Schaus hired Jim Christian, Saul Phillips and Jeff Boals. He gets no praise from me.
Saul Philips was a great hire that didn't pan out, but I think that was mostly due to injuries during his tenure. I'd like to have seen what would have happened if his teams stayed healthy.
Jeff Boals until last hear was considered a great hire and who knows what's going on right now, but Schauss felt pressure to hire him after he was turned away a couple times previous, a lot by the same folks on this board who are calling for his removal now. We are a team full of solid supporting players without a go-to stud or a dead-eye shooter. It won't take much to right the ship and I hope Boals can do it.
I think if Schauss wasn't already with a foot out the door, he would have avoided hiring a beloved alum as our coach. he hired him when he knew he wouldn't be here for any potential fall-out.
If Campbell (credit to Christian) doesn’t go down, that team wins the MAC — I’m not sure I can label Saul a terrible hire initially, with initially being the key word. Saul’s bridge of players from that team to potentially the next core of Preston/BVP was just awful. We know what happened after that in year 2 of Boals. Boals has been experiencing that since UVA. He collectively hasn’t been able to put together a good enough roster.
But I agree with your sentiment. Now that we’re experiencing a downward trend under Boals, perhaps Schaus saw something that made him hesitant all those years when it came to hiring Boals. Since he was on his way out, he didn’t have to worry if it went well or not.
I mean, Saul just had the barrage of bad news happen during his tenure.
-Campbell injury
-Ryan Taylor transfer out
-Jaaron Simmons transfer out
-Jason Carter transfer out
-BVP injury
-Lingering injuries to Mike Laster, Gavin Block and Jordan Dartis throughout their careers
Ultimately a lot of that does fall on the coach, but there seemed to be some divine intervention going on at the time. Saul's potential Year 2 and Year 3 (especially) lineups if everything had stayed in place would have been crazy good. Saw a glimpse of what could have been before Tony went down in 2016-17, as they were 11-3 and started MAC play unbeaten.
Last Edited: 1/29/2026 1:07:57 PM by GoCats105