I hate to rag on the guy but he did awful here. Pretty much just rode out the talent Groce gave him then left when it was gone. He returned a entire team that made the sweet 16 and couldn't even get them back to the tourney. I think a big share of the 10 win season we had this year has to fall on JC.
I love how the hardcore JC haters conveniently forget that the 2012 team placed third in the MAC, barely scraped past both Buffalo and Akron in the MAC tournament, then pulled a great upset in the NCAAs to make the Sweet Sixteen. Somehow doing something improbably made it OBVIOUS that the 2013 team HAD to at least match those accomplishments.
JC only went 24-10 with a share of the regular season championship and a made the title game in the MAC tournament in 2013. What a loser. Then the dirtbag went 25-12 in 2014 after graduating the core of a great team.
It's all revisionist BS history. Whatever you think of Groce, Christian or Phillips, the fact is that coaching changes hurt programs because kids decommit and transfer, and those that don't often don't fit the mold of the incumbent coach's strategy. There's no point in blaming a guy for leaving the cupboard bare because it's just what happens with a coaching change.