I have a former superintendent that once said, "Everyone feels like they're an expert on schools because they went to one." Everybody has a thousand answers on how to fix 'failing public schools' but don't notice that there are a number of successes currently.
If you look at HS graduation rates, the numbers are higher than they have ever been (82% in 2012-2013). That's not perfect (and Ohio as a state is embarrassingly poor in the difference b/w black students--63% and white students--87%). These are real statistics, nothing cooked here:
https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_coi.asp There are amazing improvements being made at public schools across the country. I have had the great fortune of mentoring a number of schools in their desire to change, and it is frustrating to see somebody take the lead who has no clue about the advancements being made in public education.
Is there room for more improvement? Absolutely. No question. But as somebody who sometimes butts heads with the teacher unions, I don't feel that they're the villain they're often made out to be. Sure, you hear anecdotal stories of the teachers in New York in the rubber room, and they color your vision. But I work with professional educators daily and guarantee that is not a representative sample.
On-line learning, charter schools, and parochial schools are not the answers to many of our underlying education problems. There's a paradigm shift occurring in public education that is something remarkable. The discussion is not about what is taught, it is about what is learned. The public education revolution is being driven by some fantastic minds such as Robert Marzano, Richard DuFour, Tom Schimmer, Thomas Guskey, John Hattie, and so many other brilliant leaders. My dream would be to see somebody who has revolutionary ideas lead education, not somebody with an agenda.
My desire as an education leader is to see Ms. DeVos rejected by the senate. This is not a political desire, it is a professional one. I know that I would have no ability to lead the National Intelligence Agency because I have no experience in that world. The Secretary of Education is the thought leader for all public education in this country, and to select somebody who is opposed to it is quite demoralizing to the profession.