If we remove the Bobcat alum title from Boals resume, are we really giving him that much grace at this point?
This is an excellent question. Made me want to do a comparison using coaches who have lasted this long.
Boals 7-year resume
125-87 (69-48 MAC)
1 NCAA Tournament appearance, 1 NCAA Tournament win, 1 20-win regular season
MAC regular season finishes (7th, 5th, 3rd, 5th, 2nd, 4th)
O'Shea 7-year resume
120-95 (66-57 MAC)
1 NCAA Tournament appearance, 0 20-win regular seasons
MAC regular season finishes (3rd, 5th, 5th, 2nd, 4th, 4th, 3rd - note these are division finishes since the conference was split then, his overall finishes are much worse)
Hunter 7-year resume
125-83 (73-47 MAC)
1 NCAA Tournament appearance, 1 NIT appearance, 2 20-win regular seasons
MAC regular season finishes (8th, 5th, 4th, 4th, 1st, 2nd, 4th)
I've posted this before - but I'll gladly take the opportunity to post it again since it was brought up above.
Ohio HC All-Time Wins
1. Jim Snyder - 355 (25 seasons)
2. Larry Hunter - 204 (12 seasons)
3. Butch Grover - 192 (16 seasons)
4. Dutch Trautwein - 136 (11 seasons)
5. Jeff Boals - 125 (6+ seasons)
6. Tim O'Shea - 120 (7 seasons)
7. Danny Nee - 107 (6 seasons)
8. John Groce - 85 (4 seasons)
9. Saul Phillips - 81 (5 seasons)
10. Dale Bandy - 69 (6 seasons)
But - they played different quantities of games per year you say. Sure. Let's look at pct.
Ohio HC All-Time Winning Pct
1. RW Finsterwald: 34-6 .850 (2 seasons)
2. Jim Christian: 49-22 .690 (2 seasons)
3. Danny Nee: 107-67 .615 (6 seasons)
4. John Groce: 85-56 .603 (4 seasons)
5. Dutch Trautwein: 136-90 .602 (11 seasons)
6. Butch Grover: 192-129 .598 (16 seasons)
7. Jim Snyder: 355-245 .592 (25 seasons)
8. Jeff Boals: 125-87 .590 (6+ seasons) (fell below Snyder with the Kent loss)
9. Larry Hunter: 204-148 .580 (12 seasons)
10. Tim O'Shea: 120-95 .558 (7 seasons)
How about winning in March in Cleveland/NCAA when it really matters (Yes, NOTHING MATTERS BUT MARCH).
Ohio HC All-Time MAC Tournament Winning Pct
1. John Groce: 9-2 .818 (2 titles)
2. Jeff Boals: 7-4 .636 (1 title)
3. Tim O'Shea: 9-6 .600 (1 title)
4. Danny Nee: 6-4 .600 (2 titles)
5. Jim Christian: 3-2 .600 (0 titles)
6. Billy Hahn: 3-3 .500 (0 titles)
7. Larry Hunter: 9-10 .474 (1 title)
8. Saul Phillips: 2-5 .286 (0 titles)
9. Dale Bandy: 0-0 .000 (0 titles) (Didn't qualify in his last season)
What about before the MAC tournament? Look at total NCAA appearances (or NIT prior to NCAA being main tournament).
Ohio HC All-Time Tournament/League Champ Appearances
1. John Groce: 2 trips in 4 seasons (2.0 seasons/champ)
2. RW Finsterwald: 1 championship in 2 seasons (2.0 seasons/champ)
3. Danny Nee: 2 trips in 6 seasons (3.0 seasons/champ)
4. Jim Snyder: 7 trips in 25 seasons (3.57 seasons/champ)
5. Butch Grover: 3 championships in 16 seasons (5.33 seasons/champ)
6. Jeff Boals: 1 trip in 6+ seasons (6.00 seasons/champ)
7. Tim O'Shea: 1 trip in 7 seasons (7.00 seasons/champ)
8. Dutch Trautwein: 1 NIT in 11 seasons (11.00 seasons/champ)
9. Larry Hunter: 1 trip in 12 seasons (12.00 seasons/champ)
10. All Remaining coaches: 0 trips in 29 seasons
Ohio total: 19 trips (14 NCAA, 1 NIT (when it was main tourney) and 4 "league championships) in 118 seasons - averaging one trip every 6.21 seasons historically.