OUBobcat13: Should a Sweet 16 appearance be the benchmark of whether we have had a "successful" season or not? While I think it's an appropriate program goal to reach the Sweet 16, I don't think we have to take the attitude of "Sweet 16 or Bust."
Look at Gonzaga. I wonder if Mark Few is feeling heat from the fanbase re not reaching the Sweet 16 since 2009?
For a midmajor like Ohio, it's great to reach the Sweet 16 and we should strive to get there again. But it's a very infrequent occurrence...all the stars have to line up re: lack of injuries, good coaching, a veteran mid major team, getting through the mine field of your conference tournament, then getting the right matchups in the NCAA.
Just in talking to people around town here in Jackson and Athens, I do get the impression that now fans "expect" a Sweet 16 appearance and that anything less is unacceptable or "maybe OK but not that good."
Have we gotten so jaded and delusional in our expectations that we consider a season "not that good" if we don't reach the Sweet 16?
Just going off of what Jeff is saying here: do you know how hard it is to make the Sweet 16 repeatedly? A few years ago, only Xavier and Michigan State were the only two programs to reach the Sweet 16 three years in a row. I believe it was 2008-2010. And what happened the very next year? They both got bounced. Hell, Xavier didn't even make the tournament in 2013, only one year removed from a Sweet 16 in 2012.
If the Ohio fanbase continues on it's current path, it will end up in Butler land. Two Final Fours spoiled them dramatically. You know what happened at Butler before that? In their entire history, they only went to three Sweet Sixteens prior to those two seasons.
Bottom line: it's hard.
I would not expect to make the sweet 16 every year. I wouldn't expect to make it past the first (2nd I guess) round every year. But what I felt JG brought is a new excitement to the program. He was successful in the post-season. HE put Ohio Basketball on the map with his post-season success. I do believe he was on his way to taking Ohio Basketball to the "next level". By that I mean, consistent trip to the NCAA tournament. Some regular season wins over larger programs. Were we there yet? No. Are we there now? No. Is JC going to take us there...I personally don't feel he will. I do NOT consider this season a success. We were decent, but not great. I understand perhaps he hasn't had enough time to build the program. I hope that if he does stay for a few more years that you all are throwing this back in my face at how wrong I was. I can admit my mistakes.
I guess simply put, I want to see Ohio basketball talked about as a Mid-Major power, not a 5 seed in the MAC tourney. Elton Alexander (I know, I know) actually put my sentiments in writing just this morning. He talked of Creighton, Gonzaga, and Wichita State as being the face of their respective leagues. Ohio WAS on the verge of that. I'm not sure we still are. Is that an unfair, premature assessment of Jim Christian. Absolutely. I guess time will tell if it was an accurate one. As I said above, I hope I'm wrong.