Can we get mythbusters on this? Sounds like another BA fairy tale that gets told over and over.
"Most players" are transferring "down", because "most players" are fringe players to begin with.
"Good players" are in-fact transferring up and sideways.
Well, let's look at this year's Ohio data. There are 5 players transferring up, those being:
Vakos - Ohio to Wisconsin
Daxon - Ohio to Illinois
Walter Reynolds - HOLY CROSS to OHIO
Christian Hilton - CITADEL to OHIO
Jack Kenneally - YOUNGSTOWN ST to OHIO
There is one player transferring sideways:
McCracken Ohio to Marshall
There are seven players transferring down, or looking to:
Kadin Beler - Ohio to ...
Cannon Blauser - Ohio to S Dakota
Kyle Kelly - Ohio to ...
Jamison Collier - Ohio to E.TENNESSEE STATE
Tyler Mullins - Ohio to UT MARTIN
CJ Hankins - LB Ohio to Siena Heights
Ches Jackson - OL - Colorado St to Ohio
Vakos is the first really good player I recall leaving, but recall a number of really good players coming to Ohio from various P5 teams, and a number of Ohio players moving down and doing well, such as Quinton Maxwell to Indiana University.