Frankly the whole idea of the redshirt is just farce. The scholarship is intended to aid in the earning of a degree which can and should be obtained in four years. For every kid who spends a fifth or 6th year that's a scholarship not available for the next generation. Who doesn't love having bvp or Jason Carter on our team, right? but should they really be in their 6th year of scholarship basketball? Combined that's an entire undergraduate scholarship for another person.
TBH....My athlete is the ONLY one of my 4 kids who made it through in 4 years. Outside of him I know very few kids these day s who can get their offerings and classes in sequence that they can get out in 4 years. I KNOW he would have taken a redshirt in a heartbeat had it been available. I don't think saying a "degree can and should be obtained in 4 years" is always realistic given the way colleges seem to be set up to run (and make money) these days.
How did you come to your views of the scholarship and redshirt? I am truly interested in this view
At the risk of sounding naive about the way things work in D1 college athletics, we just need to ask ourselves what is the purpose of a scholarship? I understand that injuries and hardship happen, and if those things truly affect a person's ability to complete their degree on time, then of course such an exception should be made. But the idea that someone gets a 5th year because they were deemed not good enough to play yet? Well, that's why you have four years. Take coaching, practice hard and earn your way into the rotation. That's why you have more scholarships than players actually on the field at a given time. I'm very much in favor of athletic scholarships and the accompanying opportunity, but when is enough enough? If someone can't complete their degree in four years because of basketball, that means that there is too much time devoted to basketball/football or whatever else and that commitment should be dialed back via regulation. Athletes also have tutors, special study facilities, summer sessions to catch up or whatever. This is all good stuff. However, that brings me to my second question... What is the purpose of a redshirt year? What does it actually accomplish? is it so someone can improve their chances of becoming a pro? Is it to help make the NBA/NFL execs have easier decisions on more seasoned players? Again, my naivete on full display, that's not really the purpose of college athletics. Has any coach ever said to a player "I want you to take a redshirt year to ensure you'll complete your degree"? No, it's a decision based almost solely on the player's current ability.
Last Edited: 2/12/2022 12:16:57 PM by Deciduous Forest Cat