edited: 11/27/2013 12:22:01 PM by L.C.