Before I say this, let me say that I think we have a good head coach. Period. But are we a little too quick to pat this staff on the back for all the "building"? It's been 8 years. Coach Hazell is in his second year. Kent is 7-1 with a top 25 win (something we've never done). We've still never had a Toledo or NIU-grade offense. In general, we've been a solid, fundamentally sound team - great. In general, we win more than we lose - great. In general our guys perform in the classroom and the community - awesome. In this much time, aren't we at least due to have one team that just takes care of business and dominates lesser opponents? Rant all you want about how some of us (ahem) express our frustration, but I just don't understand anyone who is less than disgusted after Saturday. if we can only score 20 on !@#$%& Miami, how are we going to score AT ALL against BG, who actually has a defense?
What has been shown countless times in the MAC is that the right coach can come in and take a MAC program, even a horrawful one, and win a MACC in 3 years or less. Look at the teams that have won since Solich came to Athens-
2005- Akron, JD Brookheart, 2nd season.
2006- CMU, Brian Kelly, 3rd season
2007- CMU, Butch Jones, 1st season
2008- Buffalo, Turner Gill, 3rd season
2009- CMU, Butch Jones, 3rd season
2010- Miami, Michael Haywood, 2nd season
2011- NIU, Dave Doeren, 1st season
Does Frank's inability to win after 7 years make him less successful then these coaches? In spite of not winning in Detroit he was able to get us there in just his 2nd season which puts him on par with the other coaches listed. The difference is Kelly, Gill and Haywood split as soon as they turned the program around and Jones (and likely Doeren) left as soon as they won with their own people.
But what have those programs done over the long term? Here's the total number of wins for those programs during Frank's first 7 seasons-
51- NIU
50- Ohio
50- CMU
32- Miami
26- Akron
26- Buffalo
NIU and CMU got lucky in finding 2 good coaches in a row, that's not easy to do. History shows that if Kent State wins the MACC this year in their coach's 2nd season it would not be unusual, but history also shows that he will likely leave and the chance of his replacement continuing that success is not good.
Sure, I wish Frank wasn't 0-3 in the MACC and 1-3 in bowls, and I wish we hadn't lost our last 4 games, all of which were winnable. But I wouldn't trade places with any of the teams that have won a MACC since 2005, not even NIU, their coach will be gone in a year or two and history shows it is extremely hard to hire 3 good coaches in a row. We've got Frank for at least 5 more years, I'm ok with that. Now lets go win our next 6.