Is it really that hard to not overreact one way or the other to the Groce era? In hindsight, it's pretty easy to put into perspective.
Ultimately, his stay in Athens was wildly successful. He recruited an all-time great in Cooper and took the program to heights not seen since Snyder. But he also underperformed during the regular season and had favorable draw in that NCAA tournament when he got Michigan and USF, two teams that on paper were perfect match-ups for an undersized MAC team. (The Georgetown win is Groce's masterpiece game. It's one of the most dumbfounding butt-kickings I've ever witnessed and it happened for the team I rooted for. It's the height of Ohio basketball in the new millenium — if only because DJ Cooper's half-court fling wasn't a quarter of an inch over against UNC...)
I mostly agree with this. I was there at the Sweet 16 celebration in the Convo when Groce, himself, said that he was lamented that they never hung a MAC regular season banner in the rafters. NCAA tourney wins are great, but they are what they are: neutral court match ups that can often produce surprising results. Every year, it seems, mid major teams pull upsets. It was us a few times. I enjoyed those wins as much as anyone else. I taunted Akron players in 2012 from the hotel bar, then took an awkward elevator ride with a few of them half an hour later. I, unlike some here, however, can't look back on his time here with arguably the most talented roster we have ever had in Athens and feel like he didn't vastly under perform OUTSIDE of March. Even in the Sweet 16 year, we lost on the road to BG, EMU, Kent St, and a few others. How does a team that nearly made the Elite 8 lose some of those games? Jim Christian took nearly the same roster and only lost to one team in the MAC the following year. Akron. Unfortunately for JC, DJ all but disappeared in the MAC final and we missed the tourney.