And, what if JC had stayed? It's not as if his last recruiting class here that he left for Saul was full of world beaters. A thought worth considering anyway.
It actually was full of world beaters and one is playing on Texas Tech right now.
Related to the Ryan Taylor, and other comments in the thread -- My first comment had absolutely nothing to do with Saul, Ryan Taylor, or anyone here since Saul's arrival. It was specific to the idea that JC's last recruiting class, and the "cupboard" left for Saul, besides Tony, Mo, and Setty, wasn't terribly well stocked, and left me wondering how good a JC team would have been in 2014-15, and beyond. Setty, by the way, is a great example of a player who definitely improved under the current coaching staff.
JC's last recruiting class looks like this:
Kendall Crute: ended up quitting basketball to become committed to the church, and I think enrolled in a seminary school. Good for him as a man, but not a world beater as a hooper obviously.
Tariq Owens: We all know his story - he's signed to play at four universities in five years if you count Ohio. Based on this history, I'd bet if JC stayed, he doesn't stay all 4-years. I wouldn't call him a world beater, but defensively, he's a very good talent. He would have been fun to see paired with Mo. In a lot of ways, his numbers are similar to what we say about Doug: Good defender/rebounder, lacking on the offensive end.
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/tariq-owens-... Nehemias Morillo: Had two solid years at USF. Could have been a solid MAC player assuming his time at USF translates to whatever he would have been asked to do at Ohio. Also not a world beater, or stud player in my mind.
https://gousfbulls.com/documents/2016/3/21/3376112.pdf Rodell Wiggington: Turned out to be a solid role player at the MAC level for UB. Numbers wise, and role-wise, not all that different than Gavin Block, though Gavin is probably a better passer, while Wiggington is a better defender. Like Gavin, definitely not a stud, world beater player.
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/rodell-wiggi... If anyone wants to take it farther, and point out the High School Juniors that JC was recruiting for 2015-16, that's a good addition to the conversation. I can't recall who was a JC recruit, and don't have time to dig right now to decipher who was a JC recruit, and who was a Saul recruit from that year's lists.