Absolutely no way App come to the MAC. How much money would they lose going from FCS championships to pizza bowls?
App. Sate has already announced they are looking into moving up to div. I. Now, could they leapfrog right into CUSA? Good question.
I feel like Appalachian State holds the key to MAC expansion. IF they do in-fact decide to go FBS it could represent a larger transition in college football than earlier news of the Mega-Conferences had indicated. The mid-major football conferences appear to be alive and well for now. If a traditional power like Appalachian State sees this as the best time to leave their 1-AA days behind it will probably give way to other 1-AA powers joining the FBS such as Montana, or Villanova, even a Cal Poly or Texas State. We could see a half dozen 1-AA programs joining the FBS ranks over the next several years just to fill the needs of existing conferences such as the WAC.
Appalachian State fits best with the MAC and Sun Belt when competition level and geography is taken into account. They would actually be closer to the northern MAC teams than the southern Sun Belt teams. In the event that college football is actually experiencing the Cambrian Explosion, the MAC cannot afford to miss the boat. If the Sun Belt lures the Mountaineers of Boone, N.C., Georgia Southern will follow. The addition of Louisiana Tech could add a conference championship and 5-10 years from now the MAC could be dead last out of the 11 FBS conferences. All of the money put into the Mid-American for football, and the martyrdom of MAC basketball will be for naught. If the MAC could lure Appalachian State and later MTSU and WKU (a fatal blow to the Sun Belt), 5-10 years from now the MAC will sit comfortably 9th out of 11 conferences and more likely than not a two-bid men's basketball conference.