In regards to people possibly leaving or staying, Do you know or have an idea what players were going through such as injuries or other things ? Butler suffered a sprained AC joint in his left shoulder after it was separated 6-8 games ago and only missed 1 game even though he probably shouldn’t have played the rest of the season due to the pain and discomfort he’s been dealing with to go along with playing with streptococcus ( throat infection) since last Friday . So since you love to speculate on a players future know the truth or what’s going on . The staff at Ohio didn’t feel it was your business to know what players are battling everytime . The Butler kid will be fine and a major contributor for Ohio next season or somewhere else if he decides and wants to leave .There’s over 150-200 Division 1 schools that play basketball and he won’t be without several options even if you feel he’s not ready for prime time.
Some of the reason the staff isn't telling you about what certain players are battling has to do with privacy and HIPPA laws. They can't tell you every detail without the player's permission unless I'm mistaken. If I am, perhaps someone could enlighten me, and us, on the proper/normal procedures in this case.
Privacy laws are an important element as you note. For example, with HIPAA and FERPA adult students must give written consent for parents or anyone else to receive information about health or education (grades, university discipline, etc.) status. I'm in favor.
Bornacatfan and anyone else associated with college programs at any level will confirm that all players are hurt to some degree during the season. And, just about everyone is nursing something from mid-January on. It is a rare player who is 100%. Here are common ones -- concussion (minor), ankle sprains, knee strains, hematomas, fractured or dislocated fingers, toenail/fingernail issues, back spasms, strained hip flexors, tight hamstrings. All of these can affect range of motion, explosiveness, change of direction and more. Plus, people are wired differently - some are able to block out pain more easily than others.
In addition, you have the various common viruses -- cold, flu, mono, etc. in a campus environment.
All teams face these so how you deal with it is a difference maker. What is much more difficult to control are injuries -- those that severely limit or keep players out of the lineup.