A visit to Pollstalker shows that we actually had 8 more voters casting votes for us on their AP Top 25 ballot than Michigan -- we got pushed out by Michigan because a "rouge" reporter (Jon Wilner, San Jose Mercury News) decided to place Michigan at #14 (higher than any other voter). That #14 vote gave them more than enough points to edge out our beloved Bobcats.
Get your pitchforks, men!