Jeff, thanks again, I really appreciate this refresher course in Glouster area schools. You have a good handle on this issue. I do have one additional question. Are you sure that Nelsonville was an exempted village school district? I remember that Chauncey-Dover was an exempted village. I thought that Nelsonville was a city school district back in the late '50s and early '60s when I was at Athens High. They were a member of the SEOAL then, and Nelsonville was at that time large enough to be classified as a city under Ohio law. They flirted in and out of this designation over the years. I think they are now classified as a "town." The hierarchy, if I remember correctly, is city, town and village. Glouster is village, I believe. Again, thanks for the information and I enjoy the exchange and learning more about local history.
I could be mistaken about Nelsonville as to whether it was a city school district or exempted village district. In any case it was merged with Buchtel-York somewhere along the line to form the present Nelsonville-York school district. In the 1960's and 1970's the State Board of Education forced consolidation of most of the school districts in Athens County. Besides Nelsonville-York and Trimble (J-T and Glouster), Chauncey-Dover and The Plains merged with Athens; Albany, Shade, and Waterloo were consolidated to form Alexander; and Ames-Bern, Rome-Canaan, and Carthage-Troy were merged to form Federal Hocking.
As you wrote, in football, Athens and Nelsonville were in the SEOAL; J-T, Chauncey-Dover, and the Plains played in the SEOBL (South Eastern Ohio Buckeye League). Glouster played in the Muskingum Valley Leage (MVL). Those were the only schools in Athens County that fielded football teams. These teams also played basketball in the same leagues. In addition, for basketball and baseball, the Athens County School District (which supervised all the school districts except Athens, Nelsonville, and Glouster), sponsored it's own league (the Athens County League) which had both regular season champions and ran end-of-season tournaments for basketball and baseball, the winners passing on into the state playoff system.