I like this thread.
School pride is so much better than being a fan of a school you never went to.
This is worth quoting and is spot on.
I grew up a Miami fan as both my parents went there, and they only followed Miami. I idolized Wally Szczerbiak and was psyched to meet Travis Prentice. Roethlisberger...eh, he was alright. I still pull for Miami to do well when it doesn't affect our chances at success.
I hope you don't take this the wrong way shab (the spirit is only to poke fun at Miami)...but for some reason I remember there being a discussion of frat/sorority apathy toward Ohio athletics, and remember you speaking up as being in a fraternity. I can't help but point out the humor that the poster who comes from Miami genetics and the poster who was in a fraternity are one in the same. Kudos to you for breaking free of the Miami tradition.
I was a somewhat big Wisconsin fan growing up (Dad went there, all my family is from there). Started following Ohio during high school as my sister and then brother attended Ohio, and became an all out super fan as soon as I hit campus. Wisconsin fandom slowly faded into what it is today - A very casual following or hope that they do well, but not really a true fan. It is just nothing compared to the joy of rooting for your beloved school.
A casual following I can understand, even for OSU if that was your team. But I can't understand those that do true duel fandom where they spend as much or more time/energy/money on OSU than Ohio. I just don't see how that is fulfilling.