General Ohio University Discussion/Alumni Events Topic
Topic: OHIO Named Carnegie Research 1 Institution
Page: 1 of 1
mail
person
GroverBall
1/31/2022 6:37 PM
Ohio University reaches the top classification level with 140 other institutions:

https://www.ohio.edu/news/2022/01/ohio-university-joins-h...

https://carnegieclassifications.iu.edu/lookup/srp.php?clq...

This is a big deal Bobcats.
mail
person
Jeff McKinney
1/31/2022 10:43 PM
Great to hear!
mail
The Optimist
2/1/2022 6:47 AM
That sounds like quite the honor!

Is this a distinction we've held before or is this a first?
mail
person
GroverBall
2/1/2022 12:22 PM
The Optimist wrote:expand_more
That sounds like quite the honor!

Is this a distinction we've held before or is this a first?
Pretty sure this is a first, I know university administrations have been aiming for higher classification for decades. I believe Dr. Ping led our last jump.
mail
person
rpbobcat
2/1/2022 1:47 PM
Was a little (more then a little actually) surprised to see Kent State and Buffalo on the list.

Don't tend to think of them as high level research institutions.
mail
person
SBH
2/1/2022 2:03 PM
Not surprised by Buffalo but initially so for Kent until I considered their Liquid Crystals Institute.
mail
person
mf279801
2/1/2022 4:07 PM
rpbobcat wrote:expand_more
Was a little (more then a little actually) surprised to see Kent State and Buffalo on the list.

Don't tend to think of them as high level research institutions.
Buffalo certainly is. Don’t think of them as a directional NY school. They’re the flagship of the SUNY system (or co-flagship with Stony Brook). I might be somewhat biased (my graduate degree is from Buffalo), but Buffalo has a substantially higher profile than we do for research
Last Edited: 2/1/2022 4:09:18 PM by mf279801
mail
RSBobcat
2/1/2022 9:53 PM
mf279801 wrote:expand_more
Was a little (more then a little actually) surprised to see Kent State and Buffalo on the list.

Don't tend to think of them as high level research institutions.
Buffalo certainly is. Don’t think of them as a directional NY school. They’re the flagship of the SUNY system (or co-flagship with Stony Brook). I might be somewhat biased (my graduate degree is from Buffalo), but Buffalo has a substantially higher profile than we do for research
Yet - In spite of the apparent high level of research - The question lingers - "What is Buffalo?" :)
mail
person
mf279801
2/1/2022 10:13 PM
RSBobcat wrote:expand_more
Was a little (more then a little actually) surprised to see Kent State and Buffalo on the list.

Don't tend to think of them as high level research institutions.
Buffalo certainly is. Don’t think of them as a directional NY school. They’re the flagship of the SUNY system (or co-flagship with Stony Brook). I might be somewhat biased (my graduate degree is from Buffalo), but Buffalo has a substantially higher profile than we do for research
Yet - In spite of the apparent high level of research - The question lingers - "What is Buffalo?" :)
Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_buffalo_Buffalo_buf...
mail
Cellis033
2/1/2022 11:13 PM
This certification means we are on the same level of research institution as Yale and MIT. TAKE THAT NERDS!
Last Edited: 2/1/2022 11:13:20 PM by Cellis033
mail
JSF
2/1/2022 11:18 PM
mf279801 wrote:expand_more
Was a little (more then a little actually) surprised to see Kent State and Buffalo on the list.

Don't tend to think of them as high level research institutions.
Buffalo certainly is. Don’t think of them as a directional NY school. They’re the flagship of the SUNY system (or co-flagship with Stony Brook). I might be somewhat biased (my graduate degree is from Buffalo), but Buffalo has a substantially higher profile than we do for research
UB is lowkey a very good school. Got into the AAU a few years ago.
mail
person
Recovering Journalist
2/2/2022 9:27 AM
The State University of New York at Buffalo was also just declared a flagship institution and is the largest in New York. AAU membership is a big deal and Buffalo has the highest academic rankings in the conference. Given all of that, it is truly an outlier in the MAC. On paper, the biggest school in a big state would be a P5 member. In fact, of the 30 most populous states, the only other exception is UMass.
mail
TWT
2/2/2022 5:50 PM
Recovering Journalist wrote:expand_more
The State University of New York at Buffalo was also just declared a flagship institution and is the largest in New York. AAU membership is a big deal and Buffalo has the highest academic rankings in the conference. Given all of that, it is truly an outlier in the MAC. On paper, the biggest school in a big state would be a P5 member. In fact, of the 30 most populous states, the only other exception is UMass.
Buffalo actually is #93 in the latest addition of the USNWR ahead of Fiami. AAU membership they do have but they are on the lower end of that membership which is reevaluated so they could drop back out of it.

MAC generally comprises mid tier universities. Miami of everyone in the MAC had the most momentum of being perceived as a upper tier university but they could never quite get there without med/law schools. They are a very good mid tier university and the same I believe could be said for Buffalo and Ohio.

EMU/Akron are poor excuses for a mid tier university and are using MAC membership to help prop up their images compared to lower tier offerings. At least that is why I felt they've been steadfast about keeping football and staying in the MAC when they feel more like a Horizon League university.
mail
person
OUPride
2/2/2022 7:25 PM
Club Hyatt wrote:expand_more
The State University of New York at Buffalo was also just declared a flagship institution and is the largest in New York. AAU membership is a big deal and Buffalo has the highest academic rankings in the conference. Given all of that, it is truly an outlier in the MAC. On paper, the biggest school in a big state would be a P5 member. In fact, of the 30 most populous states, the only other exception is UMass.
Buffalo actually is #93 in the latest addition of the USNWR ahead of Fiami. AAU membership they do have but they are on the lower end of that membership which is reevaluated so they could drop back out of it.

MAC generally comprises mid tier universities. Miami of everyone in the MAC had the most momentum of being perceived as a upper tier university but they could never quite get there without med/law schools. They are a very good mid tier university and the same I believe could be said for Buffalo and Ohio.

EMU/Akron are poor excuses for a mid tier university and are using MAC membership to help prop up their images compared to lower tier offerings. At least that is why I felt they've been steadfast about keeping football and staying in the MAC when they feel more like a Horizon League university.
Here's a good snapshot view of where research universities stand on the food chain using nine metrics that rank everything from research dollars to fundraising to faculty quality and median SAT scores. You can look at a ranking of all universities together or just private or just public. You're right that Buffalo is kind of near the bottom, but I'd guess that Kansas or Missouri would be next up on the chopping block.


https://mup.umass.edu/sites/default/files/mup-2019-top-am...

As for Miami, I've stated it here before. They benefited immensely from their former President rigging the system as Regents Chair in the 60s and 70s to make them the only selective public university in the state. Once they lost that advantage, they've plummeted back to their historical norm of being just another "Four Corners" college. Also, while Fiami lacks a med and law school, they are also a complete non-entity as a Ph.D granting research university.

Anyways, this is a great and significant achievement for Ohio. It's not AAU membership, but it is something truly substantive that will help our national preception, ability to grow our research footprint and to attract students and faculty.
Last Edited: 2/2/2022 7:27:14 PM by OUPride
mail
person
BillyTheCat
2/3/2022 10:23 PM
Now that we are a Tier I research institution, we would now qualify for membership into the Big10. We should move on stadium expansion now and make that move.
mail
person
Deciduous Forest Cat
2/4/2022 8:49 AM
Someone help me out here... Is this the same as the Tier ranking that is often used to rank schools? Are we officially a Tier I Research Institution or is that a separate categorization?
mail
person
Alan Swank
2/5/2022 8:31 AM
Here's a bit more clarity on the matter. I wonder how much of an influence the Edison Center has on this.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_research_universiti...
mail
TWT
2/8/2022 7:48 AM
OUPride wrote:expand_more
The State University of New York at Buffalo was also just declared a flagship institution and is the largest in New York. AAU membership is a big deal and Buffalo has the highest academic rankings in the conference. Given all of that, it is truly an outlier in the MAC. On paper, the biggest school in a big state would be a P5 member. In fact, of the 30 most populous states, the only other exception is UMass.
Buffalo actually is #93 in the latest addition of the USNWR ahead of Fiami. AAU membership they do have but they are on the lower end of that membership which is reevaluated so they could drop back out of it.

MAC generally comprises mid tier universities. Miami of everyone in the MAC had the most momentum of being perceived as a upper tier university but they could never quite get there without med/law schools. They are a very good mid tier university and the same I believe could be said for Buffalo and Ohio.

EMU/Akron are poor excuses for a mid tier university and are using MAC membership to help prop up their images compared to lower tier offerings. At least that is why I felt they've been steadfast about keeping football and staying in the MAC when they feel more like a Horizon League university.
Here's a good snapshot view of where research universities stand on the food chain using nine metrics that rank everything from research dollars to fundraising to faculty quality and median SAT scores. You can look at a ranking of all universities together or just private or just public. You're right that Buffalo is kind of near the bottom, but I'd guess that Kansas or Missouri would be next up on the chopping block.
Buffalo is ranked in between Illinois-Chicago and the University of Hawaii in federal research dollars. Significantly below the University of Cincinnati. Its not correct to brand Buffalo as being among the very top universities in the country on the basis of having AAU membership. The same for Ohio with the R1 designation.

I do like the broadening out of the MAC academic reputation over the last couple of decades. Buffalo, Ohio, Kent with the R1s. Medical schools at WMU and CMU. It might not be long before WMU earns a R1 with the 500 million dollar academic gift. Toledo of course is one of the few universities with a medical, law, pharmacy and engineering college.
mail
OhioCatFan
2/8/2022 10:36 AM
Club Hyatt wrote:expand_more
The State University of New York at Buffalo was also just declared a flagship institution and is the largest in New York. AAU membership is a big deal and Buffalo has the highest academic rankings in the conference. Given all of that, it is truly an outlier in the MAC. On paper, the biggest school in a big state would be a P5 member. In fact, of the 30 most populous states, the only other exception is UMass.
Buffalo actually is #93 in the latest addition of the USNWR ahead of Fiami. AAU membership they do have but they are on the lower end of that membership which is reevaluated so they could drop back out of it.

MAC generally comprises mid tier universities. Miami of everyone in the MAC had the most momentum of being perceived as a upper tier university but they could never quite get there without med/law schools. They are a very good mid tier university and the same I believe could be said for Buffalo and Ohio.

EMU/Akron are poor excuses for a mid tier university and are using MAC membership to help prop up their images compared to lower tier offerings. At least that is why I felt they've been steadfast about keeping football and staying in the MAC when they feel more like a Horizon League university.
Here's a good snapshot view of where research universities stand on the food chain using nine metrics that rank everything from research dollars to fundraising to faculty quality and median SAT scores. You can look at a ranking of all universities together or just private or just public. You're right that Buffalo is kind of near the bottom, but I'd guess that Kansas or Missouri would be next up on the chopping block.
Buffalo is ranked in between Illinois-Chicago and the University of Hawaii in federal research dollars. Significantly below the University of Cincinnati. Its not correct to brand Buffalo as being among the very top universities in the country on the basis of having AAU membership. The same for Ohio with the R1 designation.

I do like the broadening out of the MAC academic reputation over the last couple of decades. Buffalo, Ohio, Kent with the R1s. Medical schools at WMU and CMU. It might not be long before WMU earns a R1 with the 500 million dollar academic gift. Toledo of course is one of the few universities with a medical, law, pharmacy and engineering college.
The current UT medical school was an independent school called the Medical School of Ohio until it was acquired by UT. They had another medical school many years earlier that was of such poor quality that it was closed after the 1910 Flexner Report that evaluated all of the medical schools in the United States.
Showing Messages: 1 - 19 of 19
MAC News Links



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)