I count eight, maybe nine players on our defensive two-deep that were at one point walk-ons. Many praises to those individuals for their hard work, but are we whiffing on recruiting when players who have been on scholarship all along don't dominate the depth chart?
I think that's just part of recruiting. Every team in the country has scholarship seniors sitting on the bench. Including many who were 4 and 5 star recruits.
I don't believe this last sentence is even close to accurate. It sounds good as hyperbole, but current numbers do not bear that out. The current senior class would have come from 2013 or 2014, correct (depending on redshirts)? Just using the 2013 numbers, there were a grand total of 33 5 star recruits in the entire country. In 2014, the same number (33).
So, out of 33 recruits in 2013, there are six not in the NFL right now. Kenny Bigelow is a starter at USC, Matthew Thomas is leading returning tackler for FSU, and Frank Herron is starting DT for LSU. The possible questionable ones are Mike Mitchell, formerly of Ohio State, who is now in DII, Thomas Tyner, who medically retired and is now attempting a comeback with Oregon State, Ty Isaac, backup RB at Michigan after transferring from USC, and Max Redfield, who is no longer in DI due to legal troubles.
In 2014, there are 15 of the 33 not currently in the NFL. One, Speedy Noil, is the result of entering draft early and getting cut. The other 14 are all starting in college currently at their positions. The closest you could come to a questionable one would be Racean Thomas, who transferred to Jacksonville State to be their starting RB. Other than that, all other 5 star recruits are starters at their college and many are expected to be first-round draft picks (Da'Shawn Hand, Quin Blanding, Kyle Allen, Sony Michel, Rashaan Evans, Bo Scarbrough, Damian Prince, Chad Thomas, Tre Williams, Tony Brown, Ermon Lane, Quenton Nelson, Andrew Brown).
A 5-star prospect is rare and almost always pans out. There are exceptions, but they are very rare. So to say that many 5 star recruits are scholarship seniors riding the pine, that's inaccurate. Best you could say is that fits maybe 2 or 3 seniors in the entire country.