Cheerguy,
Under the hypothetical that we are discussing (Ohio goes 13-0), the likelihood of a C-USA, WAC or MWC tean also being undefeated is probably relatively slim. So what I'm saying is that if we are the only non-BCS team that's undefeated, even given our relatively crappy schedule (BL please note), we would get the BCS bowl invite.
Do you really think that minus the congressional anti-trust talk that Utah would have gotten a BCS Bowl bid in 2004? Do you remember all of the politicking that came into play toward the end of the season about how much weight should be given to human votes v. computer rankings and the indications that a "groundswell" was developing in favor of Utah? Even then, the Utah AG accussed the BCS of anti-trust violation since the Utes were not in the so-called national championship game. You just can't ignore the politics in this whole scenario.
If by 2004 you mean 2008, THEN I'd be fololowing you. In 2004 the national champ game was between an undefeated USC (although victories since have been vacated) and an undefeated Oklahoma team. Utah while undeafeated didn't feel cheated out of the BCS title game.
In 2008, a 1 loss Oklahoma team went to the BCS title game to face a 1 loss Florida team istead of Utah, who was undefeated, getting the go ahead. Utah finished 6th in the BCS standings, behind 5 teams that all had 1 loss. THIS is when all the anti-trust stuff came into play on a national level.
That same year, had Ball State ended up beating Buffalo for the MAC title, Bal State STILL would have not made a BCS bowl, despite being 12th in the standings prior to the MAC title game, because of Utah.
Notable games for Utah that year:
@#24 Michigan (25-23)
@Air Force (30-23)
Oregan State (who had just knocked off USC the week before) (31-28)
#11TCU (13-10)
#14 BYU (48-24)
Notable games for Ball State that year:
Navy (35-23)
@CMU (31-24)
@Indiana (42-20)
So no matter what hypothetical situation you want to throw out, due to the sos and playing the the MAC there is NO way Ohio makes a BCS bowl this year.
Like it or not a 1 loss Boise, TCU, or Utah, possibly even Fresno State gets a nod before Ohio does. The ONLY way Ohio makes a BCS bowl game this year is if they run the table AND a BCS conf. champ (mostly likely the ACC Champ baed on recent trends) has somewhere in the neighborhood of 5 losses (Last years champ had 4).
Last Edited: 7/14/2010 7:25:37 PM by OrlandoCat