The State University of New York at Buffalo was also just declared a flagship institution and is the largest in New York. AAU membership is a big deal and Buffalo has the highest academic rankings in the conference. Given all of that, it is truly an outlier in the MAC. On paper, the biggest school in a big state would be a P5 member. In fact, of the 30 most populous states, the only other exception is UMass.
Buffalo actually is #93 in the latest addition of the USNWR ahead of Fiami. AAU membership they do have but they are on the lower end of that membership which is reevaluated so they could drop back out of it.
MAC generally comprises mid tier universities. Miami of everyone in the MAC had the most momentum of being perceived as a upper tier university but they could never quite get there without med/law schools. They are a very good mid tier university and the same I believe could be said for Buffalo and Ohio.
EMU/Akron are poor excuses for a mid tier university and are using MAC membership to help prop up their images compared to lower tier offerings. At least that is why I felt they've been steadfast about keeping football and staying in the MAC when they feel more like a Horizon League university.
Here's a good snapshot view of where research universities stand on the food chain using nine metrics that rank everything from research dollars to fundraising to faculty quality and median SAT scores. You can look at a ranking of all universities together or just private or just public. You're right that Buffalo is kind of near the bottom, but I'd guess that Kansas or Missouri would be next up on the chopping block.
https://mup.umass.edu/sites/default/files/mup-2019-top-am... As for Miami, I've stated it here before. They benefited immensely from their former President rigging the system as Regents Chair in the 60s and 70s to make them the only selective public university in the state. Once they lost that advantage, they've plummeted back to their historical norm of being just another "Four Corners" college. Also, while Fiami lacks a med and law school, they are also a complete non-entity as a Ph.D granting research university.
Anyways, this is a great and significant achievement for Ohio. It's not AAU membership, but it is something truly substantive that will help our national preception, ability to grow our research footprint and to attract students and faculty.
Last Edited: 2/2/2022 7:27:14 PM by OUPride