I will say this, the type of kids they're after versus ours are two different caliber of player. The one I argue we got away with snagging from Ohio St. is maybe Dartis, but otherwise there is one other kid that could still end up a Buckeye. I don't think I need to mention his name here but does someone want to check into him graduating on time this year and being eligible to do so?
Also, I will say that Matta is re-committing to recruiting in state, idk if he will be able to see it thru though.
Ohio State never offered a scholarship to Dartis, so we didn't shag him away from TOSU.
I assume you are talking about Simmons as the kid possibly graduating early. I have raised the question several times on this site. I have even texted Arkley to suggest he check his status. My own opinion is that if he does graduate early and decide to leave, he won't go to Ohio State. The team does not appear to have any better prospects next year. He would have a better chance at reaching the NCAA staying put. Arguably their second/third best player, center Trevor Thompson, is himself a possibility to graduate and leave...
It's not about just recruiting in state, it's about getting the right kids. Mark Loving was a Mr. Basketball at Toledo St. Johns, but he is a significant under achiever in Columbus. David Bell from Cleveland? He's not a Big 10 talent, certainly not on a team that would be expected to got deep into March.
What's really changed in the last 10 years, maybe the last 5, is that the really best kids, those ranked in the top 20-25 nationally who are also from Ohio, no longer consider Ohio State or most other schools other than the Blue Bloods. Wasn't so a decade ago with Sullenger, Mullens and the like...
Over the long term, they need to keep kids like Jeremiah Francis, who right now is a top 25 sophomore. Two years from now they have Dane Goodwin from Upper Arlington committed. He has let it be known, at least for now, that he's solid at OSU even if Matta is no longer there. I expect next year he will be a preseason top 30 kid. I have seen him play a dozen times or more the last two years, and in my opinion he would play meaningful minutes for OSU right now.
Matta is an extremely decent guy, from what I hear. Saw him in an airport once, flying Southwest (you think Urban Meyer flies Southwest?) and he was nice to everyone. For the most part, his kids haven't caused trouble.
I just wonder if the whole program hasn't gotten stale...and that only a change at the top will freshen it.