A Bobcat Love sighting. A Flomo sighting. Where's Slimmy???? JSF???
Well...
The short take: College basketball makes it hard to enjoy college basketball.
The longer take: The Mid-American Conference (and Ohio by association, though to a lesser extent) are in a long, protracted death spiral. Players of Simmons's quality may come though less often. The MAC is kinda bad, Ohio is kinda mediocre, and ultimately it shouldn't surprise anyone if a really good program comes calling for someone and they decide to leave. What does OU have over Michigan? Weather? A better band?
Since 2002, here is Ohio's Kenpom numbers by year: 113, 168, 187, 85, 109, 125, 95, 169, 94, 150, 57, 82, 127, 232, 141, 105.
Since 2002, here's the MAC's Sagarin rankings by year: 11, 11, 15, 11, 13, 14, 12, 18, 15, 17, 15, 16, 12/19 (he started dividing by division to be difficult), 11/13, 13/14, 12/14.
Quite frankly, we've never been as good as we think we've been. And we can point to reasons or excuses... but you get to a point where that doesn't matter and all you have is the results. The MAC has had to fight furiously and make the best hires it possible could just to go to where it almost used to be... the problem is, the gap between, say, 8 and 11 is bigger than it was. And that gap is going to grow.
"This is all because of football!" Well, sure, but what do you mean? If you mean football is throwing trucks of money at middling power conference schools that enable them to spend on other programs, then yes, football is a factor here. If you mean the MAC and Ohio are throwing their money away on football and it's hurting basketball, I'm not so sure. I used to think that, but I'm looking at the Missouri Valley Conference. They don't have the football investment we do and they unquestionably have had more success than the MAC. Where did that get them? The loss of their best programs. Not sponsoring football seems to be less a vaccine than a palliative treatment that holds the pain off for a while. UNI is still kicking around (for now), but the MVC's days as mid-major ascendants are done. The Atlantic 10 isn't what it used to be, either, after the Big East split up. They don't play football either, but they have money. (I know most of these schools play football in some form; I'm talking about 1-A fubaw here.)
"Jim Christian ruined our opportunity in 2013!" Not really. First, there was no guarantee John Groce even gets us back to the tournament. We just don't know. Perhaps he holds practice at a different hour and DJ breaks his foot and the whole thing is shot. We probably lose to BG or something and don't go 14-2 in the conference. We probably don't beat Memphis anyway and we're hoping to win in Cleveland like always and who knows what happens on any given night? And if we do repeat, who do we draw? VCU would've licked us, too. Fact of the matter is, our tournament draw in 2012 was WAY more helpful than we had any reason to hope for. There's so much luck that goes into this and that's not a thing many want to admit.
Groce leaving was something largely beyond our control. So let's say Christian gets us back to the dance and we win another game or two. What after that? I don't see his recruiting getting and better. Here's the secret for a mid-major to rise to the national stage: You have to do it for more than one recruiting cycle. Every conference that's not a bottom feeder has a team that was really good for a couple years, then fell back to the back. There wasn't another DJ Cooper walking through that door. People point to Gonzaga and Butler. What they did was follow a once-in-a-generation coach with a once-in-a-lifetime coach who could bring in a superstar player to keep the momentum going. Both schools had to made *several* good runs in the tournament to be a national player. Seeing as we can count on one hand how many times that's happened at our level, appreciate how rare that is. It just wasn't going to happen in Athens, no matter how awesome it would be.
We're something like #120 in spending. And with some peaks and valleys, that's pretty much where we've been as a program. And that's not bad! There's a lot of debate on Saul as a coach. I think he's pretty good and most of the time we'll be in the high double digits or the low triple digits. Maybe one year we catch fire and get into the top 60 or something. I'm not expecting that as the norm because the history suggests that's not realistic.
So that's where we are: An OK program in a decidedly unexciting conference. And that's where we've been for a long time, if not always. There's two things to do about it: Find an Appalachian T. Boone Pickens or enjoy it for what it is. Most programs would trade their history for ours. Don't lose sight of that. We've gotten to witness some really cool stuff! I'm going to root for Ohio, be happy when they win, and be sad for a little bit when they lose. If that's not good enough for you, that's your right. Just be prepared to put something behind your words. And, for Heaven's sake, Golden Rule. What happened here? Everything here is just bitter fighting, trolling, and arguing. That's not what Bobcat Attack was. People wonder why some don't come around anymore. Maybe it's because they don't recognize the place and it doesn't seem like a good use of time or energy. That goes to the people here AND our former players. I hope Jaaron does well at Michigan; I think it makes us look better when our people succeed in other places rather than fail.
Just... just hope they find a way to replace that ESPN money when it runs out. Because it's going to get *real* ugly otherwise.