You can't take current FBS schools and extrapolate that back to the days of Don Peden. Some schools like Cincinnati were fairly weak while others like Western Reserve University were much stronger. These are but two examples. Also, Peden played and beat schools like Indiana, Illinois (twice) and others that you would recognize as major colleges today. Perhaps, the best year to illustrate the futility of trying the type of extrapolation you have been attempting was 1938. That year -- when Peden's Bobcats won the Buckeye Conference -- Ohio beat Illinois 6-0 but lost to Western Reserve 26-14 and Dayton 13-0.
Edit: Yes, the MAC had a self-imposed limitation of 85 scholarship when the rest of D-1 was at 105. This makes Hess' victories over major college teams in those years even more of an accomplishment. Kind of like winning a fight with one hand tied behind your back. MAC Trivia: If it hadn't been for this self-imposed scholarship limit Cincinnati would have rejoined the MAC in 1969 and Louisville would have joined for the first time. It was a package deal. This agreement was in all the papers at the time, and was all ready to go but the MAC Daddies at the last minute decided not to raise the scholarship limit to 105 and deal feel through.
Last Edited: 11/13/2011 11:01:54 AM by OhioCatFan