For my money, I'd take TT over Boo or T3 any day, and it has nothing to do with athletic ability. (although he is by no means not talented) It has everything to do with leadership. I loved Boo and T3, and have the utmost respect for their time spent serving Ohio. They were both great ambassadors for the school.
The primary difference for them both v TT in my eyes is that both Boo and T3 were well liked by their teammates, but I'm not sure they had the command and leadership qualities that TT is showing. I always felt Boo and Theo had a "California Cool" quality about them that made them immensely likable, but I'm not sure they could really push their teammates beyond their limits to perform, and I think TT is doing that.
I was fortunate to get to go to NMSU and take the game in on the sidelines, and I saw a lot of AE in TT. And for those of us that speak highly of AE, it was never his athletic ability that we stood behind, but his will to win and his ability to lead.
That is what I think we are seeing in TT, and I hope he can keep performing at this level, and with this confidence.
And BTW, he is immensely likable as well.