Am I the only one who thinks this would be a huge step back for the program. Joining a league with a bunch of 1AA schools?
Of the 4 FCS schools mentioned in the article, all have Sagarin ratings better than Kent and Akron. All but ODU are better than CMU, Buffalo, Fiami, and EMU as well. Two other CAA conference schools--UMASS (to be MAC next year) and Richmond--rank higher than all MAC schools except OHIO, WMU, NIU, and Toledo.
Virginia is a recruiting hotbed, and gives you access to the DC market. Delaware expands presence in the Philly/NJ area. As a program, Appy State is as good as it gets in I-AA. Their average attendance last year (25,715) is 10,000 more than the MAC average (15,609).
I think it would be, at worst, a step sideways.