The writers usually pick the previous year's East winner, but no East team has won back-to-back division titles since '03-'04. Hope that streak ends this year.
A look back at last year's poll and how they actually finished:
MAC East Division
1. Miami (T4th)
2. Ohio (1st)
3. Temple (2nd)
4. Kent State (3rd)
5. Bowling Green (T4th)
6. Buffalo (6th)
7. Akron (7th)
MAC West Division
1. Toledo (T1st)
2. Northern Illinois (T1st*)
3. Western Michigan (3rd)
4. Central Michigan (6th)
5. Ball State (T4th)
6. Eastern Michigan (T4th)
2011 Marathon MAC Championship Game Winner:
Toledo 5, Northern Illinois 3, Miami 3, Ohio 1, Western Michigan 1 (several voters did not select a winner for the MAC Championship)
The Cats got 8 of the 16 first place votes, so half the media can say they were right.