I mean, I understand the overarching point being made here, but this:
"Never mind that New York is a pro sports city mostly uninterested in college basketball — tournament attendance figures will be interesting — the Big Ten wants to promote its product outside of flyover country, where the majority of Big Ten fans reside. Yeah, makes sense."
is ridiculous.
The old Big East Tournaments at Madison Square Garden are literally legendary. You'd be very hardpressed to argue that there was more interest in Big 10 tournament games in Indianapolis than there were in Big East Tournament games at MSG.
Further, St. Johns regularly sells out the Garden despite being -- you know -- St. Johns. And New York's such a pro sports town with attendance issues that the ACC decided to host their tournament in. . .New York.
It's also a mistake to think this is about Rutgers. Rutgers wasn't added to the Big Ten because of Rutgers fans in the New York market. Rutgers was added to the Big Ten because of Michigan, Indiana, Penn State, Ohio State, Illinois and Wisconsin fans in the New York market. There are tons of them.
In fact, based on LinkedIn's data, there are more Michigan alums in NYC than in Chicago. Ditto Penn State, Rutgers, and Maryland. You've got easily a couple hundred thousand Big Ten alums in New York.
I get that it'd be nice if folks could easily travel, but it's not like New York's some random backwater without any Big 10 connections.
As someone who lives 20 minutes from Manhattan let me offer my take on this.
1.This is a pro sports area in terms of football.
With the exception of Notre Dame,there was/is never a problem getting a ticket to college games at Giants/Met Life Stadium.
Same thing,other then alums,you don't see locals at the Pinstripe Bowl.
2.As far as Rutgers football,usually,at their B1G home games,there are more fans for the opponents.
Once the game is out of reach,what RU fans there are,are gone.
3.College basketball is big in the area,especially when St.John's and Seton Hall are doing well.
When the Knicks are dong well,they do outdraw college teams.
But its been a while since that was the case.
4.It was an open secret that one of the "selling points" made by Rutgers to get into the B1G was an T.V. expanded market,including for BTN.
This was apparently stressed by their former A.D. (Pernetti) who was a media guy.
Apparently,the B1G has a requirement that local cable and other media providers offer BTN and have to pay a fee per subscriber.
Pernittia was forced out,before RU joined the B1G,so he never got the credit for The move.
As a college football and wrestling fan, Rutgers joining the B1G lets me see a lot of great* college football and wrestling close to home.
*great if you hate Rutgers