Good post. I agree, especially the bolded part. Since I'm not in the Athens area, I don't know what is being reported. But I wonder why this is not part of media coverage.
T^2 has previously said that he is just making the read, and the read says to hand it off. From that, I think it leaves the following possibilities:
(a) The scheme is defective/defenses have figured it out. If so, it's time to change things up.
(b) We don't have the players capable of executing the scheme/O-line isn't properly blocking/RBs aren't making the right cuts. If so, it's time to change things up.
(c) T^2 doesn't want to risk injury, is erring on the side of caution, and isn't actually making the correct read. If so, it's time to change things up.
(d) A combination of the above.
My personal opinion: (d). The offense is not nearly as creative as it was in 2011 when it was first installed. We all hoped that familiarity would allow the offense to build on itself. It seems that it has instead gotten into a rut and that defenses have figured out the keys to stopping the half dozen or so plays we run. It also seems like we do not have the right players, particularly at the skill positions, like we did in 2011. Not that we don't have athletes now...we have lots of talent. But it just feels different now. In 2011, was there any doubt that when we needed a 3rd down conversion, Dunlop was going to get open? Bates was a threat to run, throw, or catch any time he was on the field, and T^2 just found a way to win. And that last one leads me to believe that T^2 is more hesitant since that injury last season. The switch was flipped off after that and even though he is (supposedly) healthy now it just never was flipped back on. It's not just the read option...he's throwing the ball away more after the pocket breaks instead of using his legs.
Note: I don't mean any of this as criticism of any player, and maybe the stats don't back up my statements. This is totally an eyeball test. But it doesn't appear to me that this scheme with this set of players is going to work. And since at the college level it's easier to replace a scheme than find new players, I think the coaches need to spend some time revisiting what we are trying to do on offense.