Why complain about today?
Correct if I'm wrong (the lines forms to the right, please) ... but isn't a bowl supposed to be a reward for a good season. Not a mediocre one?
Last year 15 teams that went 6-6 "earned" a bowl bid? In 2017, 17 6-6 teams and three teams with losing records!
C'mon! What are we doing here?
I agree ... in 1997, the bowl system was a mess. You had 6-5 Pitt earning a bowl bid over 8-3 Ohio. (And total sidenote ... Ohio that year won at Maryland, at Hawaii, lost by 3 at K-State in non-conference. A little different from playing Hampton, UMass, Idaho and Kentucky)
So it's better there are more bowls than there were in 1997. But I think it's gone too far. Do we really need 40+ bowl games?!?!
We're rewarding teams for being average ...
Aside from that ... what I have a bigger problem with is the bowl tie-ins. It's just another massive stake driven between the "haves" and "have-nots" in CFB. The P6 & G5 schools.
If you're going to have 40+ bowls ... why do they have to be P5 vs. P5 and G5 vs. G5 games?!?
Wouldn't it be much more interesting to see a 12-1 Buffalo team get to face a 9-3 P5 school rather than facing off with a Sun Belt team?
Hell, I'd rather see a 12-1 Buffalo team face a 7-5 P5 team!
These Arkansas St vs. Toledo ... Georgia Southern vs. NIU ... Ohio vs. Troy match-ups every single year get old and stale.
Just like the Virginia Tech vs. Wisconsin battle of 7-5 teams does.
The fact all these bowls are locked into certain conferences takes away a ton of the luster (along with the fact there are too many of them)
It was pretty evident when this season started that no matter how good any MAC school was ... they were most likely headed for Mobile, AL and the Dollar General Bowl. Woo. Hoo.
Even if Buffalo went 13-0 ... that was the best they would do. Because even the divide between the MWC/AAC and the Sun Belt/MAC in the G5 has grown.
CFB is a mess. Period. We can have 40+ bowl games ... but we can't figure out a way to play an actual playoff where more than four teams are involved?
You have nearly a month between conference championship Saturday and the major bowl games.
You're telling me that you can't have a 8 or 10 team playoff that starts in mid-Dec?
I think we're going to see a potential mutiny if the playoff ends up Notre Dame, Alabama, Georgia and Clemson this year ... especially if Washington State goes 12-1 and wins PAC-12 and WVU wins Big XII at 11-1 and Ohio $t or Michigan wins B1G at 12-1.
Three power five teams left out would certainly raise some eyebrows.
The stubbornness and greed of CFB is ruining it.
Bottom line is ..... yeah, I might be a crotchety old man ... but I like to see good teams get rewarded ... mediocre teams forced to get better .... and everyone starts the season not already knowing their best-case scenario.
Last Edited: 11/14/2018 9:37:08 AM by bshot44