Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame
7/13/2020 8:53 AM
You are right, all Pitino said was it "buys some time" for a vaccine which is correct. I'm just following that reasoning to it's logical conclusion.
Any vaccine that is created by January will not have undergone any meaningful long-term studies into it's effectiveness or safety. I'm not criticizing anyone for that, it's just the fact of the matter under the circumstances...
With that in mind, I do not really see any difference between November and January* for when the season starts. In both cases, our best case scenario is an untested, unproven vaccine, which will be significantly less effective unless EVERYONE takes it (which would require forced vaccinations which isn't realistic at all)
*cancelling OOC play makes sense to limit spread via geographic isolation so if Pitino is just talking about that and we forget the vaccine point I agree with him
NCAA players being forced to take an unsafe vaccine isn't a logical conclusion. A much more logical conclusion to reach is that Rick Pitino isn't an expert on epidemiology or vaccines, and was making the obvious point that it doesn't look like the country has this pandemic under control and more time is good. Many people use "a vaccine" as a stand in for when this is all behind us.
Further, I don't think his point is let's choose between November OR January. I think his point is that November isn't happening, but maybe pushing back to January would help. As you point out, without a serious change to how Americans approach this, January is no different than November.
Last Edited: 7/13/2020 9:58:14 AM by Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame