While I would like to say I want my state to win the National Title, I place school pride before state pride. If he truly was a Bobcat fan he would see this point too. Besides, if the Little Brother up North gets caught with his pants down then he doesn't deserve the National Title out of foolishness....and inferiority.
That is my thinking. While I am an Ohio State fan since birth, I am rooting for my alma mater to win. Just for that reason, if Ohio State can't beat Ohio (or any other team they would be 20+ pt favorites) then they don't deserve it.
On the other hand, if Ohio loses, I can handle that loss alot better knowing my 2nd favorite team won and could win a national title.
Another thought... I just read Stewart Mandel's mailbag on SI.com. He said in a remark in a previous column about always rooting for your alma mater over your childhood/teenage favorite. In his email-bag there was some interesting comments regarding his thoughts. Especially the guy that grew up a Michigan fan but attented Appalachain St. But yet couldn't enjoy their epic upset.