Who really cares about stars outside of Duke, UK, KU, etc? How many stars was Nick Kellogg (avg. of 2.5). How about Big Reg Keely? (2), D.J. Cooper, probably one of the top 10 MAC players of all time was a 3 star. The MAC always comes down to which coaches find the under the radar guys. Something that Dambrot, Kent State coaches, Steve Hawkins and Keno Davis have excelled at. Hopefully Saul catches up.
I agree with BC 98 here. The MAC is far more of a player development league, and I believe that's what Saul and staff will be good at. At the same time, I just don't buy a lot of the star ratings for kids, particularly outside of the top 75 or so. Also, it's gonna take some time for Saul to build up relationships in Ohio/midwest. I asked him at the coaching caravan in Cbus if he'd made inroads with former Bcats who are now coaching like Sonny Johnson and Kirk Lehman--both state championship coaches. He said yes, they were off to a good start, but there's a lot more relationship-building that has to be done before it gets to the point where they think "Ohio" first when recommending schools to kids...
By the way, look at one of Saul's mentors, Bo Ryan. Look how successful he's been with kids who are generally ignored by other top Big 10 schools. Marched through the tourney last year with a bunch of kids hardly anybody heard of in HS...
Frank Kaminsky- 3 stars. Interest from Ohio, no offer.
Caris LeVert- 3 stars. Offer from Ohio.
Trey Burke- 3 starts. Offer from Ohio.
Kendrick Nunn- 4 stars. Offer from Ohio.
We missed out on these recruits but was it a waste of time to go after them? Would that have contributed positively to our team if they had signed? I understand that rating don't mean everything and the MAC is a developmental league and blah, blah blah.. but that doesn't mean you don't even try to get a higher rated recruit once in a while. Make the effort.
Walter Luckett was the #1 rated recruit in the country and his first visit was to Ohio and he signed. You miss 100% of the shots you don't take.