I think we've reached points at which we disagree, and where we aren't likely to agree. Here's how I see the various backs:
1. Daz is a very good all-around back, with no particular weaknesses. He has good power, good acceleration, good speed, good balance, good elusiveness, he's a good receiver and he's a very good blocker. Built low to the ground, he has good leverage when running inside. He may not be the best ever at any one skill, but all around he has no weaknesses.
2. AJ is a very powerful back who is deceptively fast, and an excellent north-south runner. He's not usually going to break the big run, but he's always going to get yards, and once in awhile he'll burst through the line for a big gain. He's also a good receiver, and an outstanding blocker. In an I formation, I want this guy as my fullback.
3. White - doesn't have a lot of power but has incredible speed and elusiveness, and he's an outstanding receiver. He's also a decent blocker.
4. Irons - Is the best on the team at reading blocks and finding lanes, and has outstanding balance, making him hard to tackle. You can't knock him down, you need to tackle him. He's also a good receiver, and has very good speed. He's also got some question marks in his skill set. He seems runs with a high pad height, so in traffic, when there is no running room, he's not able to move the pile. If he can't find a lane, he won't get much. I also have questions about his blocking. I've never actually seen him attempt a block, so I don't know how well he blocks. In a one back set, the back needs to be able to block, though.
5. Brown - Seems to be a good all around back, like a bigger Daz. He doesn't excel in any one area, but he's not bad in any area. He does need to improve his blocking, though. In the BG game I saw him miss a couple blocks, at least one of which resulted in a sack. He was trying hard, though, so I'm sure that he'll improve in the area of blocking.
For me to be convinced that Irons should move ahead of Daz or AJ he needs to convince me of two things. The first is that he can get the tough yards inside. The second is that he can block well. I expect we'll see more of him against Kent State, and maybe he'll demonstrate both abilities to me, in which case I'll join you. In the absence of that, though, I see him as a situational back who can do some great things if used properly.
Last Edited: 11/10/2015 10:45:08 AM by L.C.