If Albin averages 8 wins a year for ten years he will be among the best coaches in school history. That consistent winning should be rewarded and celebrated. MAC has a lot of parity. Solich had Ohio in top three in the MAC. That is elite. It isn't easy recruiting football at Ohio. We are not near an urban area or large TV market. We are long way from home for these kids. If you can win 8 games a year at Ohio that is a darn good job. Fans need to get over the first year. It was coming off a shortened season and mid summer coaching change.
The biggest fear of those opposed to the automatic extension seems to be that Albin will win 8, and only 8 wins every year. That is extremely unlikely. If he averages 8, there will be some some sixes and sevens mixed in with some nines and tens, in which case he will have some years where he isn't auto-renewed, and his remaining contract will grow shorter. If he does win 8 every year, that would mean that his average will be higher, with a mix of 8-9-10-11 win seasons. Thus, to achieve 8 wins every year, his win percentage would be competitive with Peden for the all-time best at Ohio.
Furthermore, if he does win 8 every year, and average 9 or better, the automatic extension may be irrelevant anyway, except in one way, as he may have the opportunity to move to a P5 school if he wants to. While I don't know the terms of the contract, if I were negotiating this contract, the payment for Ohio in case Albin wants to breach it would be tied to the number of years he had left on his contract, in which case, with every extension, the recovery by Ohio in the event Albin leaves would be preserved. As an example, say that the contract specifies that Albin must pay $250k for each remaining year on his contract in order to buy it out, and that he wins 8 next year, and 10 the following year, and then gets a P5 offer. The contract would be auto-extended twice, and there would still e 4 years left, so the payout would stay at $1m. Again, I don't know that this is the contract, but if I were Ohio, I would have insisted on something similar in exchange for the auto-renewal clause.