... Every year though we get people throwing their stuff up here that can't play DII ball. ...
That's a fact. Every year we get some people posting on here about how good they are, yet they never end up with any Division I offers. It's the coaches that decide who to offer, though, not the fans.
Ohio does have a great history of DB's in recent years. Corners Byrum, Wright, Parsons, and Turner each managed Free Agent contracts to the NFL. Byrum, Parsons, and Turner all made the practice squads, and Byrum did get some actual NFL playing time, but I'm not sure on Parson and Turner. Wright was poised to make at least the practice squad, and perhaps the final cut until he had an ankle injury that effectively ended his NFL career before it started.
At Safety, Michael Mitchell was a 2d round draft choice last year, and is playing for Oakland.