Ohio Basketball Recruiting Topic
Topic: Assuming the 2014 class is filled, how do you rate it?
Page: 1 of 1
mail
person
colobobcat66
5/14/2014 10:36 PM
What is your "gut" feeling about the quality of this class?
mail
person
Ohio69
5/15/2014 12:10 PM
colobobcat66 wrote:expand_more
What is your "gut" feeling about the quality of this class?


I gave the class a high grade.  Mainly due to the circumstances.  Landing a kid likeTaylor who was holding out for an offer from top 5 Michigan is a big, big deal.  Jaaron Simmons is a very solid PG transfer pick up.  Keeping Crute is huge.  Laster is the unknown for me.  Kind of reminds me of when we signed TJ Hall.  Hall didn't get much publicity and was a solid contributor and could have been more if his legs didn't revolt on him.

Phillips and company stabilized things pretty darn quickly. 
mail
OU_Country
5/15/2014 12:30 PM
Ohio69 wrote:expand_more
Phillips and company stabilized things pretty darn quickly. 


For this reason, I give a B.  Obviously this is like an NFL Draft grade, and means zero until we see what kinds of players and students the class is.  I guess my hope was that there would also end up being a big somewhere in this group as well.
mail
UpSan Bobcat
5/15/2014 12:39 PM
Given the circumstances, it was pretty good. If the circumstances were normal, it'd probably rate somewhat below average. That makes this a hard question to answer.
mail
perimeterpost
5/15/2014 2:09 PM
Ohio69 wrote:expand_more
What is your "gut" feeling about the quality of this class?


I gave the class a high grade. Mainly due to the circumstances. Landing a kid likeTaylor who was holding out for an offer from top 5 Michigan is a big, big deal. Jaaron Simmons is a very solid PG transfer pick up. Keeping Crute is huge. Laster is the unknown for me. Kind of reminds me of when we signed TJ Hall. Hall didn't get much publicity and was a solid contributor and could have been more if his legs didn't revolt on him.

Phillips and company stabilized things pretty darn quickly.
Taylor stated publicly that Michigan was his first choice but he didn't commit there because Michigan never offered, not because we stole him. Besides Ohio he had zero other offers, it was either us or nothing. Given those circumstances landing him was most certainly not a "big, big deal."

With that being said Taylor and Laster appear to be decent adds. As true freshmen next year they likely won't produce at the level of the JUCO recruits they are replacing but long term I think they have the potential to be solid additions.

Keeping Crute is a plus, he appears to be the early pick for heir apparent to the Tunji-Stevie-Setty line of players who most bleeds Green and White.

Losing Owens was tough but in the long run 3 years of Simmons might be more impactful to the program than 4 years of Owens. Not a bad trade off.

Also worth noting is the recruiting moves SP and staff DIDN'T make- we didn't have to recruit anyone to replace a player that transferred because no player transferred. Credit goes for getting 100% of current players to stay through the coaching change. Also, credit for not adding players for the sake of short term fixes. Perez would have been a warm body for next year but long term we don't need another 6'4 wing.

Based on the moves that were made, and not made, I give the class a solid B. If we had landed Shamburger I would have given a B+.
Last Edited: 5/15/2014 2:13:20 PM by perimeterpost
mail
RSBobcat
5/15/2014 11:59 PM
[/QUOTE]

Taylor stated publicly that Michigan was his first choice but he didn't commit there because Michigan never offered, not because we stole him. Besides Ohio he had zero other offers, it was either us or nothing. Given those circumstances landing him was most certainly not a "big, big deal."

With that being said Taylor and Laster appear to be decent adds. As true freshmen next year they likely won't produce at the level of the JUCO recruits they are replacing but long term I think they have the potential to be solid additions.

Keeping Crute is a plus, he appears to be the early pick for heir apparent to the Tunji-Stevie-Setty line of players who most bleeds Green and White.

Losing Owens was tough but in the long run 3 years of Simmons might be more impactful to the program than 4 years of Owens. Not a bad trade off.

Also worth noting is the recruiting moves SP and staff DIDN'T make- we didn't have to recruit anyone to replace a player that transferred because no player transferred. Credit goes for getting 100% of current players to stay through the coaching change. Also, credit for not adding players for the sake of short term fixes. Perez would have been a warm body for next year but long term we don't need another 6'4 wing.

Based on the moves that were made, and not made, I give the class a solid B. If we had landed Shamburger I would have given a B+.[/QUOTE]

Agree with this synopsis and grade

 
Last Edited: 5/16/2014 12:00:37 AM by RSBobcat
mail
person
Jeff McKinney
5/16/2014 11:59 AM
I think Shamburger pursued us, not vice versa.

This is like a situation where a student comes into a course three fourths of the way through the class and has to catch up.  In light of that, I think this staff did a very commendable job with their committments received. 

On Ryan Taylor only having the offer from Ohio...the fact that Michigan and Wisconsin were interested makes it very strange that Ohio was his only other offer.  If someone knows why, I'd love to know.  I DO know that Coach Phillips is VERY high on him.
Showing Messages: 1 - 7 of 7
MAC News Links



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)