Ohio Basketball Topic
Topic: Official Game 13 Thread: Campbell
Page: 2 of 2
mail
person
Victory
12/31/2019 12:10 PM
Compare the out of conference results from this year to last year. Which looks better? I would contend that last year's results were better.
mail
person
Bobcat1998
12/31/2019 6:02 PM
Victory wrote:expand_more
Compare the out of conference results from this year to last year. Which looks better? I would contend that last year's results were better.
I would contend the opposite. First look at our losses. All major ranked teams and a 9-3 team. Then look at rosters. To be 8-5 right now when I HOPED for 8 wins WITH A HEALTHY ROSTER makes this season a success already. You must be a Saulpologist.
mail
person
Jeff McKinney
12/31/2019 6:35 PM
Bobcat1998 wrote:expand_more
Compare the out of conference results from this year to last year. Which looks better? I would contend that last year's results were better.
I would contend the opposite. First look at our losses. All major ranked teams and a 9-3 team. Then look at rosters. To be 8-5 right now when I HOPED for 8 wins WITH A HEALTHY ROSTER makes this season a success already. You must be a Saulpologist.
Why do you have to start the name calling just because someone has a different opinion on something?
mail
person
Victory
12/31/2019 8:32 PM
Bobcat1998 wrote:expand_more
Compare the out of conference results from this year to last year. Which looks better? I would contend that last year's results were better.
I would contend the opposite. First look at our losses. All major ranked teams and a 9-3 team. Then look at rosters. To be 8-5 right now when I HOPED for 8 wins WITH A HEALTHY ROSTER makes this season a success already. You must be a Saulpologist.
No, I'd guess Boals is a better coach and that OUr future is brighter with him. I do think if Saul has had a normal amount of injuries that he might still be here though. Who knows this stuff though? It is hypothetical. What I can do is look at hard facts from this year to last. I think OUr strength of record at this point was better last year than this. Although, it is close. We should end up with a better record this year. The main reason that I think that is that last year was one of the best incarnations of the MAC in recent memory and this is one of the worst and not so much because the team is better.

I don't have a strong opinion one way or another. I was just trying to start a discussion. Why not have the discussion?

I DO agree that the extent that we are out performing expectations is hopeful for the future but that is not what I was asking.
Last Edited: 12/31/2019 8:57:01 PM by Victory
mail
person
Victory
12/31/2019 8:49 PM
Using the final Massey rating from last year and the current Massey ratings from this year.

2020 wins: 123, 249, 290, 296, 314, 332, [2 non D1]
2020 loses: 12, 13, 50, 69, 178

2019 wins: 121, 126, 130, 179, 181, 189, 243, [1 non-D1]
2019 losses: 13, 61, 78, 119

Our worst loss this year is much, much worse than last year. Two of the losses #50 and #69 from this year to #61 and #78 from last year are pretty equivalent with a slight edge to this season. This year's team took 1 extra loss to a national championship contender with respect to last but we cannot fault them too much for that. But on the whole I think the Campbell loss makes last years set of four losses look better than this years set of 5 but it is pretty close.

This year's wins are against St. Bonaventure and then, well, mostly crap. Last year we beat three teams of that caliber, plus three more teams that finished with a similar Massey rating that we finished with last year and also posses at the moment, plus two crap wins.

It is not a HUGE difference but is anyone seriously going to argue that this year's 8-5 record is clearly better than last year's 8-4 mark?
Last Edited: 12/31/2019 8:59:10 PM by Victory
mail
OU_Country
1/2/2020 3:32 PM
Jeff McKinney wrote:expand_more
Compare the out of conference results from this year to last year. Which looks better? I would contend that last year's results were better.
I would contend the opposite. First look at our losses. All major ranked teams and a 9-3 team. Then look at rosters. To be 8-5 right now when I HOPED for 8 wins WITH A HEALTHY ROSTER makes this season a success already. You must be a Saulpologist.
Why do you have to start the name calling just because someone has a different opinion on something?

Agreed, and the anti-Saul comments are really, really old while saying more about those saying them that the man they're saying them about. They guy and his family are gone, moved on to other things. His tenure is over, and he did absolutely nothing to warrant the hate that some here still seem to like to throw his way.
mail
OU_Country
1/2/2020 3:36 PM
CA Bobcat wrote:expand_more
Well, I worked in the athletics department at Campbell for 6 years and never in a bazillion years would I have ever thought that my beloved alma mater would play the Camels let alone lose to the Camels. I really enjoyed my time at Campbell but this is a low, low tier DI program. When I was there, they played basketball games in Carter Gym which was a step down from my junior high's gym. Carter Gym seated under 1,000 and it was an absolutely horrific facility - a single men's restroom and a single women's restroom, for example. Original everything throughout the gym except for maybe the scoreboards. It was bush league in every conceivable way. Granted, they have since built a 3,500 "arena" but to think that we're anywhere near that level makes me want to vomit. We're not, I know, but I guess I'd like to think that we could suit up a manager and still compete against or beat a very average Big South team. Oh, and for the record, I am super excited about Jeff Boals and I know he'll do a great job so no offense to him or what he's already done with the team, etc. I'm just astounded we lost to Campbell - a small, rural school in Buies Creek, NC with limited resources. Yes, far more rural than Athens, Ohio and a much, much smaller budget.

For what it's worth, Ohio played Campbell last year. Also, I'll say this -- I've watched a few of their games in the last couple years on ESPN+, and the Big South Conference Tourney on the ESPN's -- that new arena they built is VERY nice looking from the TV screen. They also have the second all time (I think) leading scorer in D1 history that just graduated in the spring in Chris Clemons. Perhaps Campbell might have changed a little since you were there last?
mail
bshot44
1/2/2020 3:41 PM
Victory wrote:expand_more
Using the final Massey rating from last year and the current Massey ratings from this year.

2020 wins: 123, 249, 290, 296, 314, 332, [2 non D1]
2020 loses: 12, 13, 50, 69, 178

2019 wins: 121, 126, 130, 179, 181, 189, 243, [1 non-D1]
2019 losses: 13, 61, 78, 119

Our worst loss this year is much, much worse than last year. Two of the losses #50 and #69 from this year to #61 and #78 from last year are pretty equivalent with a slight edge to this season. This year's team took 1 extra loss to a national championship contender with respect to last but we cannot fault them too much for that. But on the whole I think the Campbell loss makes last years set of four losses look better than this years set of 5 but it is pretty close.

This year's wins are against St. Bonaventure and then, well, mostly crap. Last year we beat three teams of that caliber, plus three more teams that finished with a similar Massey rating that we finished with last year and also posses at the moment, plus two crap wins.

It is not a HUGE difference but is anyone seriously going to argue that this year's 8-5 record is clearly better than last year's 8-4 mark?
I'm not going to argue the metrics of the wins and losses ... those speak for themselves.

I have judged this season solely on the eye-test ... and I think the 2020 version of Ohio is leaps and bounds beyond the 2019 version.

I won't bore anyone with specifics ... but I'll just say I've seen this team in person four times and a handful of others on TV and they just have an energy that last year's team seemed to lack (much like the entire program if we're being honest)

And on top of it ... the 2020 team has been patchworked together for the most part.

I, for one, am excited to see what this team looks like at full strength. Get Dartis, Price, Foster, Roderick, Murrell, and Miles Brown 100% healthy ... and add that to McDay, BVP, Ogbonda, Preston, McMurray, and Springs .... and I'd like to see what that looks like come February.

I'm not sure they'll ever be 100% healthy ... but I can say, from what I've seen so far, I like the outlook of where it's headed short term and long term much, much better than I did on Jan. 1, 2019.

Yes ... the Campbell loss wasn't great. It would certainly classify as laying an egg. But considering the youth of this team and what they were missing for that game ... and, most notably, the fact it was the only one of the non-conference season .... I'm willing to give it a pass.

I didn't think in a million years Ohio would be 8-5 heading into MAC play. Outside of the Campbell game and spurts of the Morehead & Detroit games ... this team went out and took care of business against comparable competition ... and played tough for stretches against much tougher competition.

My biggest worry about them continuing to be this competitive in the MAC is A) health and B) fatigue. Are these young guys going to be out of gas come mid-February ... and can Preston continue to play at a high level 35+ minutes a night?
Last Edited: 1/2/2020 3:44:53 PM by bshot44
mail
person
Bobcat1998
1/3/2020 2:49 PM
Jeff McKinney wrote:expand_more
Compare the out of conference results from this year to last year. Which looks better? I would contend that last year's results were better.
I would contend the opposite. First look at our losses. All major ranked teams and a 9-3 team. Then look at rosters. To be 8-5 right now when I HOPED for 8 wins WITH A HEALTHY ROSTER makes this season a success already. You must be a Saulpologist.
Why do you have to start the name calling just because someone has a different opinion on something?
My bad. I apologize. You are absolutely correct. We are all Bobcats. No sarcasm here. These boards get negative enough. I appreciate your opinion as a Bobcat!!
mail
person
Bobcat1998
1/3/2020 2:55 PM
bshot44 wrote:expand_more
Using the final Massey rating from last year and the current Massey ratings from this year.

2020 wins: 123, 249, 290, 296, 314, 332, [2 non D1]
2020 loses: 12, 13, 50, 69, 178

2019 wins: 121, 126, 130, 179, 181, 189, 243, [1 non-D1]
2019 losses: 13, 61, 78, 119

Our worst loss this year is much, much worse than last year. Two of the losses #50 and #69 from this year to #61 and #78 from last year are pretty equivalent with a slight edge to this season. This year's team took 1 extra loss to a national championship contender with respect to last but we cannot fault them too much for that. But on the whole I think the Campbell loss makes last years set of four losses look better than this years set of 5 but it is pretty close.

This year's wins are against St. Bonaventure and then, well, mostly crap. Last year we beat three teams of that caliber, plus three more teams that finished with a similar Massey rating that we finished with last year and also posses at the moment, plus two crap wins.

It is not a HUGE difference but is anyone seriously going to argue that this year's 8-5 record is clearly better than last year's 8-4 mark?
I'm not going to argue the metrics of the wins and losses ... those speak for themselves.

I have judged this season solely on the eye-test ... and I think the 2020 version of Ohio is leaps and bounds beyond the 2019 version.

I won't bore anyone with specifics ... but I'll just say I've seen this team in person four times and a handful of others on TV and they just have an energy that last year's team seemed to lack (much like the entire program if we're being honest)

And on top of it ... the 2020 team has been patchworked together for the most part.

I, for one, am excited to see what this team looks like at full strength. Get Dartis, Price, Foster, Roderick, Murrell, and Miles Brown 100% healthy ... and add that to McDay, BVP, Ogbonda, Preston, McMurray, and Springs .... and I'd like to see what that looks like come February.

I'm not sure they'll ever be 100% healthy ... but I can say, from what I've seen so far, I like the outlook of where it's headed short term and long term much, much better than I did on Jan. 1, 2019.

Yes ... the Campbell loss wasn't great. It would certainly classify as laying an egg. But considering the youth of this team and what they were missing for that game ... and, most notably, the fact it was the only one of the non-conference season .... I'm willing to give it a pass.

I didn't think in a million years Ohio would be 8-5 heading into MAC play. Outside of the Campbell game and spurts of the Morehead & Detroit games ... this team went out and took care of business against comparable competition ... and played tough for stretches against much tougher competition.

My biggest worry about them continuing to be this competitive in the MAC is A) health and B) fatigue. Are these young guys going to be out of gas come mid-February ... and can Preston continue to play at a high level 35+ minutes a night?
What works in our favor is this year's MAC does not have a Buffalo of last year or even a Dambrot Kron team. Every game is winnable in my mind. BUT we need at least Dartis, Preston, BVP, Ogbonda, McDay, McMurray, Foster, and Brown/Roderick to be healthy. Springs is the best 9th man in the league!! I predict Murrell redshirt.

We could be 10-8 or 4-14. It is that kind of year. But we do have answers to preseason questions. Dartis is back. Ogbonda is Mickle with size and McDay and Foster are impactful. McMurray and Springs have been better and Preston and BVP have gone next level.
mail
person
GoCats105
1/3/2020 3:17 PM
Bobcat1998 wrote:expand_more
Using the final Massey rating from last year and the current Massey ratings from this year.

2020 wins: 123, 249, 290, 296, 314, 332, [2 non D1]
2020 loses: 12, 13, 50, 69, 178

2019 wins: 121, 126, 130, 179, 181, 189, 243, [1 non-D1]
2019 losses: 13, 61, 78, 119

Our worst loss this year is much, much worse than last year. Two of the losses #50 and #69 from this year to #61 and #78 from last year are pretty equivalent with a slight edge to this season. This year's team took 1 extra loss to a national championship contender with respect to last but we cannot fault them too much for that. But on the whole I think the Campbell loss makes last years set of four losses look better than this years set of 5 but it is pretty close.

This year's wins are against St. Bonaventure and then, well, mostly crap. Last year we beat three teams of that caliber, plus three more teams that finished with a similar Massey rating that we finished with last year and also posses at the moment, plus two crap wins.

It is not a HUGE difference but is anyone seriously going to argue that this year's 8-5 record is clearly better than last year's 8-4 mark?
I'm not going to argue the metrics of the wins and losses ... those speak for themselves.

I have judged this season solely on the eye-test ... and I think the 2020 version of Ohio is leaps and bounds beyond the 2019 version.

I won't bore anyone with specifics ... but I'll just say I've seen this team in person four times and a handful of others on TV and they just have an energy that last year's team seemed to lack (much like the entire program if we're being honest)

And on top of it ... the 2020 team has been patchworked together for the most part.

I, for one, am excited to see what this team looks like at full strength. Get Dartis, Price, Foster, Roderick, Murrell, and Miles Brown 100% healthy ... and add that to McDay, BVP, Ogbonda, Preston, McMurray, and Springs .... and I'd like to see what that looks like come February.

I'm not sure they'll ever be 100% healthy ... but I can say, from what I've seen so far, I like the outlook of where it's headed short term and long term much, much better than I did on Jan. 1, 2019.

Yes ... the Campbell loss wasn't great. It would certainly classify as laying an egg. But considering the youth of this team and what they were missing for that game ... and, most notably, the fact it was the only one of the non-conference season .... I'm willing to give it a pass.

I didn't think in a million years Ohio would be 8-5 heading into MAC play. Outside of the Campbell game and spurts of the Morehead & Detroit games ... this team went out and took care of business against comparable competition ... and played tough for stretches against much tougher competition.

My biggest worry about them continuing to be this competitive in the MAC is A) health and B) fatigue. Are these young guys going to be out of gas come mid-February ... and can Preston continue to play at a high level 35+ minutes a night?
...I predict Murrell redshirt.
Murrell isn't eligible for a redshirt as he's already used his when he transferred to Ohio. He would have to apply for a 6th year waiver and prove that he missed up to two years (I think) of competition due to injury.
mail
person
Bobcat1998
1/3/2020 4:14 PM
GoCats105 wrote:expand_more
Using the final Massey rating from last year and the current Massey ratings from this year.

2020 wins: 123, 249, 290, 296, 314, 332, [2 non D1]
2020 loses: 12, 13, 50, 69, 178

2019 wins: 121, 126, 130, 179, 181, 189, 243, [1 non-D1]
2019 losses: 13, 61, 78, 119

Our worst loss this year is much, much worse than last year. Two of the losses #50 and #69 from this year to #61 and #78 from last year are pretty equivalent with a slight edge to this season. This year's team took 1 extra loss to a national championship contender with respect to last but we cannot fault them too much for that. But on the whole I think the Campbell loss makes last years set of four losses look better than this years set of 5 but it is pretty close.

This year's wins are against St. Bonaventure and then, well, mostly crap. Last year we beat three teams of that caliber, plus three more teams that finished with a similar Massey rating that we finished with last year and also posses at the moment, plus two crap wins.

It is not a HUGE difference but is anyone seriously going to argue that this year's 8-5 record is clearly better than last year's 8-4 mark?
I'm not going to argue the metrics of the wins and losses ... those speak for themselves.

I have judged this season solely on the eye-test ... and I think the 2020 version of Ohio is leaps and bounds beyond the 2019 version.

I won't bore anyone with specifics ... but I'll just say I've seen this team in person four times and a handful of others on TV and they just have an energy that last year's team seemed to lack (much like the entire program if we're being honest)

And on top of it ... the 2020 team has been patchworked together for the most part.

I, for one, am excited to see what this team looks like at full strength. Get Dartis, Price, Foster, Roderick, Murrell, and Miles Brown 100% healthy ... and add that to McDay, BVP, Ogbonda, Preston, McMurray, and Springs .... and I'd like to see what that looks like come February.

I'm not sure they'll ever be 100% healthy ... but I can say, from what I've seen so far, I like the outlook of where it's headed short term and long term much, much better than I did on Jan. 1, 2019.

Yes ... the Campbell loss wasn't great. It would certainly classify as laying an egg. But considering the youth of this team and what they were missing for that game ... and, most notably, the fact it was the only one of the non-conference season .... I'm willing to give it a pass.

I didn't think in a million years Ohio would be 8-5 heading into MAC play. Outside of the Campbell game and spurts of the Morehead & Detroit games ... this team went out and took care of business against comparable competition ... and played tough for stretches against much tougher competition.

My biggest worry about them continuing to be this competitive in the MAC is A) health and B) fatigue. Are these young guys going to be out of gas come mid-February ... and can Preston continue to play at a high level 35+ minutes a night?
...I predict Murrell redshirt.
Murrell isn't eligible for a redshirt as he's already used his when he transferred to Ohio. He would have to apply for a 6th year waiver and prove that he missed up to two years (I think) of competition due to injury.
I wondered about that.
Showing Messages: 26 - 37 of 37



extra small (< 576px)
small (>= 576px)
medium (>= 768px)
large (>= 992px)
x-large (>= 1200px)
xx-large (>= 1400px)