I loved watching Kareem play but he only fit in that offense. He could have played QB in no other. Tettleton pre-senior year could have excelled in any offense that is why he got my vote.
Yeah, it's going to be interesting to see the team that is ultimately assembled from this and imagine what that team would have looked like on the field. Again, favorite does not equal best necessarily.
And it is amazing what one season did to our picture of T^2. It's sad that, even though he re-wrote the Ohio QB record books, his enduring legacy probably will be shrugging his shoulders after the McCabe'ning. The whole story may never be known.