For those of us old enough to remember Coach Lichtenberg and Coach Knorr, I would much rather prefer Coach Lichtenberg, for a variety of reasons. However it is somewhat akin to saying would you rather be the 102nd best team or the 117th best team in the nation.
It seems to me a few years back the powers that be at Ohio decided, unlike the Toledo's and the Western Michigan's of the world, they were not going to enter the MAC football arms race. We have let it be known during recruiting season that we will never pull out all the stops to recruit talent we don't believe we will ever get. Some of the top recruits at Toledo and Western Michigan would probably never consider coming to Athens.
Although we are perhaps the most rural school in the MAC as far as media markets go, we have the history and attendance that most MAC schools envy. It doesn't have to be this way, but perhaps some at the top think this is as good as it gets for football. I sure hope not, but sometimes I wonder. The coaching staff is doing a good job with little talent, but why not recruit better talent? It is like someone complaining that the pizza place they go to is the worst in the town, never stopping to think if they paid a buck or two more, the pizza place down the street would be an oh so much better alternative. We have the history, tradition and attendance to shoot for better talent.
At some point I think the recruiting comes down to the coaches we have on staff and the schemes we run. Maybe we get them to a game or they see Ohio on TV and think, "I don't fit there."
More and more when I think about this program, it's like the old scouts in the room in the movie "Moneyball." And Billy Beane (some of us fans) are just banging our head against a wall.