menu
Logo
Ohio Football Topic
Topic: Time for the MAC to...
Page: 2 of 4
John C. Wanamaker
General User
Member Since: 1/2/2005
Post Count: 1,103
mail
John C. Wanamaker
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 11:48 AM
Wes wrote:expand_more
If we leave the MAC where do we go? Ideally, the best of the MAC and C-USA East need to disband and form 2 new confrences; I think the Big East might even be involved if the football/basketball split ever occurs.


Just a question for you-is Ohio among the best of the MAC? 


CMU is probably the most coveted MAC school, if any of them are coveted. After that I don't know what other schools would be above us.


If we're talking football, I'd have to say that Miami, Toledo and Bowling Green are ahead of us.  They have much more of a winning tradition over the last 25-30 years and have better facilities.  Facitilty-wise we're not even in the same ballpark as those schools.


I disagree with you completely on this. Miami has only one MAC championship in the last 25 years and that one is now 7 or 8 years ago. Overall Peden Stadium is a better facility than BG's, particularly the grounds and the tailgating park. Its an awesome setting for college football. Tradition really is what a program has done in the last 5-10 years. Boise State as an example is regarded as having a lot of tradition and they didn't have WAC titles in the 80's. They have a tradition of playing on TV, earning top 25 rankings over the last 5-10 years. TCU is the same way, the program was on life support drawing 12,000 a game in the early 80's. Where is TCU today? Colorado State was the top MWC/WAC teams in the 90's with top 20 rankings only to be reduced to the level of Wyoming in recent years. Things change. I can tell you though the most coveted school in the MAC right now is Temple with its large Philadelphia market and a program that is building tradition.



HMMMM.......not real good at math, as Doc and I went to the same High School ;) but isn't Miami's one MAC title in the past 25 years, one more than our total?

Peden is NOT a better facility than Doyt other than the fact that Peden has a nice brick look.  Doyt is bigger, more parking, larger concessions, more bathrooms, larger press box, more locker rooms, has a nicer administrative wing with recuriting and hospitality area, and their new endzone addition is pretty nice.

http://www.bgsu.edu/map/buildings/page13976.html

Last Edited: 8/22/2010 11:49:18 AM by John C. Wanamaker
Athens
General User
A
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Alexandria, VA
Post Count: 5,454
person
mail
Athens
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 12:16 PM
John C. Wanamaker wrote:expand_more
If we leave the MAC where do we go? Ideally, the best of the MAC and C-USA East need to disband and form 2 new confrences; I think the Big East might even be involved if the football/basketball split ever occurs.


Just a question for you-is Ohio among the best of the MAC? 


CMU is probably the most coveted MAC school, if any of them are coveted. After that I don't know what other schools would be above us.


If we're talking football, I'd have to say that Miami, Toledo and Bowling Green are ahead of us.  They have much more of a winning tradition over the last 25-30 years and have better facilities.  Facitilty-wise we're not even in the same ballpark as those schools.


I disagree with you completely on this. Miami has only one MAC championship in the last 25 years and that one is now 7 or 8 years ago. Overall Peden Stadium is a better facility than BG's, particularly the grounds and the tailgating park. Its an awesome setting for college football. Tradition really is what a program has done in the last 5-10 years. Boise State as an example is regarded as having a lot of tradition and they didn't have WAC titles in the 80's. They have a tradition of playing on TV, earning top 25 rankings over the last 5-10 years. TCU is the same way, the program was on life support drawing 12,000 a game in the early 80's. Where is TCU today? Colorado State was the top MWC/WAC teams in the 90's with top 20 rankings only to be reduced to the level of Wyoming in recent years. Things change. I can tell you though the most coveted school in the MAC right now is Temple with its large Philadelphia market and a program that is building tradition.



HMMMM.......not real good at math, as Doc and I went to the same High School ;) but isn't Miami's one MAC title in the past 25 years, one more than our total?

Peden is NOT a better facility than Doyt other than the fact that Peden has a nice brick look.  Doyt is bigger, more parking, larger concessions, more bathrooms, larger press box, more locker rooms, has a nicer administrative wing with recuriting and hospitality area, and their new endzone addition is pretty nice.

http://www.bgsu.edu/map/buildings/page13976.html

>


Peden also has team meeting rooms, hydrotherapy rehab pool, a few things BG does not. Overall its my opinion that its a better house than the cavernous BG stadium. You are taking Miami's success relative against ours. What you should be looking at is how much tradition does 1 MAC championship in a quarter century mean on the national landscape? That is like arguing who is the tallest midget. Further I will say the conditions that resulted in Miami having success in the 70's has changed when all the MAC schools were targeting the same Ohio players. The majority of Kent State's team is not from Ohio and they are a much better program right now than Miami. The MAC has 13 schools now which makes a MAC Championship harder to come by. Its a different day and age. Temple is favored to win the MAC Championship. You need to get with the times and stop blaming the MAC or tradition on our football fortunes (we have 2 division titles in the last 4 years). This is why I don't like to post much on this board its like a timewarp from 1984 (music references, clothing styles included).
John C. Wanamaker
General User
Member Since: 1/2/2005
Post Count: 1,103
mail
John C. Wanamaker
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 12:24 PM
I am simply asking about your math on the miami thing.  We have zero titles, not sure that puts us in any position to say we have more or anything with the exception of futility.  The only thing that Peden has that Bowling Green does not is those stupid Touchdown Club seats that the department is trying to give away, because they are the worse "premium" seats in the country. 

As for the tubs, OHIO University went for over 5 years with NO rehab pools period, and there are still NONE for the athletes at the Convocation center.
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 12:25:28 PM by John C. Wanamaker
Athens
General User
A
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Alexandria, VA
Post Count: 5,454
person
mail
Athens
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 12:59 PM
John C. Wanamaker wrote:expand_more
I am simply asking about your math on the miami thing.  We have zero titles, not sure that puts us in any position to say we have more or anything with the exception of futility.  The only thing that Peden has that Bowling Green does not is those stupid Touchdown Club seats that the department is trying to give away, because they are the worse "premium" seats in the country. 

As for the tubs, OHIO University went for over 5 years with NO rehab pools period, and there are still NONE for the athletes at the Convocation center.


From what I have read, very few schools out there even have hydrotheraphy pools. That is the way it was advertised when the project was completed. The tower facility at Peden is nicer and the stadium has a more finished look. I have never heard anyone say anything negative about Peden as what I've heard at times about BG's staadium. We can say whatever we want as to how we define tradition but in the way most people define it Miami doesn't have very much of it sitting at the bottom of a non-BCS conference.
Mark Lembright '85
General User
ML85
Member Since: 8/22/2010
Location: Highland Heights, OH
Post Count: 2,460
person
mail
Mark Lembright '85
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 1:08 PM
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.  

Please keep in mind that we're in competition with other colleges for these 17 and 18 year players when it comes to recruiting.  Of course we as alumni love Peden and maybe our views are colored by our memories.  Potential recruits have no such memories or experiences to fall back on when they see Peden Stadium.  All they see is a stadium that pales in comparison to what they watch on TV every Saturday.

As for Miami, it was within the last decade they finished in the Top 20.  When was the last time we did that?  I hate Miami, but let's be honest-other than the last 4 years under Coach Solich, Ohio hasn't accomplished anything football-wise.  I'm pretty sure we still have never won a bowl game, as meaingless as the games might be.   And BG and Toledo have brand new IPFs.  These are the schools we are directly in competition with. 
John C. Wanamaker
General User
Member Since: 1/2/2005
Post Count: 1,103
mail
John C. Wanamaker
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 1:08 PM
Wes wrote:expand_more
I am simply asking about your math on the miami thing.  We have zero titles, not sure that puts us in any position to say we have more or anything with the exception of futility.  The only thing that Peden has that Bowling Green does not is those stupid Touchdown Club seats that the department is trying to give away, because they are the worse "premium" seats in the country. 

As for the tubs, OHIO University went for over 5 years with NO rehab pools period, and there are still NONE for the athletes at the Convocation center.


From what I have read, very few schools out there even have hydrotheraphy pools. That is the way it was advertised when the project was completed. The tower facility at Peden is nicer and the stadium has a more finished look. I have never heard anyone say anything negative about Peden as what I've heard at times about BG's staadium. We can say whatever we want as to how we define tradition but in the way most people define it Miami doesn't have very much of it sitting at the bottom of a non-BCS conference.


Bowling Green has a state of the art pool

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:3UOW...
Mark Lembright '85
General User
ML85
Member Since: 8/22/2010
Location: Highland Heights, OH
Post Count: 2,460
person
mail
Mark Lembright '85
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 1:19 PM
Wes wrote:expand_more
I am simply asking about your math on the miami thing.  We have zero titles, not sure that puts us in any position to say we have more or anything with the exception of futility.  The only thing that Peden has that Bowling Green does not is those stupid Touchdown Club seats that the department is trying to give away, because they are the worse "premium" seats in the country. 

As for the tubs, OHIO University went for over 5 years with NO rehab pools period, and there are still NONE for the athletes at the Convocation center.


From what I have read, very few schools out there even have hydrotheraphy pools. That is the way it was advertised when the project was completed. The tower facility at Peden is nicer and the stadium has a more finished look. I have never heard anyone say anything negative about Peden as what I've heard at times about BG's staadium. We can say whatever we want as to how we define tradition but in the way most people define it Miami doesn't have very much of it sitting at the bottom of a non-BCS conference.


Perhaps you're right, but I'm pretty sure they don't call Ohio the Cradle of Coaches.
colobobcat66
General User
C66
Member Since: 9/1/2006
Location: Watching the bobcats run outside my window., CO
Post Count: 4,744
person
mail
colobobcat66
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 3:08 PM
I'm not so sure that being the cradle of coaches means as much as being the cradle of great players who graduated from a school. Anyway,  I would like to ask how we match up in wins, championships, games won against BCS schools, players  still in the NFL, players drafted, attendence, football budget, overall athletic budget, athletic dept profit or loss, Sagarin rankings, season tickets sold, TV ratings for our games, bowl wins, All-Americans, capacity of stadium, IPF, to start with and there are probably many more ways to look at where Ohio stands versus the MAC schools and others.  Vary the time frames to see how we do in the past 5 years, 10 years, 20 years, or whatever.  I don't think we would do very well past the past 5 years or so in many categories.

Back to my original point-When you see Big Ben or Randy Moss or Pennington or Leftwich playing on Sundays even though their current college teams are not so good, it still has a bearing on what people think about a program ( and I would guess the donations to their old schools help the programs too).  The photos on the walls can mean a lot to a recruit.
Flat Tire
General User
FT
Member Since: 12/24/2006
Post Count: 141
person
mail
Flat Tire
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 7:27 PM
Mark Lembright '85 wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 7:28:21 PM by Flat Tire
colobobcat66
General User
C66
Member Since: 9/1/2006
Location: Watching the bobcats run outside my window., CO
Post Count: 4,744
person
mail
colobobcat66
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 7:35 PM
Flat Tire wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.


An article in the Huntington paper recently said that season tickets go up 5,000 when WVU is scheduled to play in Huntington (WVU fans?).  If that's anywhere close, expanding to play WVU makes some sense.

Being realistic, I hate to break the news to anybody, but Ohio is not going to a BCS conference anytime soon and probably never will.  Oh, maybe Orrin Hatch can get all of us in.
Flat Tire
General User
FT
Member Since: 12/24/2006
Post Count: 141
person
mail
Flat Tire
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 7:50 PM
colobobcat66 wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.


An article in the Huntington paper recently said that season tickets go up 5,000 when WVU is scheduled to play in Huntington (WVU fans?).  If that's anywhere close, expanding to play WVU makes some sense.

Being realistic, I hate to break the news to anybody, but Ohio is not going to a BCS conference anytime soon and probably never will.  Oh, maybe Orrin Hatch can get all of us in.



 Marshall usually sells on average about 15,000 season tickets per year over the last ten years. Our season ticket sales did jump to nearly 20,000 the last time wvu played in Huntington.I am sure some wvu fans buy Marshall season tickets when wvu plays in Huntington, but  most of the increased  season ticket sales can be attributed to corporate  purchases.Ii have a relative in Charleston and  he usually purchase a 5-10  Marshall season tickets each year; but when wvu comes to Huntington he purchases about 30 season tickets to give to customers and friends.
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 7:54:30 PM by Flat Tire
OrlandoCat
General User
OC
Member Since: 3/15/2005
Post Count: 355
person
mail
OrlandoCat
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 8:01 PM
Flat Tire wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.


Not that much actually.

If we were to just double the size of Peden, bringing the total number of seats to just under 50k, that would put us middle of the pack for the Big East (in my opinion the mostly like place for Ohio should we ever join a BCS confrence.)

If we went up to 40k seating, we would be at the bottom of the Big East, but not by much.  Only about 2k seats behind both Lville and Rutgers, and still beating UC by 5k.

If we just add 10k seating, we'd be ahead of 4 BCS schools, and just behind big east member UC.

The convo is already BCS ready.

Edit to add:

Without doing the math and just glancing at the BSC stadium cap list; I'd say the average Stadium size is around 65,000 seats.
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 8:05:40 PM by OrlandoCat
WeAreMarshall
General User
WAM
Member Since: 8/21/2010
Post Count: 62
person
mail
WeAreMarshall
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 8:21 PM
colobobcat66 wrote:expand_more
Back to my original point-When you see Big Ben or Randy Moss or Pennington or Leftwich playing on Sundays even though their current college teams are not so good, it still has a bearing on what people think about a program ( and I would guess the donations to their old schools help the programs too).  The photos on the walls can mean a lot to a recruit.


That is very true. The photos on the wall can mean a lot to a recruit. A little over a year ago Marshall did a $1.2 million dollar renovation on the shewey building (team locker room) that included a new locker room, theatre style team meeting room and the new "NFL Wall". The NFL Wall is basically a wall of NFL helmets with the names of current and former Marshall players that have played or is actively playing in the NFL. Here is a link to the finished product:  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=phWSZdXp1Sc
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 8:22:37 PM by WeAreMarshall
Flat Tire
General User
FT
Member Since: 12/24/2006
Post Count: 141
person
mail
Flat Tire
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 8:50 PM
OrlandoCat wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.


Not that much actually.

If we were to just double the size of Peden, bringing the total number of seats to just under 50k, that would put us middle of the pack for the Big East (in my opinion the mostly like place for Ohio should we ever join a BCS confrence.)

If we went up to 40k seating, we would be at the bottom of the Big East, but not by much.  Only about 2k seats behind both Lville and Rutgers, and still beating UC by 5k.

If we just add 10k seating, we'd be ahead of 4 BCS schools, and just behind big east member UC.

The convo is already BCS ready.

Edit to add:

Without doing the math and just glancing at the BSC stadium cap list; I'd say the average Stadium size is around 65,000 seats.


Another part of the equation to moving up to a BSC conference is the media markets. If a school wants to move up to a BSC conference, the school needs facilities; attendance and media outlets IMHO. Media outlets can can get a school  like UConn; South Florida and other schools with small stadiums in a BCS conference. Unfortunately, Ohio University does have a " TV media market" to offer a conference. My relatives in Athens have always had their TV meda outlets from Columbus and and Huntington/Charleston. I don't think Ohio University can deliver the Columbus or Huntington media markets. One can use VA Tech as a school with no media market of a school that is in a BCS conference; but VA Tech can deliver most of the Commonwealth of Virgina which is a very nice media market. The same goes with Nebraska. Of course, with the "new" media, things can change; but I don't see Ohio U being able to deliver value to the broadcast media.

I am a guess at this board and I am not trying to flame Ohio U. I have relatives in Athens and I like OU. Do I think Marshall will ever be a BSC school, not really and I think OU is way below The Herd in the pecking order for a BSC conference bid. With the current economic situation in the US, a lot of colleges will have to evaluate their position in college athletics. JMHO.
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 8:58:22 PM by Flat Tire
WeAreMarshall
General User
WAM
Member Since: 8/21/2010
Post Count: 62
person
mail
WeAreMarshall
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 9:14 PM
Flat Tire wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.


Not that much actually.

If we were to just double the size of Peden, bringing the total number of seats to just under 50k, that would put us middle of the pack for the Big East (in my opinion the mostly like place for Ohio should we ever join a BCS confrence.)

If we went up to 40k seating, we would be at the bottom of the Big East, but not by much.  Only about 2k seats behind both Lville and Rutgers, and still beating UC by 5k.

If we just add 10k seating, we'd be ahead of 4 BCS schools, and just behind big east member UC.

The convo is already BCS ready.

Edit to add:

Without doing the math and just glancing at the BSC stadium cap list; I'd say the average Stadium size is around 65,000 seats.


Another part of the equation to moving up to a BSC conference is the media markets. If a school wants to move up to a BSC conference, the school needs facilities; attendance and media outlets IMHO. Media outlets can can get a school  like UConn; South Florida and other schools with small stadiums in a BCS conference. Unfortunately, Ohio University does have a " TV media market" to offer a conference. My relatives in Athens have always had their TV meda outlets from Columbus and and Huntington/Charleston. I don't think Ohio University can deliver the Columbus or Huntington media markets. One can use VA Tech as a school with no media market of a school that is in a BCS conference; but VA Tech can deliver most of the Commonwealth of Virgina which is a very nice media market. The same goes with Nebraska. Of course, with the "new" media, things can change; but I don't see Ohio U being able to deliver value to the broadcast media.

I am a guess at this board and I am not trying to flame Ohio U. I have relatives in Athens and I like OU. Do I think Marshall will ever be a BSC school, not really and I think OU is way below The Herd in the pecking order for a BSC conference bid. With the current economic situation in the US, a lot of colleges will have to evaluate their position in college athletics. JMHO.


Media Markets do play a big role. At the end of the day though it comes down to winning, facilities, national appeal, and support. After looking at schools like Wake Forest, Virginia Tech among others there is no reason that a school like Marshall or Ohio could not one day be a big player if everything falls into place. One thing is for sure, the arms race is on. Marshall got set back a few years under some bad leadership but things are back on track now. The next 10 years will be interesting. I've heard it on many occasions here.......the long term goal at Marshall from a football standpoint is to get to a BCS level like a Virginia Tech and Louisville has. It may or may not ever happen but the current leadership is going to try and get us there.
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 9:15:31 PM by WeAreMarshall
Flat Tire
General User
FT
Member Since: 12/24/2006
Post Count: 141
person
mail
Flat Tire
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 9:29 PM
Are you serious in comparing the VA Tech "situation" to Ohio U and Marshall  situations? VA Tech is the Land Grant University of the Commonwealth of Virgina and delivers the Roanoke; Richmond; Norfolk, and the Northern Virginia TV markets. VA Tech sells nearly 10,000 season tickets in the Greater Richmond area.

Never mine, this is not the forum to have a debate.
Last Edited: 8/22/2010 9:40:31 PM by Flat Tire
Casper71
General User
C71
Member Since: 12/1/2006
Post Count: 3,237
person
mail
Casper71
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 9:33 PM
My real point in starting the thread is exactly what ou79 is talking about.  For once (in it's over 50 years existence) I wish the MAC would make some noise and do something rather than wait for the leftovers becasue soon there will be nothing left ove r to take. 

It is better to ACT than REACT so good for CUSA and the WAC.  At least they are trying.  What has the MAC done lately?
WeAreMarshall
General User
WAM
Member Since: 8/21/2010
Post Count: 62
person
mail
WeAreMarshall
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 9:50 PM
Flat Tire wrote:expand_more
Are you serious in comparing the VA Tech "situation" to Ohio U and Marshall  situations? VA Tech is the Land Grant University of the Commonwealth of Virgina and delivers the Roanoke; Richmond; Norfolk, and the Northern Virginia TV markets. VA Tech sells nearly 10,000 season tickets in the Greater Richmond area.

Never mine, this is not the forum to have a debate.


Lets just put it this way, I've been around long enough to remember when Virginia Tech was just a dot on the map. They used to be horrible at everything and had no fan interest whatsoever. Research it.

 Virginia Tech didnt always have the support of any of those markets you mention with the exception of Roanoke until their football program took off. The fan base is good in Richmond but they dont have nearly as much support in the Norfolk area as you claim.
WeAreMarshall
General User
WAM
Member Since: 8/21/2010
Post Count: 62
person
mail
WeAreMarshall
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 10:24 PM
Casper71 wrote:expand_more
My real point in starting the thread is exactly what ou79 is talking about.  For once (in it's over 50 years existence) I wish the MAC would make some noise and do something rather than wait for the leftovers becasue soon there will be nothing left ove r to take. 

It is better to ACT than REACT so good for CUSA and the WAC.  At least they are trying.  What has the MAC done lately?


Casper, coming from someone on the outside looking in and having been in the Mac, here is my honest assessment of what needs to be done to make the Mac better and more attractive..........

  The Mac needs to create some standards of conference membership and make the schools in the Mac abide by them. For example, this past year Eastern Michigan averaged 5016 fans per home game. If I was the commish, Eastern Michigan would be taking a hike if they couldnt get their attendace better than that. Anybody averaging 5K per game doesnt deserve to be at the FBS level. There are far to many other programs out there that are FCS programs like Delaware, App. State, even UMass that could be brought in and would have better upside.

 2nd thing.....Why let Temple come in as a football only member? Temple had nowhere else to go and when push came to shove I bet they would have brought their basketball over to the Mac if they were forced to. Tell Temple they are either fully in or they are out on their own.

3rd thing......Why play the conference championship in Detroit? Just simply rotate the hosting Championship game on a rotating basis between the Divisions and keep the money in the conference. I'm sure it cant be cheap to host that game in Detroit every year. Those are probably the first three things I would be looking into if I was the commish.
Athens
General User
A
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Alexandria, VA
Post Count: 5,454
person
mail
Athens
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 10:53 PM
Flat Tire wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.


Not that much actually.

If we were to just double the size of Peden, bringing the total number of seats to just under 50k, that would put us middle of the pack for the Big East (in my opinion the mostly like place for Ohio should we ever join a BCS confrence.)

If we went up to 40k seating, we would be at the bottom of the Big East, but not by much.  Only about 2k seats behind both Lville and Rutgers, and still beating UC by 5k.

If we just add 10k seating, we'd be ahead of 4 BCS schools, and just behind big east member UC.

The convo is already BCS ready.

Edit to add:

Without doing the math and just glancing at the BSC stadium cap list; I'd say the average Stadium size is around 65,000 seats.


Another part of the equation to moving up to a BSC conference is the media markets. If a school wants to move up to a BSC conference, the school needs facilities; attendance and media outlets IMHO. Media outlets can can get a school  like UConn; South Florida and other schools with small stadiums in a BCS conference. Unfortunately, Ohio University does have a " TV media market" to offer a conference. My relatives in Athens have always had their TV meda outlets from Columbus and and Huntington/Charleston. I don't think Ohio University can deliver the Columbus or Huntington media markets. One can use VA Tech as a school with no media market of a school that is in a BCS conference; but VA Tech can deliver most of the Commonwealth of Virgina which is a very nice media market. The same goes with Nebraska. Of course, with the "new" media, things can change; but I don't see Ohio U being able to deliver value to the broadcast media.

I am a guess at this board and I am not trying to flame Ohio U. I have relatives in Athens and I like OU. Do I think Marshall will ever be a BSC school, not really and I think OU is way below The Herd in the pecking order for a BSC conference bid. With the current economic situation in the US, a lot of colleges will have to evaluate their position in college athletics. JMHO.


To be honest with you I would rather hear the glass is half full critique from you as a visiting fan than to hear it from some of the alumni on here which haven't watched a game in Peden Stadium since like 1982. There are some aces in the hole when it comes to sports media with Ohio University, The Scripps College produces many notable sports journalists and sports media professionals. Bobcat gear is displayed sometimes on national TV by alumni. Secondly Ohio has a great sports administration program. Third Ohio Athletics has a broad based tradition at the DI level. Football, basketball, golf, volleyball, wrestling, baseball I can all say have had some notable players and coaches through the years. This is a pretty big time D1 school when it comes to sports. We aren't a mega land grant school like Texas, Florida, or Cal that is going to win national championships by virtue of resources in every sport but we are attractive enough that good players will stop through here. Getting back to what you are saying here about Ohio's ability to carry media markets it carries several for the MAC in the regional TV package. Columbus, Chaleston, Wheeling, Roanoke all have the MAC game of the week because of Ohio and those markets were broadcasting regional TV games for the Bobcats before that. If you combine all of those areas that is a nice market of about 5 million people. Then across the state of Ohio there is general interest in the Bobcats, students from every corner of the state attend the school. Its not uncommon to see someone wearing an Ohio shirt in a mall or at the movies, more so than other MAC schools. If you want to know what the small time is that would be Marshall. I had never even heard of Marshall until I was a sophmore in college. The school was virtually unknown north of Columbus. Now that I am familar with the school I can respect Marshall as a legit D1 athletic school but I'm not sure if the academics are above the DII regional college level. I can't believe Billy Crystal actually went to school there. I know it was because of a baseball scholarship but still. And cheating, Marshall has an ugly history in that regard. Who is better positioned for the BCS, Ohio or Marshall? It depends on the circumstances behind the expansion but it looks to me that Ohio brings everything Marshall does in market plus more intangibles (state name, academic programs, located in a bigger state).
Casper71
General User
C71
Member Since: 12/1/2006
Post Count: 3,237
person
mail
Casper71
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 11:01 PM
Gee thanks We R Marsh...having been around for a long time too...it is my opinion the MAC has almost always added to the BOTTOM of the Conference, not at the top.  I agree with the standards thing and as I sarted out with, I think Middle Tenn and WKU add a lot more than EMU and some of the other current members.  You threw out a couple more names that also make more sense than some of those in the Conference.
OhioCatFan
General User
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Athens, OH
Post Count: 15,716
mail
OhioCatFan
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 11:19 PM
Wes,  I like most of your posts, but this one --- geesh!   Marshall has some very good academic programs.  It's journalism school, while not quite on par with Ohio, Missouri and Northwestern, is a very good one.  Its medical school is gaining respect and fairly recently added a Comprehensive Cancer Center, which is recognized by the National Institutes of Health.  This is very prestigious in the world of academic medicine.  MU does not have as many Ph.D. programs as Ohio, but it is certainly way above your average D2 school.  And, most importantly, it has a lot of momentum on both the academic and the athletic side.  It's an institution that is not resting on its laurels but is striving to improve and is making improvements on a continuous basis these days.  Marshall has had some cheating scandals in the past, that is true, but it is unfair to characterize the program as though it is some cheater's haven.  You make it sound like SMU or USC.  That's not fair.   
Athens
General User
A
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Alexandria, VA
Post Count: 5,454
person
mail
Athens
mail
Posted: 8/22/2010 11:50 PM
OhioCatFan wrote:expand_more
Wes,  I like most of your posts, but this one --- geesh!   Marshall has some very good academic programs.  It's journalism school, while not quite on par with Ohio, Missouri and Northwestern, is a very good one.  Its medical school is gaining respect and fairly recently added a Comprehensive Cancer Center, which is recognized by the National Institutes of Health.  This is very prestigious in the world of academic medicine.  MU does not have as many Ph.D. programs as Ohio, but it is certainly way above your average D2 school.  And, most importantly, it has a lot of momentum on both the academic and the athletic side.  It's an institution that is not resting on its laurels but is striving to improve and is making improvements on a continuous basis these days.  Marshall has had some cheating scandals in the past, that is true, but it is unfair to characterize the program as though it is some cheater's haven.  You make it sound like SMU or USC.  That's not fair.   


I will meet you on one point where I agree with you 100% in that Marshall has momentum academically. West Virginia is now starting to rise back up especially the eastern part of the state. The long term outlook for the school is good as its the only school large public school other than WVU in that state.
Athens
General User
A
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Alexandria, VA
Post Count: 5,454
person
mail
Athens
mail
Posted: 8/23/2010 12:05 AM
Casper71 wrote:expand_more
Gee thanks We R Marsh...having been around for a long time too...it is my opinion the MAC has almost always added to the BOTTOM of the Conference, not at the top.  I agree with the standards thing and as I sarted out with, I think Middle Tenn and WKU add a lot more than EMU and some of the other current members.  You threw out a couple more names that also make more sense than some of those in the Conference.


Western Kentucky? Are you from Kentucky or something and that is why you want to add them? I believe they went 0-12 in football last year. That would not help the football conference.
Athens
General User
A
Member Since: 12/20/2004
Location: Alexandria, VA
Post Count: 5,454
person
mail
Athens
mail
Posted: 8/23/2010 12:40 AM
OrlandoCat wrote:expand_more
My point isn't wether Peden Stdium is nice or not.  It is nice and it is scenic.  And it's great venue for a football game in the Fall.  My point is that by BCS standards, and BCS seems to be where we want to go, Peden is very, very small.  It has improved  over the years, no doubt about it.   But it seats only 24,000 and that's including the grassy hill, with it's small scoreboard.  It's quaint and it quite frankly isn't BCS caliber right now.  It sure doesn't compare to Akron's new stadium.    


First of all, I agree with the comments about Peden. One reason Marshall expanded their stadium to nearly 40,000 capacity was to move up to CUSA and be able to have wvu visit Huntington. If it takes 40,000 seats to move up to CUSA, then you can imagine how many seats one would need to receive a bid from a BSC conference.  JHMO.


Not that much actually.

If we were to just double the size of Peden, bringing the total number of seats to just under 50k, that would put us middle of the pack for the Big East (in my opinion the mostly like place for Ohio should we ever join a BCS confrence.)

If we went up to 40k seating, we would be at the bottom of the Big East, but not by much.  Only about 2k seats behind both Lville and Rutgers, and still beating UC by 5k.

If we just add 10k seating, we'd be ahead of 4 BCS schools, and just behind big east member UC.

The convo is already BCS ready.


The question is how many seats would be required to move up? Looking at examples in recent years here. Boston College to the ACC with a 44,500 seat stadium. Cincinnati to the Big East with a 35,000 seat stadium. Nevada to the Moutain West with a 31,500 seat stadium. This would suggest if Ohio could move to 32,000 seats, in the process making it the largest on campus MAC facility that it would help the program stick out above the fray.  Also I would like to point out that to increase the capacity of Peden Stadium to 40,000 the stadium does not need to be doubled! Peden is basically a 40k stadium with 24,000 seats. Fill in the north and south endzones and its 40,000 easy without expanding above and beyond the current stadium walls.
Showing Messages: 26 - 50 of 79
MAC News Links
Wednesday, May 13, 2026



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)