Ohio Basketball Topic
Topic: The Fall of Saul
Page: 3 of 3
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
1/31/2019 10:12 AM
GoCats105 wrote:expand_more
Anyway, I think you're right in Ohio needing to look for someone who isn't so hot in the coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but we also don't want someone is so green that it will take forever to build the program back up.
For whatever it's worth, I think we kind of do want somebody who is so hot in coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but with some caveats.

Namely, that he comes from a coaching tree and he feels encouraged by the athletic department to treat Athens as an extension of that tree. He should be building his staff from that same tree and do so with the expectation that he's going to win and be gone in 3 years, and that his replacement when that happens is sitting to his left on the bench.

If our program becomes known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs, that's a good thing, provided you build infrastructure that allows for some continuity. I think the only way to make that tenable is to feel like you're confidently able to hire from within. Three regimes in three years will cause havoc in any sort of organization.
mail
person
allen
1/31/2019 10:29 AM
Townie1977 wrote:expand_more
And, what if JC had stayed? It's not as if his last recruiting class here that he left for Saul was full of world beaters. A thought worth considering anyway.
It actually was full of world beaters and one is playing on Texas Tech right now.
Yeah and if Christian would have stayed one more year there wouldn't have been a team the following year. Would have been a full-on mutiny.
That’s Saul’s fault for not being able to keep those guys. [/QUOTE]Tariq Owens is 34 years old, has transferred 15 times, and has reached his absolute ceiling by becoming a role player on a top 15 team. He's not exactly a program altering talent.

Who were these other world beaters we're so angry at Saul for losing? [/QUOTE]
Yeah...he lost Ryan Taylor, whatever happened to that chump?

Correct me, but I believe he is just the best recruit Saul has ever delivered to our campus. And correct me again, but Saul lost him because Saul couldn't control the egos of a couple of shoot-first point guards that were on their way out.

34 years old, you just made my day lol
Last Edited: 1/31/2019 10:35:18 AM by allen
mail
person
GoCats105
1/31/2019 11:58 AM
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame wrote:expand_more
Anyway, I think you're right in Ohio needing to look for someone who isn't so hot in the coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but we also don't want someone is so green that it will take forever to build the program back up.
For whatever it's worth, I think we kind of do want somebody who is so hot in coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but with some caveats.

Namely, that he comes from a coaching tree and he feels encouraged by the athletic department to treat Athens as an extension of that tree. He should be building his staff from that same tree and do so with the expectation that he's going to win and be gone in 3 years, and that his replacement when that happens is sitting to his left on the bench.

If our program becomes known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs, that's a good thing, provided you build infrastructure that allows for some continuity. I think the only way to make that tenable is to feel like you're confidently able to hire from within. Three regimes in three years will cause havoc in any sort of organization.
Don't tell that to the people who think Ohio is above that model. ;)
mail
OU_Country
1/31/2019 12:07 PM
greencat wrote:expand_more
How bad do you guys want to see the Bobcats winning the MAC, going to the big dance, packing the Convo with big loud crowds? College sports is dog eat dog and every man for himself. Nice guys get participation trophies and juice boxes. People willing to do what it takes (recruit over guys and send the scrubs off packing) get the big dance trips and become the mid-major underdog darlings talked about in every bracket pool in every office coast to coast. Do you guys want people in Dubuque and Peoria at the water cooler saying "how about those Ohio Bobcats!" \ or not?

The school has a decision to make pretty soon.
I don't think this is a question for us, I think this is a Schaus, Nellis, etc. question. Obviously.

I've begun to change my expectations to match what I think I'm seeing from those folks. It's actually not a fun thing as it turns out.
mail
OU_Country
1/31/2019 12:08 PM
FearLeon wrote:expand_more
I am curious as to where Saul lands next? Will another lower Division One school give him a chance next year or does he have to go assistant job at a P5 Conference school first?
Previously, I thought he might end up working at Nebraska with Miles. I'm not sure he'll be at Nebraska next year.
mail
OU_Country
1/31/2019 12:11 PM
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame wrote:expand_more
Anyway, I think you're right in Ohio needing to look for someone who isn't so hot in the coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but we also don't want someone is so green that it will take forever to build the program back up.
For whatever it's worth, I think we kind of do want somebody who is so hot in coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but with some caveats.

Namely, that he comes from a coaching tree and he feels encouraged by the athletic department to treat Athens as an extension of that tree. He should be building his staff from that same tree and do so with the expectation that he's going to win and be gone in 3 years, and that his replacement when that happens is sitting to his left on the bench.

If our program becomes known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs, that's a good thing, provided you build infrastructure that allows for some continuity. I think the only way to make that tenable is to feel like you're confidently able to hire from within. Three regimes in three years will cause havoc in any sort of organization.
110% Agree with this. In retrospect, probably should have retained Dustin Ford, or attempted to Holtmann in lieu of Christian. But who thought he'd leave two years later? The answer is nearly no one.
mail
OU_Country
1/31/2019 12:15 PM
bobcatsquared wrote:expand_more
maybe Saul can get some of that luck going his way.
Sad state of the program when we're hoping to get lucky in March. And it's going to take a lot of luck for this team.
Ummm, isn't that essentially what 2005 and 2010 were all about? It's not as if Ohio was even remotely close to being the best team in the MAC those years.
mail
person
Buckeye to Bobcat
1/31/2019 12:31 PM
GoCats105 wrote:expand_more
Anyway, I think you're right in Ohio needing to look for someone who isn't so hot in the coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but we also don't want someone is so green that it will take forever to build the program back up.
For whatever it's worth, I think we kind of do want somebody who is so hot in coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but with some caveats.

Namely, that he comes from a coaching tree and he feels encouraged by the athletic department to treat Athens as an extension of that tree. He should be building his staff from that same tree and do so with the expectation that he's going to win and be gone in 3 years, and that his replacement when that happens is sitting to his left on the bench.

If our program becomes known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs, that's a good thing, provided you build infrastructure that allows for some continuity. I think the only way to make that tenable is to feel like you're confidently able to hire from within. Three regimes in three years will cause havoc in any sort of organization.
Don't tell that to the people who think Ohio is above that model. ;)
Always said that I thought CMU football (til they went outside of Grand Valley) and Toledo football (with Mount Union pipeline) had it made as a model. To have a school that acts as a "feeder" for your next coach makes life a heckuva lot easier.
mail
OU_Country
1/31/2019 12:43 PM
The better Ohio Bobcat wrote:expand_more
And, what if JC had stayed? It's not as if his last recruiting class here that he left for Saul was full of world beaters. A thought worth considering anyway.
It actually was full of world beaters and one is playing on Texas Tech right now.
Related to the Ryan Taylor, and other comments in the thread -- My first comment had absolutely nothing to do with Saul, Ryan Taylor, or anyone here since Saul's arrival. It was specific to the idea that JC's last recruiting class, and the "cupboard" left for Saul, besides Tony, Mo, and Setty, wasn't terribly well stocked, and left me wondering how good a JC team would have been in 2014-15, and beyond. Setty, by the way, is a great example of a player who definitely improved under the current coaching staff.


JC's last recruiting class looks like this:

Kendall Crute: ended up quitting basketball to become committed to the church, and I think enrolled in a seminary school. Good for him as a man, but not a world beater as a hooper obviously.


Tariq Owens: We all know his story - he's signed to play at four universities in five years if you count Ohio. Based on this history, I'd bet if JC stayed, he doesn't stay all 4-years. I wouldn't call him a world beater, but defensively, he's a very good talent. He would have been fun to see paired with Mo. In a lot of ways, his numbers are similar to what we say about Doug: Good defender/rebounder, lacking on the offensive end.
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/tariq-owens-...


Nehemias Morillo: Had two solid years at USF. Could have been a solid MAC player assuming his time at USF translates to whatever he would have been asked to do at Ohio. Also not a world beater, or stud player in my mind.
https://gousfbulls.com/documents/2016/3/21/3376112.pdf


Rodell Wiggington: Turned out to be a solid role player at the MAC level for UB. Numbers wise, and role-wise, not all that different than Gavin Block, though Gavin is probably a better passer, while Wiggington is a better defender. Like Gavin, definitely not a stud, world beater player.
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/rodell-wiggi...


If anyone wants to take it farther, and point out the High School Juniors that JC was recruiting for 2015-16, that's a good addition to the conversation. I can't recall who was a JC recruit, and don't have time to dig right now to decipher who was a JC recruit, and who was a Saul recruit from that year's lists.
mail
person
GroverBall
1/31/2019 1:10 PM
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame wrote:expand_more
Anyway, I think you're right in Ohio needing to look for someone who isn't so hot in the coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but we also don't want someone is so green that it will take forever to build the program back up.
For whatever it's worth, I think we kind of do want somebody who is so hot in coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but with some caveats.

Namely, that he comes from a coaching tree and he feels encouraged by the athletic department to treat Athens as an extension of that tree. He should be building his staff from that same tree and do so with the expectation that he's going to win and be gone in 3 years, and that his replacement when that happens is sitting to his left on the bench.

If our program becomes known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs, that's a good thing, provided you build infrastructure that allows for some continuity. I think the only way to make that tenable is to feel like you're confidently able to hire from within. Three regimes in three years will cause havoc in any sort of organization.
So you just described the Saul Phillips hire. Bo Ryan tree and actual direct DNA and coaching and playing experience from that tree on the bench next to Saul. And coming in our program was known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs. It didn't work out the way we hoped but the hire was a good one IMHO.
mail
person
Buck.Cat
1/31/2019 1:16 PM
OU_Country wrote:expand_more
Previously, I thought he might end up working at Nebraska with Miles. I'm not sure he'll be at Nebraska next year.
Ironically, Miles is also in the midst of a lame duck contract year. I believe he signed a 1 year extension after last season.
mail
OUVan
1/31/2019 1:22 PM
cbus cat fan wrote:expand_more
The next year Majerus went to Utah and Coach Dick Hunskaer took them to the Elite 8 only losing to UNLV after the Cardinal had them on the ropes, losing by one bucket. UNLV blew out Duke in the championship game (the Blue Devils lost by 30.) Ball State gave them the closest game of the whole tournament.
That was a Sweet 16 game, not an Elite 8 game. Kent State is the only MAC team in the last 50 years to make it to the Elite 8 although we were oh so close.
mail
person
Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
1/31/2019 1:40 PM
GroverBall wrote:expand_more
Anyway, I think you're right in Ohio needing to look for someone who isn't so hot in the coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but we also don't want someone is so green that it will take forever to build the program back up.
For whatever it's worth, I think we kind of do want somebody who is so hot in coaching ranks that he's almost gone before he gets here, but with some caveats.

Namely, that he comes from a coaching tree and he feels encouraged by the athletic department to treat Athens as an extension of that tree. He should be building his staff from that same tree and do so with the expectation that he's going to win and be gone in 3 years, and that his replacement when that happens is sitting to his left on the bench.

If our program becomes known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs, that's a good thing, provided you build infrastructure that allows for some continuity. I think the only way to make that tenable is to feel like you're confidently able to hire from within. Three regimes in three years will cause havoc in any sort of organization.
So you just described the Saul Phillips hire. Bo Ryan tree and actual direct DNA and coaching and playing experience from that tree on the bench next to Saul. And coming in our program was known as a place that wins games and gets coaches better jobs. It didn't work out the way we hoped but the hire was a good one IMHO.
Yep, agreed. Everybody liked the hire at the time, regardless of how many mouths around here are foaming.
mail
OU_Country
1/31/2019 2:04 PM
Buck.Cat wrote:expand_more
Previously, I thought he might end up working at Nebraska with Miles. I'm not sure he'll be at Nebraska next year.
Ironically, Miles is also in the midst of a lame duck contract year. I believe he signed a 1 year extension after last season.
I'm not sure that's the case. I think he's got at least a couple years left. I think he petitioned for 2-3 years instead of one because of how it would impact recruiting. I'm pretty sure he won that battle and got at least two. Doesn't mean he'll end up playing those years out though.
mail
person
Buck.Cat
1/31/2019 2:14 PM
OU_Country wrote:expand_more
I'm not sure that's the case. I think he's got at least a couple years left. I think he petitioned for 2-3 years instead of one because of how it would impact recruiting. I'm pretty sure he won that battle and got at least two. Doesn't mean he'll end up playing those years out though.
You are correct. He was extended 1 year through the 20-21 season. It does sound like he might not make it after this season.
mail
person
Buck.Cat
2/3/2019 10:43 AM
Saul has fallen and can’t get up.
mail
OhioCatFan
2/3/2019 12:35 PM
Buck.Cat wrote:expand_more
Saul has fallen and can’t get up.
What pleasure do you get out of repeating these sentiments over and over again? We all get it. We are having a very bad season -- by OHIO standards -- and we are very likely to have a new coach next year. I for one am very sorry that things seem to be going in this direction. I have much sympathy for Saul. I think he's a good man. If he's let go, I will sincerely wish him well in all his future endeavors.
mail
Diamond Cat
2/3/2019 1:40 PM
I like the guy as well. I know how it is to move 3 kids around the country and the impact that can take. I certainly will wish him nothing but the best if things unfold the way they seem to be heading. All that said, $500-$600K x 5 years (in Athens) allows one to have a pretty large slush fund. He will be fine.
mail
FearLeon
2/3/2019 2:03 PM
Diamond Cat wrote:expand_more
I like the guy as well. I know how it is to move 3 kids around the country and the impact that can take. I certainly will wish him nothing but the best if things unfold the way they seem to be heading. All that said, $500-$600K x 5 years (in Athens) allows one to have a pretty large slush fund. He will be fine.
Nobody likes to see somebody lose their job and have their family uprooted. But not many will have the money in a slush fund like Saul. I'm no CPA...but at 500K per year....he made 2.5 million dollars while head coach at Ohio...minimum.

My guess is that he paid at least $750,000 (30%) in taxes over these five years. So before all his monthly nut bill payments and mortgage....let's say he cleared probably $1,750,000 during his tenure after taxes. There is a good chance that after he paid all his bills, mortgage and other misc living expenses over these five years that he walks out of here with a cool $1,000,000 in profit after his five year stay in Athens. He's doing just fine and I'm sure Saul did a good job of saving his cash living in Athens for half a decade. Moving forward though Saul will probably never see or touch 500K in salary again in this business.
Last Edited: 2/3/2019 5:31:37 PM by FearLeon
mail
person
colobobcat66
2/3/2019 6:15 PM
FearLeon wrote:expand_more
I like the guy as well. I know how it is to move 3 kids around the country and the impact that can take. I certainly will wish him nothing but the best if things unfold the way they seem to be heading. All that said, $500-$600K x 5 years (in Athens) allows one to have a pretty large slush fund. He will be fine.
Nobody likes to see somebody lose their job and have their family uprooted. But not many will have the money in a slush fund like Saul. I'm no CPA...but at 500K per year....he made 2.5 million dollars while head coach at Ohio...minimum.

My guess is that he paid at least $750,000 (30%) in taxes over these five years. So before all his monthly nut bill payments and mortgage....let's say he cleared probably $1,750,000 during his tenure after taxes. There is a good chance that after he paid all his bills, mortgage and other misc living expenses over these five years that he walks out of here with a cool $1,000,000 in profit after his five year stay in Athens. He's doing just fine and I'm sure Saul did a good job of saving his cash living in Athens for half a decade. Moving forward though Saul will probably never see or touch 500K in salary again in this business.

Never is a long time. With all the money in sports, Phillips will land on his feet and I would guess end up as a head coach again. We may not like the injury “excuse”, others may not see it the same way as we do.
Time will tell.
mail
person
Buckeye to Bobcat
2/3/2019 6:35 PM
colobobcat66 wrote:expand_more
I like the guy as well. I know how it is to move 3 kids around the country and the impact that can take. I certainly will wish him nothing but the best if things unfold the way they seem to be heading. All that said, $500-$600K x 5 years (in Athens) allows one to have a pretty large slush fund. He will be fine.
Nobody likes to see somebody lose their job and have their family uprooted. But not many will have the money in a slush fund like Saul. I'm no CPA...but at 500K per year....he made 2.5 million dollars while head coach at Ohio...minimum.

My guess is that he paid at least $750,000 (30%) in taxes over these five years. So before all his monthly nut bill payments and mortgage....let's say he cleared probably $1,750,000 during his tenure after taxes. There is a good chance that after he paid all his bills, mortgage and other misc living expenses over these five years that he walks out of here with a cool $1,000,000 in profit after his five year stay in Athens. He's doing just fine and I'm sure Saul did a good job of saving his cash living in Athens for half a decade. Moving forward though Saul will probably never see or touch 500K in salary again in this business.

Never is a long time. With all the money in sports, Phillips will land on his feet and I would guess end up as a head coach again. We may not like the injury “excuse”, others may not see it the same way as we do.
Time will tell.
+1

No doubt injuries did him in, similar to Groce at Illinois.
mail
person
SBH
2/3/2019 6:38 PM
Poor talent evaluation did him in.
mail
person
colobobcat66
2/3/2019 10:29 PM
SBH wrote:expand_more
Poor talent evaluation did him in.
He still won 59% of his D-1 games and a NCAA tourney game. And as I said above, some evaluators may see it differently than some on here do. We’ll see.
Last Edited: 2/3/2019 10:30:09 PM by colobobcat66
Showing Messages: 51 - 73 of 73
MAC News Links



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)