While I realize that certain phrases are overused and, thereby, lose there effectiveness and meaning, I think you underestimate what a home win against UK in a packed Convo would have done for the local psyche. This would have been the equivalent in local lore to the OHIO win over Pitt in Solich Year 1. If everyone who claims to have been at that game was actually there, Peden would have had a crowd of 45,000. I guess in the end we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one.
I'll play along.
I fully realize what beating UK at the Convo would have done for the local lore. For the record, the PITT win would not even hold a candle to what it would have been to beat UK here. There is NO equivalent in Ohio athletics that would be on par with beating UK in Athens that night that year.
That was my biggest gripe of the Hunter Era. Somehow he managed to have his very worst team, one of the worst in OHIO history, the year UK came calling. He knew about this game several years in advance and should have adjusted his recruiting, even if it meant bringing in some JUCOs, to have a representative team on the floor for that game. Instead, we had the Wilderness Campaign. Ugh!
SO..... you think he should have adjusted his recruiting not for the program but to have brought in a roster just for that game?
Two or three years was enough to insure that we didn't have one of the worst teams in OHIO history facing the Wildcats in the house. It was a shameful performance on Hunter's part. Truly shameful. You hit a nerve with this one.
And you further go on about the team that faced UK that night......as if you expected a competitive night. Let's get a little reality.
That UK team was 29 -4 on the heels of a stinging defeat in the 97 national Championship Final. 29 other teams (pretty good ones too!) Suffered a loss to them that year. Only 4 all high majors with pretty good programs were able to beat them.
That UK team was in Athens 3 days after a defeat at the hands of Louisille. Even on a good night seeing them was a formidable task....seeing them 3 nights after losing to UL. their arch rival, is stepping into a meat grinder. You think the battle of the bricks is a big deal....try holding up to the war that exists in the Bluegrass State.
That team was ripe with guys who had lost a National Champioship the year before to a pretty good Arizona club that went through kansas, NC and UK to win with Bibby, Pastner, Simon et al. UK was on a mission with vets Magliore, padgett and Nazr Mohammed. Pretty wild to think that the locals would be the only ones who would have thought the "lore" would be huge. That would have been one for the ages in mid major circles for all time.
I stayed away from this as it is one of those arguments that is silly and out of touch but when it got to sublimely ridiculous I jumped in. Agreeing to disagree about what? This was a slaughter waiting to happen even if we had a GREAT roster. I don't get into this type of conversation very often because arguing about games and rosters that only exist in folks minds is like too much for my brain....I can, however, say with great confidence that the probability of sneaking up on UK that year, that night with anything short of a hidden stash of all americans, horseshoe planted between your cheeks, A lucky clover in your pocket and some great home cooking that night was going to be quite a feat.
I don't underestimate the effect of a win that night in the history of OHIO, the local fanbase or even what it would mean to mid major sports in general but i really think you grossly OVER estimate OUr ability to have been competitive no matter who was on that team, the coaching staff or in the house that night.